The border clash of 1969

H1 History - syllabus 8838, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how China's and Japan's relations with the USA and the USSR changed during the Cold War.

    Syllabus 8838, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the development of China's and Japan's relations with the superpowers during the Cold War

Make a guess

In March 1969 Chinese and Soviet troops fought on an island in the Ussuri River. What do you think this led China to do?

  1. Treat the USSR as its main threat and turn towards the USA.
  2. Rebuild its alliance with Moscow to avoid a wider war.
  3. Start a full-scale invasion of the Soviet Union in revenge.
Show the answer

Treat the USSR as its main threat and turn towards the USA.

Soviet hints of a strike on China's nuclear sites alarmed Beijing, which began looking for a counterweight.

Fighting on the Ussuri River in 1969 made China see the USSR as its main threat and opened the way to the USA.

In August 1968, the Soviet-led invasion of Czechoslovakia alarmed China. The Brezhnev Doctrine claimed a right to intervene in socialist states. Beijing feared it could be next.

In March 1969, Chinese and Soviet troops clashed at Zhenbao Island on the Ussuri River. The Soviets called it Damansky. Dozens were killed, and more clashes followed along the border.

Soviet officials hinted at a strike on China's nuclear sites. China prepared for war and moved its leaders out of Beijing.

The crisis changed China's strategy. Mao decided that the USSR, not the USA, was the greater danger. Better relations with the USA became a way to balance Soviet power.

Czechoslovakia
August 1968: Soviet-led invasion.
Zhenbao Island
March 1969 clash on the Ussuri River.
Brezhnev Doctrine
Claimed a Soviet right to intervene in socialist states.

Real examples to use

Zhenbao Island, 2 March 1969

Chinese troops ambushed a Soviet patrol, killing more than 30 Soviet border guards. A larger battle followed on 15 March, with Soviet tanks and artillery.

A question over lunch, 18 August 1969

In Washington, a Soviet embassy official asked a US official what the USA would do if the USSR attacked and destroyed China's nuclear installations.

Airport talks, 11 September 1969

Premier Kosygin met Zhou Enlai at Beijing airport. Chinese records say they tentatively agreed to keep the border as it was and avoid clashes. Border talks began on 20 October, but China stayed on guard.

Worked example: Four marshals advise Mao, July to September 1969

After the March clashes, Mao asked four senior marshals, including Chen Yi, to study the world situation. Their report of 17 September asked "whether or not the Soviet revisionists will launch a large-scale attack on China". Chen Yi added a note of his own. Ten years of talks with US envoys in Warsaw had produced nothing. He proposed talks "at the ministerial or even higher levels", without first demanding a deal on Taiwan.

  1. Threat: the marshals' first question was whether the USSR would attack China.
  2. Opportunity: Chen Yi argued that Nixon wanted China's help against Moscow, so China could use their rivalry.
  3. Taiwan: the old barrier would no longer block higher-level contact with the USA.
  4. Judgement: the Soviet threat turned China's old enemy into a possible partner.

Watch out for this

The 1969 clash was a full-scale war between China and the USSR.

It was a series of armed border clashes. Both sides prepared for war, but full-scale war did not follow.

Check your understanding

Why did the 1969 clash push China towards the USA?

  1. China had adopted capitalism and wanted American trade.
  2. The USA had promised to hand Taiwan over to China within ten years.
  3. China saw the USSR as its main threat and wanted a counterweight.
Show the answer

China saw the USSR as its main threat and wanted a counterweight.

Right. Security drove the change.

Check your understanding

In 1969 Chen Yi wrote that ten years of talks with the USA in Warsaw had produced nothing. What did he propose?

  1. Asking Moscow to join three-way talks with Washington on Vietnam.
  2. Higher-level talks with the USA, to use its rivalry with Moscow.
  3. Ending all contact with the USA until it gave up Taiwan.
Show the answer

Higher-level talks with the USA, to use its rivalry with Moscow.

Yes. The Soviet threat made the USA a useful counterweight.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready