Judging the extent of change

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how much Southeast Asian economies changed after independence, sector by sector.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the extent of economic change in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

By 2000, do you think every Southeast Asian economy had been transformed?

  1. No, they had barely changed since independence.
  2. Yes, each had become a modern industrial economy by then.
  3. No, change was large in some and limited in others.
Show the answer

No, change was large in some and limited in others.

Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand changed most. Indonesia and the Philippines changed partly, and Burma stayed largely agricultural.

Economic change was large in Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand, partial in Indonesia and the Philippines, and limited in Burma. Continuities remained across most of the region.

To judge the extent of change, compare the starting point with 2000. Look at what economies made, what they sold abroad, who owned firms, and where people worked.

Singapore changed most. It moved from entrepot trade to manufacturing and then to finance and services.

Malaysia and Thailand changed greatly. Factory goods, especially electronics, replaced raw materials as their main exports. Yet in 2000 more than two-fifths of Thai workers still farmed.

Indonesia and the Philippines changed less evenly. The Philippines grew slowly, and many workers moved abroad for jobs.

Burma changed least. Isolation and state control left it dependent on farming and raw materials. Farming still made up more than half its output in 2000.

Continuities remained across the region. These included dependence on foreign capital and markets, large rural populations, and the weight of Chinese-owned businesses.

Criteria
Output, exports, ownership, employment.
Most change
Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand.
Least change
Burma.

Real examples to use

The Philippines, 2000

World Bank data show factory goods, mostly electronics, at about 91 per cent of exports. Yet about 36 per cent of workers still farmed.

Worked example: Indonesia, 1980 to 2000

World Bank data show that in 1980 oil and gas made up about 72 per cent of Indonesia's merchandise exports. Factory goods made up about 2 per cent.

  1. Exports: by 2000 factory goods were about 57 per cent of exports, and fuels about 25 per cent.
  2. Output: farming's share of the economy fell from about 24 per cent in 1985 to about 16 per cent in 2000.
  3. Work: yet about 45 per cent of workers still farmed in 2000.
  4. Judgement: what Indonesia sold changed greatly. How most people earned a living changed much less.

Watch out for this

All Southeast Asian economies were transformed by 2000.

Change was uneven. Singapore was transformed, but Burma changed little, and rural poverty remained widespread in the Philippines and Indonesia.

Check your understanding

Which country changed least between independence and 2000?

  1. Burma
  2. Malaysia
  3. Singapore
Show the answer

Burma

Right. Isolation and state control held it back.

Check your understanding

Which pair best shows that the extent of change differed between countries?

  1. Malaysia's free trade zones and Thailand's factory exports.
  2. Indonesia's rice drive and its factory exports after 1986.
  3. Singapore's shift to finance and Burma's reliance on farming.
Show the answer

Singapore's shift to finance and Burma's reliance on farming.

Right. Singapore was transformed while Burma changed least, so the pair shows uneven change.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready