Country responses

G3 Social Studies - syllabus K336 (Social Studies component), 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain why individuals and countries accept or reject foreign culture to different degrees.

    Syllabus K336, Issue 3, Guiding Question 3, Responses to cultural impacts of globalisation. Varying degrees of acceptance and rejection

Make a guess

Since 1996, French radio stations must play at least 40% French-language songs at peak times. Do you think France rejects all foreign culture?

  1. No, it limits some foreign content while protecting its own French music.
  2. Yes, the quota bans English-language songs from French radio.
  3. No, because the quota is about jobs for French singers, not culture.
Show the answer

No, it limits some foreign content while protecting its own French music.

Countries can welcome foreign culture and protect local culture at the same time. A quota is one targeted tool.

Countries can welcome foreign culture, support local culture and restrict some content, all at the same time.

Picture a country that hosts a festival of foreign arts and also pays for shows in local languages. A government can welcome exchange and support local culture at the same time.

Governments may welcome foreign culture to widen choices, spark new ideas and grow arts businesses and links abroad. They also promote local culture. They give grants, money for a set purpose such as a local-language show. They fund schools, archives and apprenticeships. Archives are collections of records kept for the future. In an apprenticeship, learners practise alongside experienced artists. Singapore's hawker culture was added to UNESCO's list of intangible cultural heritage in 2020, after a national campaign.

Acceptance can come with conditions. A government might set age limits, ask for changes, or stop one import or show. It may do this to protect values, social harmony or local businesses. Singapore gives films age ratings, and some content may be cut or limited to protect racial and religious harmony. Limiting some content is different from rejecting all foreign culture.

Each choice has costs. Support uses public money, and limits reduce people's choices and artists' freedom. Countries' needs differ, and people within a country may disagree. A policy's aim does not prove it works. Culture survives only if people keep practising and passing it on.

Support local culture
Funding, education, heritage protection.
Hawker culture
Added to UNESCO's intangible cultural heritage list in 2020.
Conditions
Age ratings and restrictions on some content.

Real examples to use

France's radio quota

Under a 1994 law that took effect in 1996, French radio stations must play at least 40% French-language songs at peak times. The aim is to protect French music from English-language pop.

China's internet controls

China blocks sites such as Google, Facebook and YouTube and promotes its own platforms, limiting foreign content.

Singapore's hawker culture

Singapore nominated hawker culture for the UNESCO list, and NEA's Hawkers' Development Programme trains new hawkers to carry on the trade.

Worked example: A concert called off, 2019

In March 2019, the black metal band Watain was due to play in Singapore. IMDA, which licenses shows, first allowed the concert with conditions. For example, only adults could attend, and songs that might offend had to be dropped. On 7 March 2019, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) asked IMDA to consider cancelling it, and the concert was called off. Many Christians had found the band's songs deeply offensive.

  1. Accept with conditions: IMDA first allowed the concert, for adults only and without some songs.
  2. Restrict: the government then stopped this one concert to protect religious harmony. It did not ban the band's music, which people could still stream online.
  3. Cost: fans lost the show, and the decision limited people's choice. Countries have to weigh harmony against that freedom.

Watch out for this

Restricting one foreign film means a country rejects all foreign culture.

Countries can welcome most foreign culture while setting limits on some content.

Check your understanding

Why might Singapore give films age ratings instead of banning foreign films?

  1. Because foreign films are more likely to be harmful than films made in Singapore.
  2. To allow foreign films in while protecting children from content unsuitable for their age.
  3. To make foreign films less popular so that more people watch local ones.
Show the answer

To allow foreign films in while protecting children from content unsuitable for their age.

Yes. It accepts foreign films with conditions.

Check your understanding

How does NEA's Hawkers' Development Programme respond to cultural globalisation?

  1. It blends hawker dishes with foreign fast food to attract young diners.
  2. It limits foreign food chains near hawker centres so hawkers face less competition.
  3. It trains new hawkers so that local food culture keeps being practised.
Show the answer

It trains new hawkers so that local food culture keeps being practised.

Right. Culture survives when people keep practising it and passing it on, which the programme supports.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready