Lesson 8 of 8 / Movement of substances
Percentage change, significant figures and anomalous results
How do you calculate a percentage change that keeps every mark?
I can calculate percentage change to 3 significant figures with its sign, and deal with an anomalous result.
I can explain osmosis, tissue responses and investigations.Syllabus
Syllabus K325, Topic 2(b). Osmosis, tissue responses and investigations.
About 4 min
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A potato strip goes from 5.00 g to 4.00 g. What is its percentage change in mass?
Show the answer
-20%
The change is -1.00 g. Divide by the original 5.00 g: -1.00 / 5.00 x 100 = -20%.
The key idea
Divide the change by the original value, keep the plus or minus sign, and round to 3 significant figures only at the end.
This is the carrot graph from the last lesson. Choose the last move, "Anomaly", to see one repeat that breaks the pattern.
Explore the idea
What does a full-mark description of this graph say?
Illustrative results: invented for this activity
Move 1: DirectionStart with the overall direction: as sucrose concentration increases, the percentage mass change decreases.
Units appear in every quoted value. A "describe" answer stops here; a "describe and explain" answer then gives the osmosis reason for each range.
Explanation
Percentage change compares a change with the starting value. Percentage change = (new value - original value) / original value x 100. The original value is always the denominator. A carrot cylinder that falls from 2.45 g to 2.12 g has changed by (2.12 - 2.45) / 2.45 x 100 = -13.5%. Dividing by the final mass instead gives -15.6%, which is wrong.
Keep the sign. A minus sign shows a decrease and a plus sign shows an increase. Without the sign, the reader cannot tell which way the mass changed.
Significant figures (s.f.) count digits from the first non-zero digit. Many papers ask for answers to 3 significant figures. -13.469% to 3 s.f. is -13.5%. -10% to 3 s.f. is written -10.0%, because the final zero counts. Round only at the end of a calculation, not at each step.
An anomalous result is a reading that does not fit the pattern shown by the other results. Repeats show anomalies clearly. Suppose three repeats at one concentration are -1.0%, -1.4% and +4.6%. The +4.6% reading does not fit, so leave it out and give the mean of the other two, -1.2%. Then repeat that reading. Call a result anomalous only when you can point to the pattern it breaks.
Step by step
- 1
Find the change
Subtract the original value from the new value. A fall gives a negative change.
- 2
Divide by the original
Put the original value, not the final value, on the bottom of the fraction. Then multiply by 100.
- 3
Round once, at the end
Give 3 significant figures unless the question says otherwise. Keep the sign and the % unit.
- 4
Check the repeats
Leave out a repeat that breaks the pattern of the others before you calculate the mean.
Worked example
A beetroot disc that gains mass
A beetroot disc has a mass of 3.26 g before and 3.61 g after soaking in water. Calculate the percentage change in mass to 3 significant figures.
One way to explain it
(3.61 - 3.26) / 3.26 x 100 = +10.736...%, which is +10.7% to 3 significant figures. The plus sign shows a gain in mass.
Why this answer works
- The change is +0.35 g.
- The original mass, 3.26 g, is the denominator.
- Round only the final answer. Keep the sign and the % unit.
Watch out for this
A student says: "In a percentage change, you divide the change by the final value." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
A percentage change compares the change with the starting value, so the original value is the denominator. For 2.45 g to 2.12 g, dividing by 2.12 g gives -15.6% instead of -13.5%.
Check your understanding
Three repeats at one sucrose concentration give mass changes of -6.1%, -5.9% and +2.4%. Which mean should be recorded?
Show the answer
-6.0%, leaving out the +2.4% reading.
+2.4% is a gain while the other two are losses close to -6%, so it is anomalous. The mean of -6.1% and -5.9% is -6.0%. Repeat the odd reading.
Quick recall
How do you calculate a percentage change that keeps every mark?