What this lesson teaches
I can judge which factors shaped the Second and Third Indochina Wars.
Syllabus 8838, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that shaped the development of Cold War conflicts in Southeast Asia
Make a guess
China and the USSR were bitter rivals by the mid-1960s. How do you think this affected their help to North Vietnam?
- Both kept supplying it, competing for influence, and Hanoi played them off.
- They merged their aid into one joint command.
- They stopped helping, because they could not agree with each other.
Show the answer
Both kept supplying it, competing for influence, and Hanoi played them off.
China sent support troops and goods, the USSR sent advanced weapons. Each wanted to look like the better ally.
China and the USSR both supported North Vietnam while competing with each other, and Hanoi used their rivalry to its advantage.
China provided rifles, food and vehicles. From 1965 it also sent hundreds of thousands of support troops to North Vietnam. They built railways and manned anti-aircraft guns. This freed North Vietnamese troops to fight in the South.
The USSR became the main supplier of advanced weapons after 1965, including surface-to-air missiles, jets and tanks. Its greater wealth and technology made it more important as the war grew.
The Sino-Soviet split shaped this aid. Each power wanted to show it was the true leader of world communism. China accused the USSR of being too willing to talk with the USA. At times it held up Soviet supplies crossing its territory.
Hanoi balanced skilfully between them. It took aid from both but kept control of its own strategy. Neither the USSR nor China could dictate North Vietnam's decisions, as the Tet Offensive and later talks showed.
- Chinese support troops
- Hundreds of thousands served in North Vietnam from 1965.
- Soviet aid
- Main supplier of missiles, jets and tanks after 1965.
- Hanoi's strategy
- Balanced between Moscow and Beijing.
Real examples to use
Kosygin in Hanoi, February 1965
The Soviet premier was in Hanoi when US raids began, and Moscow stepped up its military aid.
Soviet missiles, July 1965
A Soviet-supplied surface-to-air missile shot down a US aircraft for the first time, on 24 July 1965.
Supplies through China
Soviet arms went by rail across China. The Sino-Soviet quarrel at times delayed them, which Hanoi had to manage.
Worked example: China scolds Hanoi over the Paris talks, October 1968
Hanoi had begun talks with the USA in Paris in May 1968. On 17 October, China's foreign minister, Chen Yi, met Hanoi's negotiator Le Duc Tho in Beijing. Passing on Zhou Enlai's views, he criticised Hanoi for its concessions and for taking Soviet advice to negotiate. Le Duc Tho replied that events would decide. Hanoi went ahead: after the US bombing halt of 31 October, wider talks opened in January 1969.
- Rivalry: China saw the talks as a Soviet success and feared losing influence in Hanoi.
- Independence: Hanoi ignored Beijing's advice and kept to its own plan.
- Limit: neither patron could dictate to the ally it armed.
- Use: in an essay on the role of the USSR and China, weigh their aid against Hanoi's control of strategy.
Watch out for this
China and the USSR worked together closely to support North Vietnam.
They were rivals after the Sino-Soviet split. They both helped Hanoi, but competed for influence and sometimes obstructed each other.
Check your understanding
Why did fear of China limit American strategy in Vietnam?
- China had signed a mutual defence treaty with the USA in 1950.
- US leaders feared invading the North might bring China in, as in Korea.
- China controlled South Vietnam's army.
Show the answer
US leaders feared invading the North might bring China in, as in Korea.
Right. The Korean experience shaped American caution.
Check your understanding
Soviet arms for North Vietnam travelled by rail across China. Why was this a problem for Hanoi?
- China charged fees for the railway that Hanoi could not afford.
- The Sino-Soviet quarrel meant China at times held the supplies up.
- The railway ran through Laos, where US forces blocked the route.
Show the answer
The Sino-Soviet quarrel meant China at times held the supplies up.
Yes. Hanoi needed both powers, so it had to manage their rivalry.