What this lesson teaches
I can judge how the Cold War played out in Korea, Vietnam and Cuba, and how each conflict changed the Cold War.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the manifestation of the Cold War conflict across different contexts over time, and its impact on the Cold War
Make a guess
The Geneva settlement called for national elections in Vietnam in 1956. What do you think Diem did?
- Held them and accepted a narrow defeat by Ho.
- Held them in the South and won a fair majority.
- Refused to hold them, with US support.
Show the answer
Refused to hold them, with US support.
Diem argued free voting was impossible in the North, and Ho was expected to win. Without elections, division hardened into war.
Diem's unpopular South Vietnam and Hanoi's decision to support armed struggle turned division into war.
In the South, Ngo Dinh Diem became president in 1955 with American backing. He refused to hold the 1956 elections. He argued that free voting was impossible in the communist North. The USA supported him, partly because Ho was expected to win.
Diem's rule was narrow and harsh. He favoured fellow Catholics in a mainly Buddhist country and imprisoned opponents. His campaigns against former Viet Minh members drove many into armed resistance.
In 1959, North Vietnam's leaders decided to support armed struggle in the South. Supplies began moving down what became the Ho Chi Minh Trail. In December 1960 the National Liberation Front (NLF) was formed to fight Diem. Its enemies called it the Viet Cong.
Diem's position grew weaker. In 1963, Buddhist protests, including monks burning themselves to death, drew world attention. They showed that Diem was losing support among his own people. In August 1963, Washington signalled that it would not oppose a coup. In November, South Vietnamese generals overthrew and killed Diem. Several unstable governments followed.
- Diem
- President of South Vietnam from 1955; overthrown November 1963.
- Hanoi's 1959 decision
- Support for armed struggle in the South.
- NLF
- Formed December 1960.
Real examples to use
Diem's referendum, October 1955
Diem claimed about 98 per cent of the vote against Bao Dai in a rigged poll, then declared a republic.
Ap Bac, January 1963
A small communist force beat a much larger South Vietnamese army unit, exposing its weakness.
Thich Quang Duc, 11 June 1963
A Buddhist monk burned himself to death in Saigon in protest at Diem's rule. Photographs turned US opinion against Diem.
Worked example: Hanoi chooses armed struggle, 1959
In January 1959, the Central Committee of North Vietnam's ruling party met for its 15th plenum. It agreed that the revolution in the South should combine armed struggle with political struggle. In May 1959, the army set up Group 559 to open a supply route south. This was the start of the Ho Chi Minh Trail.
- North Vietnam: Hanoi chose to back the southern rising, so the war was not only a southern revolt.
- South Vietnam: southern communists, hit hard by Diem's campaigns, had pressed Hanoi for this change.
- Limit: Hanoi still stressed political struggle at first, and armed struggle grew step by step.
- Use: in an essay on what shaped the war, weigh Hanoi's choice against Diem's weakness.
Watch out for this
The Viet Cong was simply an army sent from North Vietnam.
The NLF drew on southerners opposed to Diem, though it was directed and supplied by Hanoi and later reinforced by northern troops.
Check your understanding
Why did Diem refuse to hold the 1956 elections?
- He argued free voting was impossible in the North, and expected Ho to win.
- The UN cancelled them because of fighting in the countryside.
- Ho Chi Minh refused to take part unless French troops left the South first.
Show the answer
He argued free voting was impossible in the North, and expected Ho to win.
Right. The USA backed his refusal.
Check your understanding
Why did the Buddhist protests of 1963 matter to Washington?
- They forced Diem to hold the elections promised at Geneva.
- They showed Diem's narrow rule was losing support at home and abroad.
- They showed that most Buddhists supported the communist North.
Show the answer
They showed Diem's narrow rule was losing support at home and abroad.
Yes. Photographs of the protests turned US opinion against Diem. In August, Washington signalled it would not oppose a coup.