How sustainable was growth?

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge the outcomes of economic change in Southeast Asia for growth, equity and economic nationalism.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of economic change across different contexts and over time

Make a guess

In July 1997 Thailand was forced to float its currency, the baht. What do you think happened next?

  1. A crisis spread, and several economies shrank sharply in 1998.
  2. Thailand's economy grew faster than it ever had before.
  3. Little, because the problem stayed in Thailand.
Show the answer

A crisis spread, and several economies shrank sharply in 1998.

Short-term dollar borrowing left them fragile. Indonesia's economy shrank by about 13 per cent in 1998.

Fast growth rested on foreign money, cheap labour and natural resources. The 1997 crisis showed how fragile it could be.

Sustainable growth is growth that can last. It rests on rising skills, safe ways of paying for investment, and resources that are not used up.

Growth relied heavily on foreign investment and borrowing. In the 1990s, banks and firms in Thailand and Indonesia borrowed short-term in US dollars. Much of the money went into property and shares.

In July 1997 Thailand was forced to float its currency, the baht, which lost much of its value. The crisis spread. In 1998 the economies of Thailand and Malaysia shrank by about 7 to 8 per cent. Singapore's, with strong banks, shrank by about 2 per cent.

Responses differed. Thailand and Indonesia accepted IMF loans with strict conditions. Malaysia rejected IMF help. In September 1998 it imposed capital controls, limits on moving money out of the country.

Growth also had environmental costs. Forests in Indonesia and Malaysia were cleared for timber and plantations, and fires in 1997 spread a choking haze across the region.

In 1994 the economist Paul Krugman argued that growth came mainly from adding more workers and capital, not from using them better. Growth of that kind slows as these inputs run out.

Yet every economy hit by the crisis grew again in 1999. Much of the earlier progress had lasted.

July 1997
Thailand floats the baht.
Indonesia
Economy shrank about 13% in 1998.
Malaysia
Capital controls, September 1998.

Real examples to use

Malaysia's capital controls, September 1998

Malaysia limited the movement of money out of the country and fixed its currency at 3.80 ringgit to the US dollar.

Worked example: Indonesia, 1997 to 1999

Indonesian firms had borrowed heavily in US dollars. When the crisis spread from Thailand in 1997, investors pulled their money out and the rupiah fell.

  1. The fall: by World Bank figures, the rupiah averaged about 2,300 to the dollar in 1996 and about 10,000 in 1998. Each dollar owed now cost about four times as many rupiah.
  2. The damage: the economy shrank by about 13 per cent in 1998, and prices rose by about 58 per cent. Suharto resigned in May 1998.
  3. The slow recovery: Indonesia grew by less than 1 per cent in 1999, against about 6 per cent in Malaysia.
  4. Judgement: growth paid for by short-term foreign loans was fragile, and the political crisis deepened the fall. Indonesia's growth had real gains, but weak foundations.

Watch out for this

The 1997 crisis proved that Southeast Asian growth had been an illusion.

Living standards had risen greatly, and most economies recovered from 1999. The crisis showed that growth was fragile, not that it was false.

Check your understanding

How did Malaysia respond differently to the 1997 crisis?

  1. It rejected IMF help and imposed capital controls.
  2. It accepted strict IMF loans and conditions.
  3. It nationalised the foreign banks.
Show the answer

It rejected IMF help and imposed capital controls.

Right. It chose its own path in 1998.

Check your understanding

Why did the falling rupiah hurt Indonesian firms that had borrowed in US dollars?

  1. Each dollar they owed now cost far more rupiah to repay.
  2. A weaker rupiah made their rupiah earnings worth more dollars.
  3. Their dollar debts were cancelled when the rupiah fell.
Show the answer

Each dollar they owed now cost far more rupiah to repay.

Right. They earned mostly in rupiah, but their debts were in dollars.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready