Sino-American confrontation, 1950-1969

H1 History - syllabus 8838, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how China's and Japan's relations with the USA and the USSR changed during the Cold War.

    Syllabus 8838, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the development of China's and Japan's relations with the superpowers during the Cold War

Make a guess

After 1950 the USA refused to recognise the People's Republic of China. Why do you think the hostility lasted so long?

  1. Korea and Taiwan locked the two into direct conflict.
  2. Because China attacked American bases in Japan and the Philippines.
  3. Because of their different political ideologies alone.
Show the answer

Korea and Taiwan locked the two into direct conflict.

Their troops fought in Korea, and the USA protected Taiwan. Non-recognition and an embargo followed for two decades.

Korea and Taiwan locked China and the USA into two decades of hostility, non-recognition and trade embargo.

The Korean War made China and the USA direct enemies. American and Chinese troops fought each other for nearly three years.

Taiwan was the central issue. The USA protected the Nationalist government on Taiwan. In December 1954 it signed a mutual defence treaty with it. In the Taiwan Strait crises of 1954-55 and 1958, China shelled islands held by the Nationalists. Both times the USA backed Taiwan, and in 1955 it hinted at using nuclear weapons.

The USA refused to recognise the People's Republic. It kept China out of the UN and banned trade with it. It also built a ring of allies around China, through SEATO and treaties with Japan and South Korea.

To China, the USA was the leading imperialist power. In the 1960s China backed North Vietnam, which kept the two on opposite sides. Ideology and security fed each other.

US-Taiwan defence treaty
December 1954.
Taiwan Strait crises
1954-55 and 1958.
Formosa Resolution
January 1955: Congress lets the President use force to defend Taiwan.

Real examples to use

The Seventh Fleet, 27 June 1950

Two days after the Korean War began, Truman ordered the US Seventh Fleet "to prevent any attack on Formosa". Taiwan now had US protection.

Korea, from October 1950

Chinese troops entered the Korean War and fought American-led UN forces for nearly three years.

The 1958 crisis

From August 1958, China shelled the Nationalist-held islands of Jinmen (Quemoy) and Matsu. US ships helped supply the island garrisons, and the crisis eased.

Worked example: The first Taiwan Strait crisis, 1954-1955

In September 1954, China began shelling Jinmen, an island held by the Nationalists. In December, the USA signed its defence treaty with Taiwan. In January 1955, Congress let Eisenhower use force to defend Taiwan. On 16 March, he said small atomic weapons could be used on military targets "just exactly as you would use a bullet". In April, Zhou Enlai said China was willing to negotiate with the USA.

  1. Security: Taiwan was the flashpoint, and both sides were ready to use force over it.
  2. Threat: the US nuclear hint aimed to stop an attack on Taiwan and its islands.
  3. Contact: even as enemies, the two began talks in Geneva later in 1955.
  4. Judgement: hostility rested on a real clash over Taiwan, not on ideology alone.

Watch out for this

The USA and China were enemies only because of ideology.

Security, especially Taiwan and Korea, was at least as important. Hostility rested on concrete conflicts.

Check your understanding

Why was Taiwan the central issue in Sino-American relations?

  1. China had promised Taiwan to the USA in return for aid.
  2. Taiwan was a Soviet base that threatened the American fleet.
  3. The USA protected the Nationalist government that China wanted to defeat.
Show the answer

The USA protected the Nationalist government that China wanted to defeat.

Right. The USA signed a defence treaty with Taiwan in 1954.

Check your understanding

In March 1955 Eisenhower said small atomic weapons could be used "just exactly as you would use a bullet". What was he trying to do?

  1. Warn the USSR to pull its forces out of North Korea.
  2. Tell Chiang Kai-shek he could now invade the Chinese mainland.
  3. Deter China from attacking Taiwan and the islands near it.
Show the answer

Deter China from attacking Taiwan and the islands near it.

Yes. The public hint aimed to make Beijing think twice about using force.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready