Low or negative growth

H2 Economics - syllabus 9570, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain the causes of weak growth, unemployment, inflation or deflation and a large trade imbalance.

    Syllabus 9570, 3.2.2(a). Macroeconomic Issues: Macroeconomic issues and their causes; Undesirable economic growth - persistently low or negative, unsustainable, non-inclusive due to factors such as changes in AD or AS, environmental degradation, inequitable income distribution; Unemployment - demand-deficient, structural, frictional due to factors such as lack of AD, technological changes, mismatch of skills, transition between jobs; Price instability - demand-pull inflation, cost-push inflation, deflation due to factors such as changes in AD, costs of production, productive capacity; Persistently large balance of trade deficit or surplus due to factors such as changes in global conditions, international competitiveness, exchange rates

Make a guess

Repeated power cuts stop factories from filling the orders they have. What is holding back growth?

  1. Supply: firms cannot produce, even with orders.
  2. Demand: people are not buying enough to keep factories busy.
  3. Neither: the orders will simply be filled later.
Show the answer

Supply: firms cannot produce, even with orders.

Demand is there, but production is blocked. This is a supply-side cause, which needs a supply-side fix.

Growth can be weak because demand is too low, because supply is held back, or both.

Weak demand can cause low growth. If exports fall, consumers grow cautious or firms invest less, firms sell less and cut output. If real GDP falls for two quarters in a row, the economy is in a recession.

Supply problems can also hold growth back. Poor roads or power supplies, a lack of skilled workers, disruptions or slow gains in productivity limit how much the economy can produce.

For a small, open economy like Singapore, weak demand abroad is the most common cause of a downturn, as in 2009 and 2020.

Low growth that lasts for years does lasting damage. Firms cancel investment, and jobless workers lose skills. Both cut the economy's future capacity.

Demand causes
Weak exports, consumption or investment.
Supply causes
Skill shortages, disruptions, slow productivity growth.

Worked example: Germany, 2023 and 2024

Germany's real GDP fell in both 2023 and 2024 (Destatis, its statistics office). Destatis pointed to tougher competition for German exports, high energy costs, high interest rates and an uncertain outlook.

  1. Tougher competition abroad and high interest rates cut spending on German goods: demand-side causes.
  2. High energy costs raised the cost of making goods: a supply-side cause.
  3. Two years of falling output is persistent low growth, not a one-off dip.
  4. With both kinds of cause at work, one policy alone was unlikely to fix it.

Watch out for this

Japan's output fell in 2020, so the pandemic explains its weak growth.

Check the longer record first. Japan's growth had been weak since the 1990s, with falling prices, so a lasting problem needs a lasting cause.

Check your understanding

A global recession cuts demand for Singapore's exports. What is the likely effect?

  1. AD falls, so real output growth slows or turns negative.
  2. AS falls, so prices rise.
  3. Growth is unaffected, because domestic demand is unchanged.
Show the answer

AD falls, so real output growth slows or turns negative.

Right. Exports are the biggest part of Singapore's AD.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready