Lesson 4 of 8 / Climate, biodiversity and disease ecology
Coral reefs, seagrass and an acidifying ocean
Why is rising carbon dioxide a double threat to coral reefs?
I can explain heat stress on coral, seagrass and mangrove ecosystems, and ocean acidification.
I can explain environmental and ecosystem consequences of climate change.Syllabus
Syllabus 9477, Extension B(b). Explain environmental and ecosystem consequences of climate change.
I can discuss effects on habitats, food chains and ecological niches.Syllabus
Syllabus 9477, Extension B(f). Discuss effects on habitats, food chains and ecological niches.
About 6 min
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater. Could this slow coral growth even if the water does not warm?
Show the answer
It can, because the water chemistry changes.
Dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid. Its hydrogen ions use up the carbonate ions that corals need for their calcium carbonate skeletons.
The key idea
Rising carbon dioxide harms reefs twice: warmer water makes corals bleach, and dissolved carbon dioxide lowers ocean pH, so skeletons grow more slowly.
Trace the biological links
What does heat do to the coral partnership?
Algae living in the coral tissue photosynthesise and pass sugars to the coral.
Explanation
Reef-building corals live in a mutualism with tiny algae inside their tissue. A mutualism is a partnership that benefits both. The algae photosynthesise and pass sugars to the coral, which gives them shelter and raw materials for photosynthesis.
When the sea stays too warm for too long, the partnership breaks down and the coral expels most of its algae. The coral turns white: this is coral bleaching. A bleached coral is still alive but has lost most of its food supply. It can recover if the water cools soon, but it can die if the heat lasts.
Seagrass meadows and mangroves are also stressed by heat, flooding by rising seas, changes in salinity (saltiness) and storms. These habitats are nurseries for young fish, so their loss harms the animals that feed or shelter there.
Rising CO2 also changes ocean chemistry. Carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater and reacts with water to form carbonic acid. This releases hydrogen ions, so the pH of the ocean falls. This is ocean acidification.
Many of the extra hydrogen ions combine with carbonate ions to form hydrogencarbonate ions, so less carbonate is left. Corals, molluscs and some plankton build skeletons and shells from calcium carbonate. With less carbonate, they calcify more slowly, and existing structures can start to dissolve.
A reef that is bleached by heat and calcifies slowly grows more slowly than it is worn away, so fish lose shelter and food. Seawater stays slightly alkaline: acidification means its pH is falling, not that the sea has become an acid.
Step by step
- 1
Separate the two threats
Heat causes bleaching; dissolved CO2 causes acidification.
- 2
Follow the chemistry
Carbonic acid, hydrogen ions, fewer carbonate ions.
- 3
Link it to the habitat
Slower reef growth means less shelter and food for other species.
Worked example
Work through the evidence
Two tanks of coral are kept at the same temperature. Extra carbon dioxide is bubbled through one of them. Predict the difference after some months.
One way to explain it
The coral in the high-CO2 tank builds its skeleton more slowly. Dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid, and the hydrogen ions use up carbonate ions, so less calcium carbonate is laid down.
Why this answer works
- The temperature is the same, so any difference comes from the water chemistry.
- Bleaching is a heat response, so this design tests acidification alone.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Ocean acidification happens because warmer water is more acidic." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
It happens because dissolved carbon dioxide forms carbonic acid; it would happen even if the water did not warm.
In the real world
The Great Barrier Reef, 2016
Record sea temperatures in 2015-2016 caused coral bleaching across the tropics. On the Great Barrier Reef, the pattern of bleaching in 1998, 2002 and 2016 followed the pattern of hot water each year. Water quality and fishing pressure had little effect on the unprecedented bleaching of 2016, suggesting that local protection gives reefs little or no resistance to extreme heat.
Source: Hughes and others (2017), Global warming and recurrent mass bleaching of corals, Nature 543, 373-377
Check your understanding
Why do corals in more acidic seawater build their skeletons more slowly?
Show the answer
Hydrogen ions combine with carbonate ions, leaving less carbonate to make calcium carbonate.
Fewer carbonate ions are available for calcification.
Quick recall
Why is rising carbon dioxide a double threat to coral reefs?