What this lesson teaches
I can judge how well diplomacy, peacekeeping and peace talks managed conflicts.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the effectiveness of conflict management
I can judge how local states, the superpowers and the UN shaped how conflicts developed over time.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the roles of different actors in the development of conflicts over time
Make a guess
European peace plans for Bosnia in 1992 and 1993 failed. What do you think finally changed the war in 1995?
- Russia sent troops to force a ceasefire.
- The European plans were redesigned and then accepted.
- US leadership, NATO bombing and battlefield shifts.
Show the answer
US leadership, NATO bombing and battlefield shifts.
Once the USA took the lead and NATO bombed Bosnian Serb positions, Croat and Bosniak advances changed the balance.
European peace plans failed because no one would enforce them. In 1995 the USA took the lead, NATO bombed, and the balance on the ground shifted.
The European Community tried first. Its 1992 Lisbon plan, and the 1993 Vance-Owen plan drawn up with the UN, proposed dividing Bosnia into ethnic cantons or provinces. The Bosnian Serbs rejected Vance-Owen in 1993.
The problem was enforcement. European governments had troops in UNPROFOR and feared for their safety. The USA would not send ground troops. Russia sympathised with the Serbs.
In 1994 a Contact Group of the USA, Russia, Britain, France and Germany offered a new plan. Bosnia would be split 51 to 49 per cent between a Bosniak-Croat Federation and the Serbs. The Bosnian Serbs again said no.
NATO enforced a no-fly zone from 1993. In February 1994 it shot down Serb aircraft in its first ever combat action. But it used force only in small doses.
After Srebrenica, and the shelling of a Sarajevo market in August 1995, NATO launched Operation Deliberate Force. This heavy bombing campaign hit Bosnian Serb forces. Together with Croat and Bosniak advances, it pushed the Serbs to negotiate.
- Vance-Owen plan
- 1993: rejected by the Bosnian Serbs.
- Contact Group
- 1994: a 51-49 split proposed.
- Deliberate Force
- August-September 1995.
Real examples to use
Vance-Owen voted down, May 1993
The Bosnian Serb assembly at Pale rejected the plan on 5 and 6 May 1993. A Serb-held vote on 15 and 16 May backed the rejection.
Gorazde, April 1994
After NATO air attacks near Gorazde, the Serbs took about 150 UN personnel hostage on 14 April 1994.
Worked example: Hostages, then bombs, May to August 1995
On 25 May 1995 NATO jets bombed ammunition bunkers near Pale, the Bosnian Serb capital. The Serbs struck back by seizing UN troops. The UN's 1999 report on Srebrenica records what followed.
- Cost: by 26 May, over 400 UN personnel were hostage or trapped. Some were shown on TV handcuffed to possible targets.
- Retreat: the hostages were freed in groups between 2 and 18 June. Over the next two months, UN commanders moved troops out of places where they could be seized.
- Change: mortar fire hit Sarajevo's Markale market on 28 August. That evening the UN commander turned the UN "key", and Deliberate Force began at 3 a.m. on 30 August.
- Judgement: fear for their troops held European states back. Once the troops were safer, force became possible.
Watch out for this
The European peace plans failed because they were badly designed.
The Contact Group's 51-49 split became the basis of the final settlement. The plans failed mainly because no one would use force to make the Bosnian Serbs accept them.
Check your understanding
What was Operation Deliberate Force?
- NATO's bombing of Bosnian Serb forces in 1995
- A Bosnian Serb offensive against the safe areas
- A UN aid convoy that reached besieged Sarajevo
Show the answer
NATO's bombing of Bosnian Serb forces in 1995
Right. It helped push the Serbs to negotiate.
Check your understanding
In May 1995 the Bosnian Serbs answered NATO air strikes by taking hundreds of UN personnel hostage. Why did this make European states wary of force?
- Their voters wanted the Bosnian Serbs to win.
- NATO had no aircraft that could reach Bosnia.
- Their own soldiers in UNPROFOR could be taken hostage.
Show the answer
Their own soldiers in UNPROFOR could be taken hostage.
Right. Troops on the ground were exposed whenever NATO bombed.