Full chapter
Energy
All 5 topics and the revision summary on one page.
01
Energy stores and transfers
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A ball is thrown straight upwards. At the top of its flight, which energy store has gained energy compared with the moment it left the hand?
Show the answer
The gravitational potential store, while the kinetic store has fallen.
As the ball rises, its kinetic store empties into the gravitational potential store of the ball and Earth. At the top it is momentarily at rest, so nearly all the energy is in the gravitational store.
In short
- Energy is held in stores such as kinetic, gravitational potential, chemical, elastic and internal.
- Energy is transferred by forces, electric currents, heating and waves.
- Energy is never created or destroyed; the total stays the same.
To explain an energy change, name the objects, the stores that change and the pathway that transfers the energy.
A battery-powered motor raises a load. The battery's chemical store goes down, and the gravitational store of the load and Earth goes up. Energy reaches the motor electrically. It then reaches the rising load mechanically, through the lifting force.
Energy is measured in joules, J. A store is energy that an object or system has because of its state. The state is how it moves, where it is or what it is made of. A transfer pathway is the way energy moves from one store to another. An energy account can cover more than one object. For gravitational energy, treat the load and Earth as one system.
A battery supplies a motor that lifts a load
This simplified steady lift ignores transfers to internal stores. The arrows label energy-transfer pathways.
The Singapore Flyer, 165 m tall, shows the same pattern. Its motors get energy electrically. As the wheel turns, each capsule that rises gains gravitational potential energy.
Recognise the store from the physical situation
- Kinetic
- Energy an object has because it moves. A moving trolley has kinetic energy. If it slows down, this store decreases.
- Gravitational potential
- Energy that depends on where masses are in a gravitational field. Lifting a load near Earth increases the gravitational store of the load-Earth system. Choose a reference height before you give a value.
- Chemical
- Energy held in the chemical make-up of substances. A battery, food or fuel can supply energy when chemical reactions change the substances.
- Elastic potential
- Energy held in an object that is stretched or compressed. Stretching a spring increases its elastic store. It can transfer energy as it goes back towards its first shape.
- Nuclear
- Energy held in the nuclei of atoms. Changes in nuclei can release energy from nuclear stores, as when nuclear fuel undergoes fission.
- Internal
- Energy that comes from the motion of the particles in a substance and the forces between them. A warmer metal block usually has more internal energy than the same block when it is cooler and in the same state.
Gravitational, chemical and elastic stores are examples of potential energy stores. One object may have more than one store. A warm trolley that moves has both kinetic energy and internal energy. Choose the stores whose changes matter in the question.
Four ways energy is transferred
- Mechanically, by a force acting over a distance. A string pulls a load upwards as it moves upwards. The force transfers energy to the load-Earth gravitational store. If nothing moves in the direction of the force, the force transfers no energy mechanically.
- Electrically, by an electric current. A battery supplies energy to a motor through a circuit. In an electric heater, an electrical transfer raises internal energy. Call the current the pathway. Do not invent an extra store called "electricity".
- By heating, because of a temperature difference. A hot metal block touching a cooler block transfers energy to it. The hotter block's internal store goes down and the cooler block's goes up. Heat is a transfer, not a substance stored inside an object.
- By waves, both electromagnetic and mechanical. Sunlight is an electromagnetic wave: a surface that absorbs it can gain internal energy. Sound is a mechanical wave that travels through a medium such as air: it can make a membrane vibrate when it arrives. The energy travels with the wave. The medium itself does not travel from the source to the receiver.
Some descriptions overlap. Energy carried by infrared waves from a hotter object to a cooler one is also a transfer by heating. Count that amount once in the energy account.
Include the surroundings
When a sliding trolley slows because of friction, its kinetic store goes down. The internal stores of the trolley, track and surroundings go up. If you say the energy is "lost" and do not say where it went, the account is not complete.
Energy cannot be created or destroyed. It can be transferred between stores. If no energy enters or leaves the system you are looking at, its total energy stays constant. If energy crosses the edge of the system, count that transfer when you compare the stores at the start and at the end.
Keep stores and pathways apart. Chemical and internal are stores. Mechanically, electrically, heating and waves are transfers. A full answer names what changes and how the energy is transferred.
Check your understanding
A loudspeaker makes a nearby thin membrane vibrate without touching it. Which description identifies the transfer between them?
Show the answer
Energy is transferred by sound, a mechanical wave travelling through the air.
The sound wave transfers energy through the air and can make the membrane move. Sound describes a transfer by waves, rather than an extra store inside the membrane.
02
Kinetic and gravitational energy
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A car speeds up from 10 m/s to 20 m/s. What happens to its kinetic energy?
Show the answer
It becomes four times as large, because it depends on speed squared.
Kinetic energy is 1/2 m v2, so doubling the speed squares to a factor of four. The 20 m/s car has four times the kinetic energy.
In short
- Kinetic energy: Ek = 1/2 m v2.
- Gain in gravitational potential energy: Ep = mgh, using the vertical height.
- Doubling the speed gives four times the kinetic energy.
Kinetic energy depends on mass and speed. A change in gravitational potential energy near Earth depends on mass and vertical height change.
Use mass in kg, speed in m/s and height in m. Gravitational field strength g is measured in N/kg. Review unit conversions before substituting.
Worked example
A moving 2.0 kg object
At a speed of 4.0 m/s:
Ek = 0.5 x 2.0 x 4.02 = 0.5 x 2.0 x 16 = 16 J.
At 8.0 m/s, the same mass has Ek = 0.5 x 2.0 x 64 = 64 J. Doubling the speed makes the kinetic energy four times as large.
Try it step by step
Work it out in steps: Speed in m/s, then Speed squared in m2/s2, then Kinetic energy in J.
Show the answer
Problem 1.
Speed in m/s: v = 54 x 1000 / 3600 = 15 m/s
Speed squared in m2/s2: v2 = 15 x 15 = 225 m2/s2
Kinetic energy in J: Ek = 1/2 m v2 = 0.5 x 800 x 225 = 90000 J, which is 90 kJ (2 sf)
Problem 2.
Speed in m/s: v = 72 x 1000 / 3600 = 20 m/s
Speed squared in m2/s2: v2 = 20 x 20 = 400 m2/s2
Kinetic energy in J: Ek = 0.5 x 1200 x 400 = 240000 J, which is 240 kJ (2 sf)
Problem 3.
Speed in m/s: v = 36 x 1000 / 3600 = 10 m/s
Speed squared in m2/s2: v2 = 10 x 10 = 100 m2/s2
Kinetic energy in J: Ek = 0.5 x 60 x 100 = 3000 J (2 sf)
- At fixed speed, doubling the mass doubles kinetic energy.
- At fixed mass, doubling speed multiplies kinetic energy by four; halving speed makes it one quarter.
- The direction of motion does not change this calculation. Use speed, and give energy in J without a spatial direction.
Use a vertical height change
Raising a mass increases the gravitational store of the mass-Earth system; lowering it decreases the store. The numerical value Ep = mgh is measured relative to a chosen zero-height level. Changing that reference changes the assigned value, but not the energy change between the same two positions.
Worked example
Raise a load through 1.5 m
A total mass of 2.0 kg is raised vertically by 1.5 m. Use g = 10 N/kg.
Increase in Ep = 2.0 x 10 x 1.5 = 30 J.
Its weight is mg = 20 N. Lifting it to the same height along a longer ramp still increases the gravitational store by 30 J. Extra transfers due to friction would change the input required, not this gravitational change.
At fixed m and g, doubling the vertical rise doubles the gravitational store increase. At fixed rise and g, doubling the mass also doubles the increase. If the same load descends by 1.5 m, the store decreases by 30 J.
The summit of Bukit Timah Hill, Singapore's highest natural point, is about 164 m above sea level. Compared with sea level, a 50 kg student on the summit has 50 x 10 x 164 = 82 000 J more gravitational potential energy. The value is the same whichever trail the student took.
Rearrange for the quantity asked for
If the height change is unknown, h = change in Ep / (mg). For the 2.0 kg load, a 30 J increase at g = 10 N/kg gives h = 30 / (2.0 x 10) = 1.5 m.
If speed is unknown, first rearrange to v2 = 2Ek / m, then take the square root. Do not treat the value of v2 as the speed.
Try it step by step
Work it out in steps: Weight mg in N, then Height h = Ep / (mg) in m.
Show the answer
Problem 1.
Weight mg in N: mg = 3.0 x 10 = 30 N
Height h = Ep / (mg) in m: h = 450 / 30 = 15 m (2 sf)
Problem 2.
Weight mg in N: mg = 8.0 x 10 = 80 N
Height h = Ep / (mg) in m: h = 960 / 80 = 12 m (2 sf)
Problem 3.
Weight mg in N: mg = 5.0 x 10 = 50 N
Height h = Ep / (mg) in m: h = 275 / 50 = 5.5 m (2 sf)
Height is not route length. Identify the starting and final vertical levels before using mgh. For kinetic energy, identify the speed at the instant being considered and square it.
Check your understanding
A 0.50 kg load is taken up a ramp of length 2.0 m. Its final position is 0.80 m vertically above its starting position. Use g = 10 N/kg. What is its increase in gravitational potential energy?
Show the answer
4.0 J
Use the vertical rise, 0.80 m: increase = mgh = 0.50 x 10 x 0.80 = 4.0 J. The route taken does not change this store increase.
03
Work done by a force
In short
- Work done = force x distance moved in the direction of the force, W = Fd.
- Work done equals the energy transferred, in J.
- A force does no work if nothing moves in its direction.
A force does work when it moves an object in the direction of the force. The work done is the energy that the force transfers.
Kinetic energy is 1/2 mv2; a gravitational change is mgh. These describe stores. The work done by a force describes a transfer.
W = FdW = work in J; F = force in N; d = distance in m along the force. Apply this relationship to a constant force and the movement along its direction.
Work done may be written W or E, since it is energy transferred. Here W means work in joules. In W = mg, W instead means weight in newtons; after a power value, such as 60 W, W is the unit watt. Read the quantity and unit together.
Worked example
A 12 N pull through 3.0 m
A constant force of 12 N acts on a body while it moves 3.0 m along the force's direction.
Work done by the force = 12 x 3.0 = 36 J.
This tells us the mechanical transfer by that force. To say that the kinetic store increases by 36 J, we must also establish that no other transfer or store change takes part. For example, friction could transfer some of the input to internal stores.
A force can act without doing work on the object
- Pushing a stationary wall: the wall does not move, so the work done on it by the push is zero.
- Supporting a load during purely horizontal motion: the upward support is perpendicular to the movement. There is no distance moved in that force's direction, so its work on the load is zero.
These statements concern the specified force and object. They do not mean that a person's body transfers no energy internally while pushing or supporting.
Weightlifting shows both cases. At the Tokyo Olympics, held in 2021, Lasha Talakhadze lifted a 265 kg barbell from the floor to above his head. The barbell weighs 2650 N. If it rose about 2 m, he did about 2650 x 2 = 5300 J of work on it. While he held it still, he did no more work on it, because it did not move.
For the 2.0 kg load lifted at constant speed through 1.5 m, take g = 10 N/kg and neglect losses. The lifting force balances its 20 N weight, so the lift does 20 x 1.5 = 30 J of work. That equals the 30 J gravitational store increase; the speed is unchanged, so kinetic energy is unchanged.
Work tells you how much energy one force transfers. Conservation of energy shows where all the energy goes.
Use the distance moved along the force. Do not multiply by a distance at right angles to the force, and do not multiply by time. The weight of a bag carried along a level floor does no work, however far the bag goes.
Check your understanding
A shopper pushes a trolley 20 m along a level floor with a horizontal force of 30 N. The loaded trolley weighs 400 N. Which of these is the work done by the push?
Show the answer
600 J, from 30 N x 20 m.
Work done = force x distance moved in the direction of the force. The push is horizontal and the trolley moves 20 m horizontally, so W = 30 x 20 = 600 J.
Check your understanding
A weightlifter holds a barbell still above his head for 3 s. Which of these describes the work he does on the barbell during those 3 s?
Show the answer
Zero, because the barbell does not move in the direction of his force.
Work done = force x distance moved in the direction of the force. His upward force is large, but the distance moved is zero, so no work is done on the barbell.
04
Conservation of energy
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Two balls of equal mass are released from rest at the same height. One falls straight down. The other slides down a smooth curved track to the same level. Air resistance and friction are negligible. Which ball is moving faster when it reaches the lower level?
Show the answer
Both reach the same speed, because they drop the same height.
Each ball loses the same gravitational potential energy, mgh, and with no friction all of it becomes kinetic energy. Same mass, same kinetic energy, same speed.
In short
- Energy cannot be created or destroyed. It is only transferred between stores.
- With no air resistance, a falling object's loss in Ep equals its gain in Ek.
- With friction or air resistance, some energy goes to internal stores. The total stays the same.
Energy cannot be created or destroyed. It can only be transferred from one store to another, so the total stays the same.
Kinetic energy is 1/2 mv2; a gravitational change is mgh. Work done by a force is one way energy is transferred.
Conservation is an account of the whole change
The principle of conservation of energy states that energy cannot be created or destroyed. For an isolated system, the total energy remains constant. More generally:
= final energy + energy transferred outChoose the objects included in the system and the same start and end points for every term. Do not count a transfer twice.
If no energy enters or leaves the system and only kinetic and gravitational stores change, their total remains constant. These are model assumptions, not a rule that air resistance or friction must be absent from every real situation.
Account for the initial 9.0 J throughout the fall
A 0.50 kg object is released from rest at height 1.8 m; g = 10 N/kg. First, take the object and Earth as the system, with negligible air resistance and no other store changes.
Ep: gravitational energy of the object and Earth
Ek: kinetic energy of the object
Released from rest: h = 1.8 m
During the fall: h = 0.80 m
At the chosen zero height: h = 0 m
The zero-height level sets the gravitational reference. The last bar is before any impact.
Separate case: resistance increases internal stores
Start with the same 9.0 J. Now include the object, Earth and surrounding air in the account. At zero height, internal stores have increased by 2.0 J.
2.0 J is the increase in internal energy of the object and surroundings.
Worked example
Find the speed during a fall
A 0.50 kg body is released from rest 1.8 m above the chosen zero-height level. Use g = 10 N/kg. Neglect air resistance and all other store changes, and consider the body just before it reaches that level, before any impact.
- Initial account: Ek = 0 because it starts from rest. Ep = 0.50 x 10 x 1.8 = 9.0 J.
- At zero height: Ep = 0, so conservation gives Ek = 9.0 J.
- Use the kinetic-energy equation: 9.0 = 0.5 x 0.50 x v2, so v2 = 36 and v = 6.0 m/s.
At a height of 0.80 m, the remaining gravitational energy is 0.50 x 10 x 0.80 = 4.0 J. The kinetic energy is 9.0 - 4.0 = 5.0 J. Then v2 = (2 x 5.0) / 0.50 = 20, giving v = about 4.5 m/s.
Try it step by step
Work it out in steps: Gravitational potential energy lost in J, then Kinetic energy gained in J, then Speed in m/s.
Show the answer
Problem 1.
Gravitational potential energy lost in J: Ep lost = mgh = 0.20 x 10 x 3.2 = 6.4 J
Kinetic energy gained in J: No other store changes, so Ek gained = 6.4 J
Speed in m/s: 6.4 = 0.5 x 0.20 x v2, so v2 = 64 and v = 8.0 m/s (2 sf)
Problem 2.
Gravitational potential energy lost in J: Ep lost = 2.0 x 10 x 1.25 = 25 J
Kinetic energy gained in J: Smooth slope, so Ek gained = 25 J
Speed in m/s: 25 = 0.5 x 2.0 x v2, so v2 = 25 and v = 5.0 m/s (2 sf)
Problem 3.
Gravitational potential energy lost in J: Ep lost = 0.50 x 10 x 0.45 = 2.25 J
Kinetic energy gained in J: Ek gained = 2.25 J
Speed in m/s: 2.25 = 0.5 x 0.50 x v2, so v2 = 9.0 and v = 3.0 m/s (2 sf)
A diver who steps off the 10 m platform at the OCBC Aquatic Centre loses mgh and gains 1/2 mv2. With air resistance neglected, v2 = 2 x 10 x 10 = 200, so v is about 14 m/s. The mass cancels, so every diver reaches the water at about this speed.
Include a transfer to internal stores
Now keep the same starting conditions. Suppose 2.0 J has gone to internal stores of the body and the nearby air by the time the body reaches zero height. Its final kinetic energy is 9.0 - 2.0 = 7.0 J.
The speed follows from v2 = (2 x 7.0) / 0.50 = 28, giving about 5.3 m/s. It is smaller than 6.0 m/s because less energy remains in the kinetic store.
The final account is 7.0 J kinetic + 2.0 J internal increase = 9.0 J. The total has not decreased. Expanding the system to include the surroundings explains the destination of energy that has left the body's mechanical stores.
State the conditions before equating two stores. Starting from rest, negligible air resistance and an unchanged set of other stores justify Ep lost = Ek gained here. If a condition changes, change the account.
Check your understanding
A 0.50 kg body is released from rest 1.8 m above a chosen zero-height level. Use g = 10 N/kg. By the time it reaches that level, 2.0 J has increased internal stores. No other energy changes occur. What is its final kinetic energy?
Show the answer
7.0 J
Initial energy = 0.50 x 10 x 1.8 = 9.0 J. The final account is 9.0 = Ek + 2.0, so Ek = 7.0 J. Total energy is conserved.
05
Power and measurements
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Two motors each lift the same 20 kg load through the same 2.0 m. Motor A takes 4 s. Motor B takes 8 s. Which motor transfers more energy to the gravitational store?
Show the answer
Both transfer the same energy, because the load and height match.
The gain in gravitational potential energy is mgh, which is the same load through the same height. Motor A has twice the power, not twice the energy.
In short
- Power is the rate of energy transfer: P = E / t, in W.
- 1 W means 1 J transferred each second.
- A more powerful motor does the same job in less time.
Power is the rate of energy transfer. The same energy transfer can happen quickly or slowly.
Energy and work are measured in J. Time is measured in s. A power calculation needs both the amount transferred and the time taken for that transfer.
P = E / tP = average power in watts, W; E = energy transferred in J; t = elapsed time in s. 1 W = 1 J/s.
The watt is named after James Watt (1736 to 1819), the Scottish engineer known for improving the steam engine. A 2000 W kettle transfers 2000 J every second.
Same energy transfer, different times
Each motor transfers 240 J. The energy bars use one common scale; the time bars use a separate common scale.
Motor A: 240 J in 8.0 s
Average power = 240 J / 8.0 s = 30 W.
Motor B: 240 J in 4.0 s
Average power = 240 J / 4.0 s = 60 W.
Transferring the same energy in half the time gives twice the average power.
Worked comparison
The same transfer in half the time
- Motor A: P = 240 / 8.0 = 30 W.
- Motor B: P = 240 / 4.0 = 60 W.
B transfers the energy twice as quickly. It does not transfer twice as much energy in this comparison: both amounts are 240 J.
Try it step by step
Work it out in steps: Energy transferred mgh in J, then Power P = E / t in W.
Show the answer
Problem 1.
Energy transferred mgh in J: E = mgh = 40 x 10 x 2.5 = 1000 J
Power P = E / t in W: P = 1000 / 5.0 = 200 W (2 sf)
Problem 2.
Energy transferred mgh in J: E = 60 x 10 x 3.0 = 1800 J
Power P = E / t in W: P = 1800 / 12 = 150 W (2 sf)
Problem 3.
Energy transferred mgh in J: E = 25 x 10 x 4.0 = 1000 J
Power P = E / t in W: P = 1000 / 8.0 = 125 W (3 sf)
Rearrange to E = Pt when power and time are given, or t = E / P when the transfer amount and power are given. For example, transferring 240 J at a constant 60 W takes 240 / 60 = 4.0 s. Convert minutes to seconds and kilowatts to watts before combining with joules.
If the rate changes during the interval, total energy divided by total elapsed time gives the average power. It does not show how the rate varied at each instant.
Determine useful lifting power from measurements
A motor steadily raises a load. Its intended output is the increase in the load-Earth gravitational store. Measure that store change and the time over the same part of the lift.
- Measure total lifted mass: include the load and its hanger. Record mass in kg; for example, 500 g = 0.500 kg.
- Mark two vertical levels: use a fixed point on the load to identify its start and end positions. Measure their vertical separation h, not the length of a sloping string.
- Time the marked interval: start as the chosen point passes the lower mark and stop at the upper mark. Use the steady part of the lift so the load's kinetic energy does not change over the interval.
- Calculate the output: use the supplied g to find mgh, then divide by the corresponding time.
| Quantity | Value |
|---|---|
| Total lifted mass / kg | 0.500 |
| Vertical rise / m | 0.80 |
| Time for that rise / s | 2.0 |
| Supplied g / N/kg | 10 |
The intended energy increase is mgh = 0.500 x 10 x 0.80 = 4.0 J. Average useful lifting power = 4.0 / 2.0 = 2.0 W.
This method determines the rate at which the gravitational store increases. It does not determine the motor's total electrical input power: energy can also increase internal stores. The input requires a separate measurement.
Link improvements to a specific measurement
- Repeat timings for the same mass, rise and operating conditions to estimate random variation. A longer suitable steady interval can make reaction time a smaller fraction of the measured time.
- Keep the ruler vertical and use the same point on the load at both marks. Overestimating h makes the calculated energy and output power too large.
- Keep the timing interval matched to those height marks. Timing extra motion outside the measured rise makes t too large and the calculated power too small.
- Including the hanger matters: omitting part of the lifted mass makes the calculated gravitational change too small.
Repeated readings do not repair an incorrect height reference or a systematically mismatched timing interval. Correct the method causing that error.
Keep the unit attached to the claim. J describes an energy amount. W describes an amount per second. A high power alone does not establish a large total transfer.
Check your understanding
A motor steadily lifts a total mass of 2.0 kg through a vertical height of 1.5 m in 6.0 s. Use g = 10 N/kg. What can these measurements determine?
Show the answer
Its useful lifting output power is 5.0 W.
The intended gravitational store increase is mgh = 30 J. Dividing by 6.0 s gives 5.0 J/s = 5.0 W of useful lifting output. These measurements do not measure the motor's electrical input.
Revision summary
Choose the quantity before calculating
- Kinetic energy
- Ek = 1/2 mv2. Use m in kg and speed v in m/s; the result is J. Doubling speed gives four times the energy at fixed mass.
- Gravitational energy change
- Change = mgh. h is vertical height change, not path length. Use an approximately constant g in N/kg near Earth and a stated zero level for Ep.
- Mechanical transfer
- Work W (also written E) = Fd, where d is the distance moved in the constant force's direction. N x m gives J. Distinguish work W in J from weight W in N and the unit watt W. No displacement in that direction means no work by that force on that object.
- Rate of transfer
- Average P = E / t; E = Pt; t = E / P. Use E in J and t in s for P in W. 1 W = 1 J/s.
Stores and transfer pathways
Stores include kinetic, gravitational potential, chemical, elastic potential, nuclear and internal. Transfers occur mechanically, electrically, by heating or by waves. Include both electromagnetic examples such as sunlight and mechanical examples such as sound.
Name the objects and the stores that change. Gravitational energy concerns the mass-Earth interaction; internal energy concerns particles. Heat, sound and electricity should not be added as extra stores in this description.
Close the energy account
Energy cannot be created or destroyed. Initial energy + transfers in = final energy + transfers out. With no transfer across the boundary, the total for the system stays constant.
Equate a gravitational decrease with a kinetic increase only when the other changes are negligible. If friction or air resistance increases internal stores, include that amount. A body released from rest starts with zero kinetic energy; a moving starting body does not.
Power from a steady lift
Measure total lifted mass, vertical rise and elapsed time for the same steady interval. mgh/t gives average useful gravitational output power. It does not measure total electrical input power. Match height and timing marks, include the hanger and distinguish repeated random variation from an incorrect reference.
Back to energy stores and transfersPractise exam questions
Write your answer first, then tick the mark points it makes.
Exam-style question
A 0.50 kg ball is dropped from a height of 3.2 m. Air resistance is negligible and g = 10 N/kg. Describe the energy transfer as it falls, and calculate its speed just before it hits the ground. [3]
Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.
Exam-style question
State what is meant by the work done by a force. A boy pushes a box 3.0 m along the floor with a horizontal force of 40 N. Calculate the work done by the boy. [3]
Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.
Exam-style question
An electric motor lifts a 50 kg load at a steady speed through a height of 6.0 m in 12 s. Take g = 10 N/kg. Calculate the useful power output of the motor. [3]
Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.
Quick recall
A loudspeaker makes a nearby thin membrane vibrate without touching it. Which description identifies the transfer between them?