Historians' interpretations of the origins

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge which causes mattered most in turning the wartime allies into Cold War rivals after 1945.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of the Cold War

Make a guess

Historians writing in the 1960s, during the Vietnam War, looked again at who caused the Cold War. Who do you think many of them blamed?

  1. Neither side, because the Cold War was an accident.
  2. The USA, for pushing its economic interests and power.
  3. Stalin alone, as earlier historians had argued.
Show the answer

The USA, for pushing its economic interests and power.

Revisionists such as Williams and Alperovitz argued that the US drive for an open door for trade, and use of the bomb, provoked a defensive USSR.

Traditional, revisionist, post-revisionist and post-Cold War historians disagree about who was mainly responsible.

Traditional, or orthodox, historians blamed Soviet expansion. They wrote in the 1940s and 1950s. In this view, Stalin broke wartime promises and the USA responded in self-defence. Herbert Feis and Arthur Schlesinger Jr are often linked with it.

Revisionist historians blamed the USA instead. Most wrote in the 1960s, in the shadow of the Vietnam War. William Appleman Williams argued that the USA wanted an "open door" for its trade and investment. Gar Alperovitz argued that the atomic bomb was used partly to put pressure on the USSR. In this view, the USSR acted in self-defence.

Post-revisionist historians, such as John Lewis Gaddis in 1972, spread the blame. They stressed mutual misperception. Each side's defensive moves looked aggressive to the other, creating a spiral of mistrust.

After Soviet archives opened in the 1990s, post-Cold War historians looked again at Soviet aims. Gaddis argued in We Now Know (1997) that Stalin's outlook and ideology made the Cold War hard to avoid. Others saw Stalin seeking both security and empire. Vladislav Zubok and Constantine Pleshakov argued this. Use these schools to explain why accounts differ, not just to list them.

Traditional v revisionist
Traditional (1940s-50s): Soviet expansion, USA defensive. Revisionist (1960s): US economic expansion, USSR defensive.
Post-revisionist
Shared responsibility; mutual misperception (Gaddis, 1972).
Post-Cold War
Soviet archives; renewed focus on Stalin (Gaddis, We Now Know, 1997).

Real examples to use

Schlesinger, 1967

Schlesinger's article 'Origins of the Cold War' restated the traditional view. Soviet ideology and expansion were to blame.

Williams, 1959

Williams's book The Tragedy of American Diplomacy began the revisionist case. It argued that US economic expansion drove the conflict.

Leffler, 1992

Melvyn Leffler's A Preponderance of Power argued that US leaders sought security so broadly that they alarmed the USSR. This is a post-revisionist view.

Worked example: One historian changes his view, 1972 to 1997

In 1972, John Lewis Gaddis's The United States and the Origins of the Cold War spread responsibility across both sides. In 1997, after Soviet-bloc archives had opened, his We Now Know put more weight on Stalin.

  1. New evidence: the archives let historians test claims about Soviet aims against Soviet records.
  2. Changed judgement: the same historian moved from a post-revisionist view towards a post-Cold War one.
  3. In an answer: name the historian, the date and the evidence each view rests on. Then judge which fits the sources best.

Watch out for this

Post-revisionists say the Cold War was nobody's fault.

Post-revisionists spread the blame and stress how each side misread the other. They still judge the choices each side made.

Check your understanding

Which interpretation argues that American economic expansion was a major cause of the Cold War?

  1. Post-Cold War
  2. Revisionist
  3. Traditional
Show the answer

Revisionist

Right. Williams and others stressed the "open door" for US trade.

Check your understanding

Why did the opening of Soviet archives in the 1990s change the debate on the Cold War's origins?

  1. The archives proved the revisionists right that the USA had caused the Cold War.
  2. Historians could test claims about Stalin's aims against Soviet records.
  3. The archives ended the debate, so historians now agree on who was to blame.
Show the answer

Historians could test claims about Stalin's aims against Soviet records.

Yes. New evidence let post-Cold War historians re-examine Soviet aims, as Gaddis did in 1997.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • An American diplomat explains Soviet conduct

    Paraphrase of George Kennan's "Long Telegram" from the US embassy in Moscow to the State Department, 22 February 1946.

  • A Soviet ambassador describes American policy

    Paraphrase of a telegram from Nikolai Novikov, Soviet ambassador in Washington, to Foreign Minister Molotov, 27 September 1946.

  • Truman asks Congress for aid

    Paraphrase of President Truman's address to a joint session of Congress, 12 March 1947.

  • Marshall proposes European recovery

    Paraphrase of Secretary of State George Marshall's speech at Harvard University, 5 June 1947.

  • The North Atlantic Treaty

    Paraphrase of Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, signed in Washington, 4 April 1949.

  • the Yalta promise, February 1945

    Extract from the Declaration on Liberated Europe, agreed by Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin at the Yalta (Crimea) Conference, 11 February 1945, as published by the US State Department on 24 March 1947. A US government publication in the public domain; text from the Avalon Project.

  • Truman meets Molotov, 23 April 1945

    Extract from a memorandum of conversation by Charles Bohlen, interpreter and assistant to the Secretary of State, recording President Truman's meeting with Soviet Foreign Minister Molotov at the White House, 23 April 1945, eleven days after Truman became president. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1945, volume V, document 196. A US government document in the public domain.

  • Kennan explains Soviet conduct, February 1946

    Extract from George Kennan's "Long Telegram" from the US embassy in Moscow to the Secretary of State, 22 February 1946. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1946, volume VI, document 475. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the Cominform declares two camps, October 1947

    Extract from a telegram from the US Charge d'Affaires in Moscow, Elbridge Durbrow, to the Secretary of State, 6 October 1947, summarising and quoting the declaration issued by the meeting in Poland that set up the Cominform. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1947, volume IV, document 412. A US government document in the public domain.

  • a Soviet view of American policy, 1947

    An original cartoon drawn for these notes in the style of a Soviet magazine cartoon of 1947, after the Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan. It is not a copy of a real cartoon.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready