What this lesson teaches
I can explain how price elasticities of demand and supply change the effect of an intervention.
Syllabus 8843, 2.1.3(c). Government Intervention in Markets: Impact of government intervention on markets may be affected by price elasticities of demand and supply
Make a guess
Which sentence is real evaluation of a sugar tax?
- Inelastic demand means the tax cuts sugar intake only a little, so pair it with education.
- The tax has many advantages for health and some disadvantages for poorer families.
- The tax is a good policy because the government chose it after careful study.
Show the answer
Inelastic demand means the tax cuts sugar intake only a little, so pair it with education.
Evaluation weighs the policy against its aim and says what the result depends on. Here it names elasticity and offers a better mix.
Judge a policy against its aim, compare it with an alternative, and say what the answer depends on.
Good evaluation is not a list of advantages and disadvantages. It is a judgement about whether the policy achieves its aim.
Start with the aim: affordability, less consumption, more output or higher incomes. Then ask whether the policy delivers it, for whom, and at what cost.
Next, compare with an alternative. A subsidy or a direct cash transfer may reach the same people at lower cost than a price control.
Finish with what your judgement depends on: elasticity, the time frame, the government's budget, and whether the policy can be enforced. Also check that a change came from the policy, not from something else at the same time, such as a recession.
- Aim
- What is the policy for?
- Alternative
- Would another tool do it better or cheaper?
- Depends on
- Elasticity, time, budget, enforcement.
Worked example: Holding down bus and train fares, 2024
In September 2024, the government set aside about $250 million to hold down the year's fare rise. Fares rose 6%, under a third of what the fare formula allowed; adult card fares went up 10 cents a journey.
- Aim: keep fares low while running costs rose. Every rider gained, rich or poor.
- Cost: about $250 million of public money, which could have funded other services.
- Alternative: targeted help reaches those in need at lower cost. The government also raised transport vouchers for lower-income households to $60.
- Judgement: help for all riders is simple but costly. It is worth it if many riders struggle with fares. If not, vouchers do more for each dollar.
Watch out for this
My evaluation: it depends on the short run and the long run, and a policy mix is best.
A rehearsed line earns little. Tie each point to the case: which effect is bigger here, for whom, and why.
Check your understanding
A cigarette tax cuts smoking, but low-income smokers now spend a larger share of their income on it. Which criterion does this second point address?
- Efficiency: whether the tax wastes resources.
- Equity: who bears the burden of the policy.
- Effectiveness: whether smoking falls as intended.
Show the answer
Equity: who bears the burden of the policy.
Right. A tax that takes a bigger share of poorer people's income raises a fairness question, separate from whether smoking falls.