From the First Indochina War to Geneva

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how the Cold War played out in Korea, Vietnam and Cuba, and how each conflict changed the Cold War.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the manifestation of the Cold War conflict across different contexts over time, and its impact on the Cold War

Make a guess

From 1950 France was fighting the Viet Minh in Indochina. How much of France's war costs do you think the USA paid by 1954?

  1. About a tenth, mostly as food aid.
  2. Very little, because the USA opposed colonial wars.
  3. Roughly three-quarters.
Show the answer

Roughly three-quarters.

Washington saw the war as part of containment after 1949, so it paid more and more, and then replaced France after Geneva.

The French defeat in 1954 left Vietnam divided at the 17th parallel, and the USA replaced France as the main Western power.

From 1946, the Viet Minh, led by Ho Chi Minh, fought France for Vietnam's independence. After the communists won in China in 1949, China sent the Viet Minh weapons and advisers. The USA saw the war as part of containment. It paid a growing share of France's costs, roughly three-quarters by 1954.

In May 1954 the Viet Minh defeated the French at Dien Bien Phu. At the Geneva Conference, Vietnam was divided for a time at the 17th parallel. The final declaration said national elections would be held in July 1956 to reunify the country.

The superpowers and China shaped Geneva. China and the USSR pressed the Viet Minh to accept partition. They wanted to avoid American intervention and to ease tensions. Ho's movement felt it had been denied the full fruits of victory.

No delegation signed the final declaration, and the USA would not accept it. In September 1954 it set up SEATO, a Southeast Asian alliance, and backed a non-communist state in the south. Its relations with the two Vietnams were now set: hostility to the communist North and support for the South.

Course note: H1 questions on this war start in 1959, so this lesson is background for H1. H2 questions can ask about it directly.

Dien Bien Phu
May 1954: French defeat.
Geneva
July 1954: division at the 17th parallel; elections promised for July 1956.
SEATO
September 1954: US-led alliance in Southeast Asia.

Real examples to use

US aid from 1950

Truman approved aid to the French in May 1950, before the Korean War. By 1954 the USA was paying most of France's war costs.

Siege of Dien Bien Phu, 13 March-7 May 1954

Viet Minh artillery on the hills closed the airstrip, and the garrison surrendered the day before Indochina talks began at Geneva.

No US air strikes, April 1954

Eisenhower declined to bomb the Viet Minh without allies and Congress behind him, which kept the USA out of direct war.

Worked example: The US statement at Geneva, 21 July 1954

Instead of joining the final declaration, Under Secretary of State Walter Bedell Smith read a separate US statement. The USA would "refrain from the threat or the use of force to disturb" the agreements. But it would view any renewed aggression "with grave concern." On 8 September, a protocol to the new SEATO treaty covered "the free territory under the jurisdiction of the State of Vietnam": the South.

  1. Hands off: the USA promised not to wreck the Geneva deal by force.
  2. Warning: "grave concern" kept its right to act if the North moved south.
  3. Commitment: the SEATO protocol put South Vietnam under Western protection.
  4. Use: this shows how the First Indochina War set US relations with the two Vietnams.

Watch out for this

The Geneva Accords created two permanent Vietnamese states.

The division at the 17th parallel was meant to be temporary, with elections in July 1956 to reunify the country.

Check your understanding

Why did China and the USSR press the Viet Minh to accept partition at Geneva?

  1. They planned to occupy the south themselves.
  2. They wanted to avoid American intervention and ease tensions.
  3. They wanted France to keep the south as a buffer.
Show the answer

They wanted to avoid American intervention and ease tensions.

Right. Both had wider priorities than a complete Viet Minh victory.

Check your understanding

A historian says Geneva was a full victory for Ho Chi Minh. Which evidence best challenges this?

  1. France kept its colonial rule over the south after 1954.
  2. China and the USSR pressed him to accept a divided Vietnam.
  3. The final declaration ruled out elections in Vietnam for good.
Show the answer

China and the USSR pressed him to accept a divided Vietnam.

Yes. His movement had won the war, but it was denied control of the whole country.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • Johnson explains why Americans are in Vietnam

    Paraphrase of President Lyndon Johnson's address at Johns Hopkins University, 7 April 1965.

  • McNamara recommends more troops

    Paraphrase of a memorandum from Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara to President Johnson, 20 July 1965.

  • The Geneva final declaration

    Paraphrase of paragraph 7 of the final declaration of the Geneva Conference on Indochina, 20 July 1954, as cabled by the US delegation.

  • Nixon appeals to the silent majority

    Paraphrase of President Richard Nixon's televised address to the nation on the war in Vietnam, 3 November 1969.

  • Eisenhower explains the stakes, 1954

    Extract from President Dwight Eisenhower's news conference of 7 April 1954, answering a question on the strategic importance of Indochina, a month before the French defeat at Dien Bien Phu. A US government record in the public domain; text from the American Presidency Project.

  • a Defense official ranks American aims, March 1965

    Extract from "Action for South Vietnam", a paper prepared by John McNaughton, Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs, Washington, 10 March 1965, two days after the first US Marines landed at Da Nang. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1964-1968, volume II, document 193. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the Secretary of State on American commitments, July 1965

    Extract from a paper by Secretary of State Dean Rusk, Washington, 1 July 1965, written for the President's meeting on whether to send large numbers of combat troops. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1964-1968, volume III, document 39. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the Under Secretary of State dissents, July 1965

    Extract from "A Compromise Solution for South Viet-Nam", a paper by Under Secretary of State George Ball for the same meeting, Washington, undated (circulated 1 July 1965). The President's security adviser predicted that Johnson would "listen hard to George Ball and then reject his proposal". Foreign Relations of the United States, 1964-1968, volume III, document 40. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the Secretary of Defense explains the strategy, November 1965

    Extract from a draft memorandum from Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara to President Johnson, "Courses of Action in Vietnam", Washington, 3 November 1965. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1964-1968, volume III, document 189. A US government document in the public domain.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready