What this lesson teaches
I can judge the outcomes of economic change in Southeast Asia for growth, equity and economic nationalism.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of economic change across different contexts and over time
Make a guess
A 1993 World Bank report spoke of an East Asian miracle. Do you think every Southeast Asian economy shared in it?
- No, they grew no faster than Western economies.
- Yes, each economy in the region grew equally fast.
- No, some grew fast while others grew slowly or stagnated.
Show the answer
No, some grew fast while others grew slowly or stagnated.
Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia grew fast for long periods. The Philippines and Burma lagged far behind.
Several Southeast Asian economies grew fast enough to be called a "miracle". Others grew slowly or stagnated.
Growth is measured by national income and output. The usual measure is gross domestic product (GDP), the value of everything a country produces in a year.
Income per person is GDP divided by the population. It shows living standards better than total GDP.
Singapore grew fastest. By Singapore's official figures, its economy grew by about 9 per cent a year from 1965 to 1997.
Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia also grew fast for long periods. Thailand grew by about 9 per cent a year in the decade before 1997.
The Philippines grew more slowly. Its income per person was higher than Thailand's in 1960, but Thailand overtook it in the mid-1980s. Growth collapsed in 1984-1985 under Marcos.
Burma stagnated under state socialism. Vietnam grew quickly only after the Doi Moi reforms of 1986.
- Singapore
- About 9% a year, 1965-1997.
- Miracle economies
- Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia (World Bank, 1993).
- The Philippines
- Overtaken by Thailand in the mid-1980s.
Real examples to use
Burma, 1987 and 1988
World Bank figures show its economy shrinking by 4 per cent in 1987 and by 11 per cent in 1988.
Worked example: The World Bank's "East Asian Miracle" report, 1993
In 1993 the World Bank published The East Asian Miracle. It named eight "high-performing Asian economies". Four were in Southeast Asia: Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia.
- The claim: East Asia had grown faster than every other region from 1965 to 1990, mostly because of these eight.
- The evidence: the World Bank's 1992 World Development Report shows Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia each growing about 7 per cent a year in 1965-1980. In the 1980s Thailand kept this pace, while Malaysia and Indonesia slowed to just over 5 per cent.
- The gap: from 1965 to 1990 the Philippines averaged about 4 per cent a year and Burma about 3 per cent. Their populations grew by 2 to 3 per cent a year, so income per person rose slowly.
- Judgement: growth was the clearest success of the period. But it was a miracle for four economies, not for the whole region.
Watch out for this
All of Southeast Asia shared in the "Asian miracle".
The miracle was concentrated in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia. The Philippines grew slowly and Burma stagnated.
Check your understanding
What happened to the Philippines compared with Thailand?
- The Philippines was richer per person in 1960 but Thailand overtook it.
- Both stagnated equally under military rule.
- The Philippines grew faster and stayed ahead of Thailand throughout the period.
Show the answer
The Philippines was richer per person in 1960 but Thailand overtook it.
Right. Slower growth left it behind.
Check your understanding
From 1965 to 1990 the Philippine economy grew by about 4 per cent a year, and its population by about 2.6 per cent a year. What does this suggest?
- Each Filipino's income rose by about 4 per cent a year.
- Living standards fell, because the population grew faster than the whole economy.
- Income per person rose only slowly, by just over 1 per cent a year.
Show the answer
Income per person rose only slowly, by just over 1 per cent a year.
Right. More people shared the extra output, so income per person grew far more slowly than GDP.