Protectionism

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how oil crises, protectionism and debt crises hurt the global economy from the 1970s.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the challenges that affected the global economy over time

Make a guess

After 1973, slow growth raised pressure to protect jobs, but GATT limited tariffs. What do you think governments did?

  1. Raised tariffs sharply, as in the 1930s.
  2. Left GATT and closed their markets.
  3. Used quotas, subsidies and voluntary export limits instead.
Show the answer

Used quotas, subsidies and voluntary export limits instead.

This new protectionism got around GATT's tariff rules, yet the open trading system bent rather than broke.

Slow growth after 1973 brought a "new protectionism" of quotas and export limits, but the open trading system bent rather than broke.

Post-war leaders remembered the 1930s, when tariff wars deepened the Depression. A tariff is a tax on imports. The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), signed in 1947, was designed to stop that happening again.

After 1973, slow growth and rising unemployment increased pressure to protect jobs. GATT limited tariffs, so governments used other barriers. These included quotas, which cap how much can be imported, and subsidies to home firms. Others were anti-dumping duties and "voluntary" export restraints, where an exporter agrees to sell less.

Examples were widespread. From 1974 the Multi-Fibre Arrangement (MFA) let rich countries set quotas on textile and clothing imports, mostly from developing countries. Japan limited its car exports to the USA from 1981. The European Community paid its farmers high prices and sold the extra food abroad cheaply, using subsidies.

Protectionism raised prices for buyers. It hurt developing countries that relied on exports of textiles and farm goods. It also caused friction, especially between the USA and Japan in the 1980s.

Yet world trade kept growing. The Tokyo Round (1973-1979) set rules for some non-tariff barriers. The Uruguay Round (1986-1994) agreed to phase out textile quotas and export restraints, and it brought farm trade under rules.

Multi-Fibre Arrangement
1974: textile quotas.
Japan's car restraint
1981: 1.68 million cars a year to the USA.
Uruguay Round
1986-1994: barriers to be phased out.

Real examples to use

US tariffs on Japan, April 1987

The USA put 100 per cent duties on up to 300 million dollars of Japanese goods. It said Japan had not kept a 1986 deal on computer chips.

Britain and Japan, 1975

A "gentlemen's agreement" kept Japanese cars to about 11 per cent of the British market, so Europe used such limits too.

Worked example: Japan's car export limit, 1 May 1981

On 1 May 1981 Japan's trade ministry announced a "voluntary" limit on car exports to the USA. It was meant to give US carmakers time to catch up.

  1. Limit: 1.68 million cars a year from April 1981, down from 1.82 million sold in 1980.
  2. Buyers: by early 1985, US prices of eight popular Japanese models had risen by 17 to 35 per cent. Japanese firms shipped dearer models.
  3. Jobs: the US International Trade Commission put the gain at about 44,000 car jobs by 1984.
  4. Judgement: the limit sat outside GATT's tariff rules. It saved some jobs at a high cost to buyers, and trade went on.

Watch out for this

Protectionism after 1973 meant higher tariffs.

Most new barriers were non-tariff measures, such as quotas and "voluntary" export restraints, because GATT limited tariffs.

Check your understanding

Which was an example of the new protectionism?

  1. Japan's 1981 limit on car exports to the USA
  2. The Marshall Plan's aid to rebuild Western Europe
  3. The creation of the World Trade Organization
Show the answer

Japan's 1981 limit on car exports to the USA

Right. It was a "voluntary" export restraint.

Check your understanding

Protectionism grew after 1973, yet the open trading system "bent rather than broke". Which fact best supports this?

  1. Most countries left GATT and signed private trade deals instead.
  2. World trade kept growing, and GATT talks later rolled barriers back.
  3. Tariffs rose to 1930s levels, but only for a few years.
Show the answer

World trade kept growing, and GATT talks later rolled barriers back.

Right. The barriers distorted trade but did not stop it.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready