What this lesson teaches
I can judge how local states, the superpowers and the UN shaped how conflicts developed over time.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the roles of different actors in the development of conflicts over time
I can judge how well diplomacy, peacekeeping and peace talks managed conflicts.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the effectiveness of conflict management
Make a guess
In 1993 the UN declared Srebrenica a safe area. What do you think happened there in July 1995?
- UN troops defended it successfully until the end of the war.
- Bosnian Serb forces overran it and killed about 8,000 Bosniaks.
- Its people were safely evacuated before any attack.
Show the answer
Bosnian Serb forces overran it and killed about 8,000 Bosniaks.
The victims were men and boys. Dutch peacekeepers were few and lightly armed, and air strikes were too few and too late. Srebrenica became the UN's darkest moment.
The UN fed civilians and tried to protect them. With too few troops and a weak mandate, it failed at Srebrenica.
In September 1991 the UN banned arms sales to all of Yugoslavia. This arms embargo hurt the Bosnian government most, because the Bosnian Serbs already held the Yugoslav army's weapons.
The UN Protection Force (UNPROFOR) was sent to Bosnia in 1992. It kept Sarajevo airport open and escorted aid convoys, which saved many lives. But it was there to keep a peace that did not exist. Its mandate tied any use of force to self-defence.
In 1993 the Security Council declared six "safe areas", including Srebrenica and Sarajevo. The UN Secretary-General said about 34,000 troops were needed to protect them. The Council approved only about 7,600.
NATO air strikes needed approval from both NATO and the UN. This "dual key" system made the use of force slow and weak.
In July 1995 Bosnian Serb forces overran Srebrenica. A small, lightly armed Dutch UN battalion could not stop them. About 8,000 Bosniak men and boys were killed.
The UN also created an international tribunal in 1993 to try war crimes. Its judges later convicted Karadzic and Mladic of genocide.
- Arms embargo
- September 1991.
- Safe areas
- 1993: six declared.
- Srebrenica
- July 1995: about 8,000 killed.
Real examples to use
Sarajevo airlift, from July 1992
UNHCR began flying aid into Sarajevo in July 1992. It used an airport deal that UNPROFOR had brokered on 5 June.
Air drops, 1993 to 1994
French, German and US planes flew 2,735 sorties dropping aid to cut-off towns. By August 1994 they had delivered almost 18,000 tons.
Worked example: The UN judges itself, November 1999
In November 1999 Secretary-General Kofi Annan reported on the fall of Srebrenica. He admitted: "we failed to do our part to help save the people of Srebrenica from the Serb campaign of mass murder."
- Provenance: the UN was judging itself. An admission of failure by the body that failed is strong evidence.
- Means: by January 1994, fewer than 3,000 of the 7,600 extra troops for the safe areas had arrived.
- Blame: the report said the whole international community shared the blame for its "prolonged refusal to use force".
- Judgement: the UN failed to protect Srebrenica. The report blames UN errors and the mandate and means that member states gave.
Watch out for this
The UN failed because its peacekeepers were cowardly.
UN troops were few and lightly armed, and their mandate tied force to self-defence. The failure came from the weak mandate and resources that member states gave them.
Check your understanding
Why did the arms embargo hurt the Bosnian government most?
- It applied to the Bosnian government but not to the Serbs.
- The Bosnian Serbs already had the Yugoslav army's weapons.
- The Bosnian government had a large army it could not supply.
Show the answer
The Bosnian Serbs already had the Yugoslav army's weapons.
Right. The embargo froze an unequal balance.
Check your understanding
By January 1994, fewer than 3,000 of the 7,600 extra troops for the safe areas had arrived. What does this show?
- Member states did not supply the troops the plan needed.
- UN commanders turned away the troops that countries had offered.
- The safe areas needed no more troops after the fighting in 1993.
Show the answer
Member states did not supply the troops the plan needed.
Right. The safe areas failed partly because UN members held back troops.