Why the wartime allies became rivals

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge which causes mattered most in turning the wartime allies into Cold War rivals after 1945.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of the Cold War

Make a guess

The USA and the USSR fought side by side against Hitler. Why do you think they became rivals so soon after May 1945?

  1. They argued over who deserved credit for defeating Japan.
  2. With the shared enemy gone, ideology, fear and mistrust split them.
  3. Stalin had secretly planned to attack the USA from the start.
Show the answer

With the shared enemy gone, ideology, fear and mistrust split them.

They were allies of necessity. Once Germany was beaten, clashing systems, Soviet fears of invasion and different economic aims returned.

Ideology, security fears, economic aims and mistrust turned the wartime alliance into rivalry by 1947.

The USA and the USSR fought together against Nazi Germany, but they were allies of necessity. Once Germany was defeated in May 1945, the reason to cooperate weakened. Old quarrels came back.

Ideology divided them. An ideology is a set of beliefs about how society should be run. The USA believed in liberal democracy and free-market capitalism. The USSR was a one-party communist state that expected capitalism to collapse. Each saw the other's system as a long-term threat.

Security fears pulled them apart. The USSR had lost around 27 million people. It had been invaded through Eastern Europe twice in thirty years, so Stalin wanted friendly governments on his western border. The USA had the atomic bomb and a strong economy. It wanted a world where such spheres did not block open trade and free elections.

Economic aims differed. The USA wanted an open world economy and the recovery of Western Europe, including Germany. The USSR wanted reparations from Germany to rebuild. Wartime grievances deepened mistrust. Stalin resented the long wait for a second front in France, which opened only in June 1944.

Leaders mattered too. Roosevelt had hoped to manage Stalin through personal diplomacy. After his death in April 1945, Truman took a firmer line. Each side read the other's defensive moves as signs of aggression. Historians call this mutual misperception. It turned quarrels into rivalry.

Soviet war dead
Around 27 million people.
Second front
Opened in France only in June 1944, a Soviet grievance.
Roosevelt dies
April 1945; Truman takes a firmer line.

Real examples to use

Invasions from the west, 1914 and 1941

Germany attacked Russia in 1914 and the USSR in June 1941, both times through Poland. This is why Stalin treated a friendly Poland as a matter of survival.

Truman meets Molotov, 23 April 1945

Eleven days into his presidency, Truman spoke sharply to the Soviet foreign minister about Poland. Use it to show the firmer tone after Roosevelt.

Worked example: Lend-Lease is cut, May 1945

Lend-Lease was American wartime aid to its allies. In May 1945, days after Germany surrendered, a US agency stopped shipments to the USSR, and some ships were unloaded. The order was cancelled within a day. On 27 May, Stalin told Truman's envoy Harry Hopkins that the way it was done had been "unfortunate and even brutal". If it was meant as pressure, he said, it was "a fundamental mistake".

  1. Mistrust: Stalin read a muddled order as deliberate pressure on the USSR.
  2. The US view: Hopkins called it "a technical misunderstanding", not policy, and said aid linked to the coming war on Japan would go on.
  3. Judgement: the cut mattered less than how it was read. A small decision became a grievance. Mistrust worked alongside the deeper causes, ideology and security.

Watch out for this

The Cold War started because the USSR wanted to spread communism across the world.

That is one interpretation. Many historians argue Soviet actions in 1945-47 were driven mainly by security in Eastern Europe, and that US actions also contributed.

Check your understanding

Why did Stalin insist on friendly governments in Eastern Europe?

  1. He wanted warm-water ports on the Atlantic and the Mediterranean for the navy.
  2. He saw the region as a buffer against another invasion from the west.
  3. The USA had asked him to occupy the region to keep Germany down.
Show the answer

He saw the region as a buffer against another invasion from the west.

Right. Security after huge wartime losses was central to Soviet thinking.

Check your understanding

Stalin called the May 1945 Lend-Lease cut "unfortunate and even brutal", though the order was cancelled within a day. Which cause of the Cold War does this best show?

  1. Ideology: the cut was meant to spread capitalism into Eastern Europe.
  2. Security: the USA cut aid to stop a Soviet attack on Western Europe.
  3. Mistrust: each side read the worst into the other's moves.
Show the answer

Mistrust: each side read the worst into the other's moves.

Yes. Hopkins called it a misunderstanding, but Stalin saw pressure. Misperception fed rivalry.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • An American diplomat explains Soviet conduct

    Paraphrase of George Kennan's "Long Telegram" from the US embassy in Moscow to the State Department, 22 February 1946.

  • A Soviet ambassador describes American policy

    Paraphrase of a telegram from Nikolai Novikov, Soviet ambassador in Washington, to Foreign Minister Molotov, 27 September 1946.

  • Truman asks Congress for aid

    Paraphrase of President Truman's address to a joint session of Congress, 12 March 1947.

  • Marshall proposes European recovery

    Paraphrase of Secretary of State George Marshall's speech at Harvard University, 5 June 1947.

  • The North Atlantic Treaty

    Paraphrase of Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, signed in Washington, 4 April 1949.

  • the Yalta promise, February 1945

    Extract from the Declaration on Liberated Europe, agreed by Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin at the Yalta (Crimea) Conference, 11 February 1945, as published by the US State Department on 24 March 1947. A US government publication in the public domain; text from the Avalon Project.

  • Truman meets Molotov, 23 April 1945

    Extract from a memorandum of conversation by Charles Bohlen, interpreter and assistant to the Secretary of State, recording President Truman's meeting with Soviet Foreign Minister Molotov at the White House, 23 April 1945, eleven days after Truman became president. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1945, volume V, document 196. A US government document in the public domain.

  • Kennan explains Soviet conduct, February 1946

    Extract from George Kennan's "Long Telegram" from the US embassy in Moscow to the Secretary of State, 22 February 1946. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1946, volume VI, document 475. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the Cominform declares two camps, October 1947

    Extract from a telegram from the US Charge d'Affaires in Moscow, Elbridge Durbrow, to the Secretary of State, 6 October 1947, summarising and quoting the declaration issued by the meeting in Poland that set up the Cominform. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1947, volume IV, document 412. A US government document in the public domain.

  • a Soviet view of American policy, 1947

    An original cartoon drawn for these notes in the style of a Soviet magazine cartoon of 1947, after the Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan. It is not a copy of a real cartoon.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready