Full chapter
Data and Experimental Skills
Read unfamiliar evidence, make useful measurements and explain what a result can support.
SEC G2 Science K223 / K225 (2027)
Read unfamiliar data with a purpose
Separate the question, the evidence and the chemistry that connects them.
Start with the quantity or claim the question asks you to establish. Then locate the relevant measurements, conditions and any new definitions in the stem. An unfamiliar substance name does not make its data unusable. Use the supplied information together with a familiar idea, such as conservation of atoms, collision frequency or intermolecular attraction.
- Name the task
For a calculation, identify the required quantity and unit. For an explanation, identify the observation that needs explaining.
- Select the evidence
Extract the relevant rows, axes and conditions. Distinguish a measurement from a proposed explanation; do not use every number just because it is present.
- Connect a principle
State the chemical relationship that makes the evidence relevant. Check that the comparison holds other important variables constant.
- State the result and its limit
Give a numerical answer with units, or a conclusion supported by a specific comparison. State an assumption where the inference depends on it.
Worked exampleAssess a claim about a catalyst
Two runs use the same amount of reactant and the same temperature. Run A gives 40 cm3 of gas in 20 s; run B gives 40 cm3 in 50 s. Both eventually give 60 cm3. A report says: "A produces more product because it is faster."
Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
- The time to reach the same volume is smaller for A. Its average rate to 40 cm3 is 2.0 cm3 s-1, compared with 0.80 cm3 s-1 for B.
- The final volumes are the same under the same collection conditions, so these data do not show more final gaseous product in A.
- The evidence supports faster production, not a greater final amount. Identifying the cause as a catalyst also requires the stated experimental difference between the runs.
Compare rate using a time interval and final amount using the plateau. They answer different questions.
Answer in the quantity the question asks for. If it asks how the rate changes, describe the rate, not the time taken: a shorter time means a faster rate.
Data can also predict. Dmitri Mendeleev used the patterns in his periodic table to predict an undiscovered element, eka-silicon. He predicted a relative atomic mass of about 72 and a density of 5.5 g/cm3. Germanium, isolated in 1886, has values of 72.6 and 5.32 g/cm3.
Check your understanding
A table gives temperature, concentration, reaction time and the colour of the laboratory bench. Which data belong in an explanation of the rate trend?
Show the answer
Temperature, concentration and reaction time, after checking which one was changed
Use the variables that can affect rate, and find out which one was varied. Bench colour has no chemical role, so do not invent a link just because a detail is given.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Temperature affects the rate like this: as the temperature rises, the reaction time decreases." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
That describes the time, not the rate the question asked about. Turn it round: as the temperature rises, the time taken falls, so the rate increases. Examiners report "reaction time decreases" as the most common wrong answer when the question asked about rate.
Exam-style question
Data-based questionA school is next to a bus interchange. Students used a sensor to measure two gases in the air at the school gate on one weekday. They also counted the buses that arrived each hour. The unit ppm means parts per million and ppb means parts per billion. Both are ways of measuring very small amounts of a gas in air.
Table 1. Air at the school gate time buses per hour carbon monoxide / ppm nitrogen dioxide / ppb 06:00 10 0.8 20 08:00 45 3.6 70 10:00 25 2.0 45 14:00 20 1.7 42 18:00 50 4.0 78 22:00 8 0.7 18
- (a) State the time when the carbon monoxide level was highest. Give the reading with its unit. [1]
- (b) Describe how the carbon monoxide level changes with the number of buses. Quote two pairs of readings. [2]
- (c) Explain how a bus engine produces carbon monoxide. [1]
- (d) Explain how nitrogen dioxide forms in a bus engine. [1]
- (e) State why carbon monoxide is harmful to the students. [1]
- (f) The principal says: "These readings prove that all the nitrogen dioxide at the gate comes from the buses." Use the data to explain whether you agree. [2]
[8]
Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.
Turn measurements into a graph or calculation
Keep the meaning of each axis, ratio and unit visible.
Put the independent variable on the horizontal axis and the measured or derived dependent variable on the vertical axis. Label each axis with a quantity and unit, use a clear uniform scale, and plot the actual points. A best-fit line or smooth curve represents a trend; do not force it through every point or through the origin without a reason. A point that does not fit the pattern is anomalous: circle it, and leave it out when you draw the line.
| Time / s | Gas volume / cm3 |
|---|---|
| 0 | 0 |
| 20 | 24 |
| 40 | 39 |
| 60 | 45 |
| 80 | 48 |
An interval rate is a gradient between two points
Between 20 and 40 seconds, gas volume increases from 24 to 39 cubic centimetres. The horizontal change is 20 seconds and the vertical change is 15 cubic centimetres. The curve becomes less steep later.
Worked exampleCalculate and interpret a gradient
Find the average gas-production rate between 20 and 40 s.
Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
- Change in gas volume = 39 - 24 = 15 cm3.
- Time interval = 40 - 20 = 20 s. Average rate = 15 / 20 = 0.75 cm3 s-1.
- This is an interval average. A rate at one instant is the gradient of a tangent to the curve at that instant, where required.
0.75 cm3 s-1. The graph later becomes flatter, so the gas-production rate decreases.
Interpolation estimates a value within the measured range. Extrapolation extends a trend outside it and needs an extra assumption that the relationship continues. If a graph is linear, find the gradient from two well-separated points on the best-fit line. Do not choose two close points just because they are measurements.
Keep guard digits during working. Round the final answer to a precision justified by the inputs and any question instruction. A unit conversion changes the numerical value, not the physical quantity: 25.0 cm3 = 0.0250 dm3. Check dimensions before inserting numbers into a formula.
Units matter at every step. In September 1999, NASA lost its Mars Climate Orbiter. One piece of software, supplied by Lockheed Martin, gave its results in US customary units, while NASA's system expected SI units.
Check your understanding
A gas-volume curve is high but nearly horizontal. Does its height show a high rate at that moment?
Show the answer
No. Height shows gas made so far; the flat gradient shows a low rate now.
The rate at a moment is the gradient of the curve. A high, flat curve means a lot of gas has been made but very little is being made now.
Check your understanding
Gas volume was measured every 20 s from 0 to 80 s. A student uses the graph to estimate the volume at 100 s. What is this, and what does it assume?
Show the answer
Extrapolation; it assumes the trend carries on beyond 80 s
100 s is outside the measured range, so this is extrapolation. It is only safe if the trend continues, and the reaction may have stopped by then.
Watch out for this
A student says: "A best-fit line must pass through every plotted point, including one that lies far from the others." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
A best-fit line follows the trend shown by most of the points. Ignore an anomalous point, one that does not fit the pattern, and circle it so the reader can see you left it out. Examiners report lines drawn through the anomalous point instead of ignoring it.
Evaluate evidence and explain the direction of an error
An improvement is useful when it targets a specific limitation.
| Issue | Effect on evidence | Useful response |
|---|---|---|
| Random variation | Repeated results scatter unpredictably | Repeat independent measurements; compare their spread and use a justified mean |
| Systematic bias | Results are displaced consistently, for example by an incorrect calibration | Check against a suitable standard or correct the apparatus/method; repetition alone does not remove the bias |
| Uncontrolled variable | Two possible causes change together | Hold that variable constant or design an additional comparison |
| Limited range or sample | A relationship may be supported only locally | Collect appropriate additional values; restrict the conclusion to the evidence |
Accuracy concerns closeness to a valid reference value; precision concerns the closeness of repeated measurements. A tightly grouped set can still be inaccurate. An anomalous point is a reason to investigate the method and repeat a measurement, not permission to remove inconvenient evidence silently. Record an exclusion and its reason.
Write evaluation as a causal chain: limitation -> affected measurement -> effect on the calculated result -> targeted improvement. "Human error" and "use better equipment" do not identify what happened. For example, gas escaping before collection lowers measured gas volume; assembling a closed collection system before starting the reaction addresses that loss.
Timing by hand is one such limitation. You start and stop a stopwatch yourself, so your reaction time adds an error to every timing. When a reaction is very fast, as at a high temperature, that error is a large part of the time measured.
A result must be repeatable before anyone trusts it. In March 1989, Martin Fleischmann and Stanley Pons of the University of Utah announced "cold fusion" in a test tube. Physicists in several countries tried to repeat their results and failed.
Check your understanding
A thermometer reads 2 degrees too high at every temperature. Will averaging five readings remove that error?
Show the answer
No. Averaging reduces random scatter, but a fixed offset stays in every reading.
Every reading is 2 degrees high, so their average is too. Calibrate the thermometer against a reference. A temperature change measured with the same thermometer can cancel a constant offset.
Check your understanding
A pipette should deliver 25.00 cm3. Five measured deliveries are 24.60, 24.62, 24.61, 24.60 and 24.62 cm3. How would you describe these readings?
Show the answer
Precise but not accurate: they agree closely but are all too low
Precision is how close repeated readings are to each other; these agree within 0.02 cm3. Accuracy is closeness to the true value, and all are about 0.4 cm3 low.
Watch out for this
A student says: "The reaction cannot be studied at 90 degrees C, because it would be over in less than two seconds." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
That gives the time but not the problem it causes. Explain the effect on the measurement. The time is too short to measure accurately with a stopwatch. Your reaction time in starting and stopping it is a large part of so short a time. Examiners did not credit answers that only said the reaction would take less than one or two seconds.
Record measurements that another person can interpret
Use the instrument scale, a clear table and observations that preserve the sequence.
Choose apparatus for the measurement you need. A volumetric pipette delivers one fixed, accurate volume. A burette delivers a variable volume that you can measure accurately. A measuring cylinder suits less exact volume work, and a balance measures mass. Read the scale at eye level to avoid parallax, an error from viewing the scale at an angle. For a clear aqueous solution, read the bottom of the meniscus unless told otherwise.
| Trial | Initial burette / cm3 | Final burette / cm3 | Titre / cm3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rough | 0.00 | 24.80 | 24.80 |
| 1 | 1.10 | 25.50 | 24.40 |
| 2 | 0.20 | 24.65 | 24.45 |
| 3 | 0.30 | 24.70 | 24.40 |
For Secondary Chemistry, the syllabus normally expects burette readings to the nearest 0.05 cm3. It also expects enough titrations to give, with a good end-point, two titres within 0.20 cm3. Record both readings and the difference. Follow the question if it gives a particular agreement criterion; do not include the rough titre in a precise mean.
Worked exampleSelect a justified mean titre
Use the precise titrations in the table; their maximum separation is 0.05 cm3.
Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
- Trials 1, 2 and 3 form a close group. The rough trial was for locating the end-point.
- Mean = (24.40 + 24.45 + 24.40) / 3 = 24.4166... cm3.
- Record a suitable rounded mean of 24.42 cm3; retain the unrounded value through subsequent calculations where useful.
24.42 cm3, with the selected trials clearly identified.
Separate raw observations from interpretation. "A white precipitate forms after three drops and dissolves in excess" preserves information that "positive test" loses. Record colour, physical state, changes on standing or warming, and any confirmed gas test. Put units in table headings; do not attach a unit to a pure ratio.
Write every reading to the same precision, so a burette reading at the zero mark is 0.00 cm3, not 0. Units matter too. On 23 July 1983, the fuel for Air Canada Flight 143 was worked out with the wrong unit. The crew used a density in pounds per litre instead of kilograms per litre. So the plane took off with less than half the fuel it needed.
Check your understanding
The initial burette reading is 2.35 cm3 and the final reading is 26.70 cm3. What volume was delivered?
Show the answer
24.35 cm3
Delivered volume = final - initial = 26.70 - 2.35 = 24.35 cm3.
Watch out for this
A student says: "The burette was filled to the zero mark, so the initial reading is recorded as 0." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Record every burette reading to the same precision, the nearest 0.05 cm3, so a reading at the zero mark is written 0.00. Examiners report readings of 0 written without their decimal places.
Make a titre correspond to the reacting amounts
The endpoint, rinsing and complete transfer determine what the number means.
- Prepare the measured solutions
Rinse the burette with its solution and the pipette with the solution it will measure. Fill the burette tip, remove the funnel and record the initial reading. Use a pipette filler.
- Transfer a fixed aliquot
Deliver the pipetted solution into a clean conical flask. Allow the pipette to drain as designed; do not blow out a residual tip drop unless it is a blow-out pipette.
- Locate the endpoint
Add a small consistent amount of a suitable indicator. Swirl during addition, use a white background and add titrant dropwise near the endpoint. Rinse flask walls with distilled water if needed.
- Repeat and calculate
Record the final reading and titre. Obtain agreeing precise titres, select a justified mean, then use concentration, volume and the balanced mole ratio.
The equivalence point is the stoichiometric completion of reaction. The endpoint is the observed indicator change. Choose an indicator that changes colour within the steep pH change near equivalence. Universal indicator gives a broad colour change, so it is unsuitable for a precise titration. The required final colour depends on the indicator and which solution is added.
The burette has a long history. The German chemist Karl Friedrich Mohr made it much easier to use by giving it a tip and a clamp at the bottom. In 1855 he published the first textbook on titration.
Check your understanding
After pipetting the alkali into the conical flask, a student adds a little distilled water. How does this affect the titre?
Show the answer
No effect, because the amount of alkali in the flask is unchanged.
Water dilutes the alkali but does not change the moles present, so the same volume of acid neutralises it. This assumes nothing is lost and the end-point is still clear.
Check your understanding
Why is universal indicator not used to find the end-point of an acid-alkali titration?
Show the answer
Its colour changes gradually over a wide pH range, so there is no sharp end-point
A titration needs one sudden colour change at the end-point. Universal indicator passes through many colours as the pH changes, so you cannot tell exactly when to stop.
Watch out for this
A student says: "In a titration, the acid is added from a pipette, a little at a time, until the indicator changes colour." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
The acid is added from a burette. A burette delivers any volume and lets you read how much was added. A pipette delivers one fixed volume, so it is used to put the alkali into the flask. Examiners report students swapping the burette and the pipette.
Reason from an unknown test without guessing
A valid inference needs the right reagent, a clear observation and an appropriate comparison.
Use clean apparatus and a fresh small portion for each test. Add reagent gradually with mixing; observe a few drops, excess reagent and warming separately when instructed. Write the actual colour and physical change. A blue solution and a pale-blue precipitate are different observations. Name a gas only after the appropriate confirmatory test.
For a simple organic test, record the reagent and what changes. Aqueous bromine changing from orange to colourless is consistent with an alkene. But decolourisation alone does not prove a C=C bond, because other substances can also react with bromine. Use the stated candidate structures and any other evidence to narrow the conclusion.
Name a solid that forms as a precipitate, with its colour, such as "white precipitate".
Careful tests have long mattered, even in court. In 1836 James Marsh published a test for arsenic. A cold ceramic bowl held in the flame of the gas from the sample is stained with a silvery-black deposit if arsenic is present. The test was used in 1840 in the famous Lafarge poisoning case.
Check your understanding
A precipitate dissolves when excess reagent is added, leaving a clear coloured liquid. How should this be recorded?
Show the answer
Give the precipitate colour, that it dissolves in excess, and the solution colour.
Record each stage: the precipitate and its colour, that it dissolves in excess, and the colour of the final solution. Saying the colour disappeared is wrong if the solution is still coloured.
Watch out for this
A student says: "The reagent made the colourless solution go cloudy, so my observation is that the solution turns cloudy." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Record what forms and its colour: a white precipitate. "Cloudy" does not say that a solid has formed, or what colour it is. Examiners report words such as "chalky", "misty" and "cloudy" wrongly used in place of "white precipitate".
In G2 the gas tests you must know are hydrogen (lighted splint, squeaky pop), oxygen (glowing splint relights) and carbon dioxide (limewater turns milky). A question may describe another test and ask you to record or interpret what you would see. Describe the change first, then state what it suggests.
Recover the substance you need
Choose a process from solubility, volatility and thermal stability.
| Task | Method | What is recovered |
|---|---|---|
| Remove an insoluble solid from a liquid | Filtration | Solid is the residue; liquid passing through is the filtrate |
| Obtain a dissolved solid that crystallises on cooling | Concentrate, cool, filter crystals, wash sparingly and dry | Crystals; some solute remains dissolved in the mother liquor |
| Recover a solvent | Simple distillation | Condensed vapour from the distillate; monitor the apparatus correctly |
| Compare soluble mixture components | Paper chromatography | Separated spots, compared under the same conditions |
For paper chromatography, use a pencil baseline above the solvent, small concentrated spots and a covered vessel where appropriate. Remove the paper before the solvent reaches the top and mark the solvent front immediately. One spot does not prove a pure substance: two substances that travel the same distance give a single spot.
Chromatography began with plant colours. The botanist Mikhail Tsvet invented it in 1900, during his research on plant pigments, and used it to separate chlorophylls from carotenoids.
Check your understanding
Why is a filtered insoluble precipitate washed with a little distilled water?
Show the answer
To rinse away soluble impurities left from the solution it was made in.
The solid is coated with the solution it formed in, which contains soluble ions. A small amount of cold distilled water removes them without dissolving much of the product.
G2 practical work includes crystallisation of salts, filtration, paper chromatography and distillation. Describing the full preparation of a pure salt is not required.
Watch out for this
A student says: "A dye gives a single spot on a paper chromatogram, so it must be a pure substance." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Two substances that travel the same distance in this solvent also give a single spot. Before calling the dye pure, run it again in a different solvent, or compare it with known substances. Examiners report students not realising that two dyes can travel the same distance on a chromatogram.
Quick revision
Revisit the essentials, then return to an explanation when you need it.
Read the requested quantity or claim first. Select the relevant evidence, state the chemical connection and give a result with its unit or a justified conclusion.
| Question | Check |
|---|---|
| What do the axes mean? | Distinguish accumulated amount from its rate of change |
| Is the comparison fair? | Check temperature, amounts and other potentially changing variables |
| What does the uncertainty affect? | Trace its effect through the calculation; do not assume every error raises the answer |
| How far can I conclude? | Distinguish interpolation from extrapolation and evidence from an untested explanation |
For a G2 practical question: choose suitable apparatus, read scales at eye level, record raw readings with units in the table heading, describe what you see before concluding, and suggest a specific improvement rather than "be more careful".
Scope
Learning outcomes
Assessment Objective C: experimental skills in the theory papers. Use the outcome map to find the explanation for a particular syllabus requirement.
These labels map assessment skills and practical techniques, separately from the numbered theory outcomes. P, MMO, PDO and ACE are practical skill areas; T labels follow the listed techniques, and B labels follow H1 Assessment Objective B.
See the learning outcome map
C1 Select and use techniques, apparatus and materials
- Choose apparatus for measuring, separating and testing
- Acid/alkali titration with pipette, burette and indicator
- Separation by crystallisation, filtration, chromatography and distillation
Record measurements that another person can interpretMake a titre correspond to the reacting amountsRecover the substance you need
C2 Take readings and record observations
- Read scales, burettes and thermometers
- Units in table headings
- Record colours, precipitates and gas tests
Record measurements that another person can interpretReason from an unknown test without guessing
C3 Interpret and evaluate data and observations
- Read tables and plot graphs
- Gradient, intercept or intersection
- Separate observation from conclusion
Read unfamiliar data with a purposeTurn measurements into a graph or calculationReason from an unknown test without guessing
C4 Evaluate methods and suggest improvements
- Identify sources of error
- Suggest a needed modification
- Comment on safety