Economic aims: growth, equity and nationalism

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how much Southeast Asian economies changed after independence, sector by sector.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the extent of economic change in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

After independence, new governments wanted growth. What else do you think many of them wanted from the economy?

  1. Little else, since growth was their main aim.
  2. To keep foreign owners in full control of key industries.
  3. A fairer share of wealth and national control.
Show the answer

A fairer share of wealth and national control.

Malaysia's NEP aimed at equity, and Indonesia and Burma seized foreign firms. These aims could clash with growth.

New governments pursued three aims: growth, a fairer share of wealth, and national control of the economy. These aims could pull in different directions.

Growth meant raising national income and output. It created jobs and paid for roads and schools. Every government made it a goal.

Equity meant cutting poverty and inequality. Malaysia began its New Economic Policy (NEP) in 1971, after the riots of 1969. It aimed to end poverty and to end the link between race and type of work.

Economic nationalism meant taking control from foreigners. Indonesia seized Dutch firms in 1957 and 1958. The Philippines' "Filipino First" policy of 1958 favoured Filipino firms.

The aims could clash. Seizing foreign firms scared off foreign money and slowed growth. Singapore put growth first. It welcomed big foreign firms rather than seeking local ownership.

Priorities changed over time. In the 1950s and 1960s many governments stressed national control. From the 1970s and 1980s many turned to growth through foreign investment and exports.

Three aims
Growth, equity, nationalism.
NEP
Malaysia, 1971.
Nationalisation
Indonesia 1957-1958; Burma 1963.

Worked example: Burma's Way to Socialism, 1962 to 1987

On 30 April 1962, weeks after the army seized power, General Ne Win's Revolutionary Council issued The Burmese Way to Socialism. It put state control and national ownership first.

  1. Action: from 1963 the state took over most industry, banks and trade. Many Indian and other foreign-owned firms were seized, and many Indian traders left.
  2. Cost: foreign investment stayed away, and Burma traded little with the world.
  3. Result: on 11 December 1987 the UN added Burma to its list of Least Developed Countries.
  4. Judgement: Burma won national control, but at the cost of growth. The aims really could pull in opposite directions.

Watch out for this

All governments wanted the same things in the same order.

Priorities differed. Burma put nationalism first and stagnated; Singapore put growth first and prospered.

Check your understanding

What was the main aim of Malaysia's New Economic Policy?

  1. To nationalise the foreign companies that owned the estates and tin mines
  2. To stop exporting rubber and grow more rice
  3. To end poverty and the link between race and type of work
Show the answer

To end poverty and the link between race and type of work

Right. It combined equity with growth.

Check your understanding

Singapore welcomed foreign multinationals, while Burma nationalised foreign firms. Which aim did each put first?

  1. Singapore put growth first; Burma put national control first.
  2. Both put equity between races first.
  3. Singapore put national control first; Burma put growth first.
Show the answer

Singapore put growth first; Burma put national control first.

Right. The choice mattered: Singapore grew fast, while Burma was listed as least developed in 1987.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready