What this lesson teaches
I can show how each intervention changes price, quantity, consumer spending and producer revenue.
Syllabus 8843, 2.1.3(b). Government Intervention in Markets: Government intervention in markets can affect the equilibrium price and quantity, consumer expenditure and producer revenue
Make a guess
A clinic caps its fee, and now 120 patients a day want slots but only 40 are offered. Slots open online at 9am. Who gets them?
- Most of the 120 patients, because the lower fee lets the clinic see more.
- The 40 patients who need medical care the most urgently.
- Whoever books first at 9am, not necessarily those most in need.
Show the answer
Whoever books first at 9am, not necessarily those most in need.
The cap does not create more slots. The sharing method decides who gains, and online booking favours people who are free and online at that moment.
A policy only helps the people who can actually get the good.
A lower official price does not mean everyone who needs the good gets it. With a maximum price, the shortage means some willing buyers go without.
Who gets the limited supply depends on how it is shared out: first-come-first-served, online booking, ballots or eligibility rules. Each method favours different people.
The same question applies to other tools. With a minimum price, which sellers find buyers? With a quota, who gets the permits?
In an exam, this is strong evaluation: ask who the policy is meant to help, and whether they are the ones who gain.
- Key question
- Who actually gets the good?
- Rationing methods
- Queues, ballots, online booking, eligibility.
Worked example: HDB flats: who gets them?
HDB sells new BTO flats at subsidised prices, and popular projects draw many more applicants than flats. HDB shares them out by computer ballot.
- Ballot: luck, not willingness to pay, decides who gets a flat at the subsidised price.
- Priority: first-timer families get two ballot chances, and first-timer parents and married couples get three. The rules favour the groups HDB most wants to help.
- Applicants who lose the ballot get nothing from that project, however much they need a home.
- So ask two things: how low is the price, and do the people it is meant to help actually get the flats?
Watch out for this
A rent cap is fair because housing is a basic need and no one should be homeless.
That is a value statement, not analysis. Show who actually gets a home at the capped rent, using Qd and Qs. Then judge whether the result is fair.
Check your understanding
Under a binding maximum price on concert tickets, which method would most likely get tickets to the fans who value them most?
- None of these guarantees it; each method favours a different group.
- A ballot.
- First come, first served.
Show the answer
None of these guarantees it; each method favours a different group.
Right. Queues favour those with time, ballots are random and online sales favour the fastest. The price cap removes the usual rationing by price.