K325 / 2027

Lesson 4 of 11 / Biological molecules

Comparing and recording food test results

How much can one colour tell you?

I can use Benedict's colours to rank samples fairly, use controls to check a test, and record the observation in full.

  • I can describe and interpret tests for starch, reducing sugars, protein and fat.Syllabus

    Syllabus K325, Topic 3(c). Describe and interpret tests for starch, reducing sugars, protein and fat.

About 4 min

Make a guess. You are not marked.

One fruit juice gives a brick-red precipitate in Benedict's test and another gives a green one. Can you say exactly how much sugar each juice has?

  1. Yes. Each colour stands for one fixed concentration.
  2. No. The colours only rank the juices.
  3. No. The colours show different sugars, not amounts.
Show the answer

No. The colours only rank the juices.

Brick-red shows more reducing sugar than green, but the test gives no exact amount. It is semi-quantitative.

The key idea

Benedict's colours rank samples by reducing sugar only when every tube is treated the same way. Controls show that the test itself worked.

A semi-quantitative test ranks samples as having more or less of a substance, without giving an exact amount. A control is a tube with a known result that is tested in the same way as the samples.

Explore the idea

Four tubes, one water bath

Same volumes, same water bath, 5 minutes.

Benedict's test results for two controls and two juicesFour test tubes after heating. Water stays blue. Glucose solution gives a brick-red precipitate. Juice A gives a green precipitate. Juice B gives an orange precipitate.WaterBlueGlucosesolutionBrick-redJuiceAGreenJuiceBOrange

Water (negative control): stays blue. No reducing sugar. Benedict's solution does not change colour on its own.

Illustrative results, not a simulated experiment.

Explanation

In Benedict's test, the colour depends on how much precipitate forms, so it shows roughly how much reducing sugar a sample holds. Green shows a trace, yellow a small amount, orange a moderate amount and brick-red a large amount.

The ranking is fair only if every tube is treated the same way. Use the same volumes of sample and Benedict's solution, and heat all the tubes in the same water bath for the same time. More sample or longer heating can form more precipitate without a more concentrated sugar solution.

Controls show whether the reagents and the method work. Water is the negative control: it should stay blue. A known glucose solution is the positive control: it should give a precipitate. For the iodine test, use a known starch solution. If the glucose control stays blue, the Benedict's solution or the heating failed. If the starch control stays yellow-brown, the iodine failed. A negative result from a food then proves nothing.

A result describes the sample at the time of the test. Starch alone stays blue in Benedict's test. After the enzyme amylase digests the starch into maltose, a reducing sugar, the mixture gives a coloured precipitate.

Record a positive result as a colour and a precipitate, such as "a brick-red precipitate forms". A common practical-exam slip is writing only "the mixture turns brick-red". The precipitate is the evidence that reducing sugar reacted. Give the observation first, then the conclusion.

The test is named after Stanley Benedict, an American chemist who published it in 1909. It can also detect glucose in urine, but doctors do not rely on it to diagnose disease.

Step by step
  1. 1

    Treat every tube the same

    Equal volumes of sample and Benedict's solution, the same water bath and the same heating time.

  2. 2

    Check the controls

    Water should stay blue. A known glucose solution should give a precipitate.

  3. 3

    Rank, record, conclude

    Order the samples by colour. Write the colour and the word precipitate, then what it shows.

Worked example

Rank three fruit juices

Equal volumes of three juices are heated with equal volumes of Benedict's solution in the same water bath for 5 minutes. Juice A gives a green precipitate, juice B brick-red and juice C orange. A water control stays blue. Rank the juices by reducing sugar content and explain why the ranking is fair.

One way to explain it

Juice B has the most reducing sugar, then juice C, then juice A. The ranking is fair because the volumes, heating time and temperature were the same for every tube. The water control stayed blue, so the colours came from the juices. The test does not show an exact concentration.

Why this answer works
  • Brick-red shows a large amount, orange a moderate amount and green a trace.
  • The same volumes and heating make the colours comparable.
  • A ranking is not a measurement, so no concentration can be stated.

Watch out for this

A student says: "A brick-red result means the food has twice as much sugar as an orange result." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

The colours only put samples in order. Benedict's test is semi-quantitative, so it cannot give a ratio or an exact concentration.

Check your understanding

Two drinks are tested with Benedict's solution. Drink X gives an orange precipitate and drink Y a green precipitate. X was heated for 5 minutes and Y for 1 minute. What can you conclude?

  1. Both contain reducing sugar, but the amounts cannot be compared fairly.
  2. Y contains no reducing sugar, because it did not turn orange or brick-red.
  3. X contains more reducing sugar than Y.
  4. Y contains starch in place of reducing sugar.
Show the answer

Both contain reducing sugar, but the amounts cannot be compared fairly.

Any coloured precipitate shows reducing sugar. Y was heated for less time, so its green colour may come from the shorter heating and not from less sugar.

Exam-style questions

Check your understanding

A starch solution stays blue when heated with Benedict's solution. A student adds amylase to more of the same starch solution and waits 10 minutes. A sample of this mixture now gives a brick-red precipitate when heated with Benedict's solution. Why?

  1. Starch is a reducing sugar that needs ten minutes to react.
  2. The first test was not heated, so its blue result was wrong.
  3. Amylase digested the starch into maltose, a reducing sugar.
  4. Amylase is a reducing sugar, so it reacted with Benedict's solution.
Show the answer

Amylase digested the starch into maltose, a reducing sugar.

Starch is not a reducing sugar, so the first test stayed blue. Amylase breaks starch down into maltose, which reacts with Benedict's solution when heated.

Quick recall

Card 1 of 3. Answer in your head, then check.

How much can one colour tell you?

You can return to this lesson any time.