Weighing the challenges

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how oil crises, protectionism and debt crises hurt the global economy from the 1970s.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the challenges that affected the global economy over time

Make a guess

Which challenge to the post-war economy do you think was most serious?

  1. Protectionism, because it alone ended the post-war boom.
  2. Whichever lasted longest, since length matters more than the other tests.
  3. It depends on your criteria: breadth, depth, length and links.
Show the answer

It depends on your criteria: breadth, depth, length and links.

The oil crises reached furthest and triggered the others; the debt crises did the deepest regional damage.

To judge which challenge mattered most, set criteria: breadth, depth, length and links to the other challenges.

Questions may ask which challenge was most serious, or whether one challenge caused the others. Set clear criteria before you judge.

The oil crises had the widest reach. They hit almost every economy and marked the end of the Golden Age. They also set off the other challenges, through petrodollars and high interest rates.

The debt crises did the deepest damage to some regions. They cost Latin America a decade of growth and threatened major Western banks. But industrial economies recovered from the mid-1980s.

Protectionism was the longest-lasting challenge but the least dramatic. It distorted trade throughout the period, but world trade kept growing.

A good judgement explains how the challenges were linked. It can then argue which was the root cause and which did the most harm.

Criteria
Breadth, depth, length and links.
Oil crises
Widest reach; set off other challenges.
Debt crises
Deepest damage in Latin America and Africa.

Worked example: Testing the criteria with World Bank figures

Figures let you test each criterion with evidence. These come from the World Bank's long-run data.

  1. Breadth: world output grew 6.5 per cent in 1973, but only 0.8 per cent in 1975 and 0.4 per cent in 1982. Each slump came after an oil shock.
  2. Depth: Latin America's output per head was about 6 per cent lower in 1990 than in 1980. Argentina's was about a fifth lower.
  3. Length: textile quotas lasted from 1974 until 2005. Yet world exports more than doubled in real terms between 1973 and 1990.
  4. Judgement: the oil crises reached furthest and set off the others. The debt crises cut deepest in one region. Protectionism lasted longest but did least harm.

Watch out for this

The most serious challenge is simply the one that lasted longest.

Length is one criterion. You also need to weigh breadth, depth and links to the other challenges.

Check your understanding

Which argument best supports the oil crises as the most serious challenge?

  1. They were caused by protectionism.
  2. They mainly hit the Middle East and spared the industrial economies.
  3. They hit nearly every economy and set off the debt crisis.
Show the answer

They hit nearly every economy and set off the debt crisis.

Right. Breadth and causal links make a strong case.

Check your understanding

World exports more than doubled in real terms between 1973 and 1990. Which judgement does this support?

  1. Protectionism was real but did less harm than the other challenges.
  2. The debt crises did no lasting harm to developing countries.
  3. Protectionism was the most serious challenge of the whole period.
Show the answer

Protectionism was real but did less harm than the other challenges.

Right. The barriers lasted, but trade still grew.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready