What this lesson teaches
I can explain the causes of weak growth, unemployment, inflation or deflation and a large trade imbalance.
Syllabus 9570, 3.2.2(a). Macroeconomic Issues: Macroeconomic issues and their causes; Undesirable economic growth - persistently low or negative, unsustainable, non-inclusive due to factors such as changes in AD or AS, environmental degradation, inequitable income distribution; Unemployment - demand-deficient, structural, frictional due to factors such as lack of AD, technological changes, mismatch of skills, transition between jobs; Price instability - demand-pull inflation, cost-push inflation, deflation due to factors such as changes in AD, costs of production, productive capacity; Persistently large balance of trade deficit or surplus due to factors such as changes in global conditions, international competitiveness, exchange rates
I can explain how these macroeconomic problems hurt households, firms and governments.
Syllabus 9570, 3.2.2(b). Macroeconomic Issues: Consequences of undesirable economic growth, unemployment, price instability, persistently large balance of trade deficit or surplus for economic agents on the standard of living
Make a guess
Prices across an economy fall for two years. Must consumers be better off?
- Yes. Lower prices mean each dollar buys more, so people are richer.
- No. Falling prices harm consumers, because goods lose quality.
- Not if falling demand is cutting jobs and pay.
Show the answer
Not if falling demand is cutting jobs and pay.
Deflation from weak demand comes with layoffs and lower incomes. It is only benign when it comes from rising productivity.
Deflation from weak demand is harmful; deflation from rising productivity can be benign.
Deflation is a sustained fall in the general price level. Whether it is harmful depends on its cause.
Demand-led (malign) deflation: AD falls, so output, jobs and prices fall together. People may delay buying in the hope of lower prices, which cuts AD further: a downward spiral. The real burden of debt also rises.
Supply-led (benign) deflation: productivity rises and costs fall, so AS shifts right. Prices fall while output and jobs rise.
To tell them apart, look at output and jobs. If they fall along with prices, the deflation is the harmful kind.
- Malign
- Falling AD: prices, output and jobs fall.
- Benign
- Rising productivity: prices fall, output rises.
Worked example: Hong Kong, 1998 to 2004
After the Asian financial crisis, Hong Kong's consumer prices fell for 68 months in a row, from November 1998 to mid-2004. Unemployment reached 8.7% in 2003 (Hong Kong government).
- Flat prices fell by more than half from their 1997 peak, so households felt poorer and spent less.
- AD fell, so output, jobs and prices fell together: demand-led deflation.
- Many owners owed more than their flats were worth, so they cut spending to pay down debt.
Watch out for this
Any fall in the price level is a sign of a weak economy.
Not if it comes from lower costs. Cheaper oil or higher productivity shifts AS right, so prices fall while output and jobs rise. Check output and jobs before you judge.
Check your understanding
Why can deflation caused by falling AD become a downward spiral?
- Falling prices make exports less competitive, so foreign buyers cut their orders.
- People delay spending as they expect lower prices, cutting AD further.
- Firms raise output when prices fall, so a glut of goods pushes prices lower.
Show the answer
People delay spending as they expect lower prices, cutting AD further.
Right. Lower spending leads to lower output, jobs and prices.