How hard times fed anger

G3 Elective History - syllabus K336, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain how authoritarian regimes rose in Germany and Japan, and judge how they changed politics, society and the economy.

    Syllabus K336, Rise of Authoritarian Regimes, Learning Outcomes. Examine the rise of authoritarian regimes and evaluate their impact on the political, economic and social context of countries.

Make a guess

In the Depression after 1929, prices for Japan's farm goods fell. Do you think lower prices helped rural families?

  1. No, because the government banned farm sales during the crisis.
  2. No, falling prices cut their incomes while rents and debts stayed high.
  3. Yes, cheaper goods meant families could afford more food and clothing.
Show the answer

No, falling prices cut their incomes while rents and debts stayed high.

Farmers sold silk and rice for less, but still owed rent and loans, so hardship grew and politicians looked weak.

Rising prices, lost jobs and falling farm incomes hurt people in different ways, and all made party politicians look weak.

Inflation is a rise in prices in general. During and after the First World War, living costs in Japan rose. In 1918, rice riots showed the anger over expensive food, while some businesses made big profits. The 1923 earthquake and a banking crisis in 1927 added to insecurity. Workers could lose their jobs or face uncertain pay.

The countryside had its own tensions. A tenant farmer rented land from a landlord, its owner. Rent disputes set the farmer's need to keep enough income against the landlord's demand for payment. Rural people were not all the same: owning land, renting it, or growing different crops changed how hard a crisis hit.

The Depression began in 1929. Foreign buyers bought much less Japanese silk. Families who raised silk cocoons earned far less, but rent and debt repayments stayed high. Many tried to grow and sell more to make up the loss. But when everyone sold more, prices fell even further. Falling sales also put jobs at risk. This was a different problem from before: now people suffered because what they sold earned less, not because prices rose.

Hard times made party leaders look unable to protect ordinary people. The 1927 crisis had also left the banks of the biggest business groups more powerful. Ultranationalists offered an alternative: strong national leadership and expansion abroad to gain markets, land and resources. Unhappy people listened. But this did not prove conquest was necessary, or that hardship made war automatic.

Rice riots, 1918
Anger over the high price of food.
Depression, 1929
Silk prices fall and farm families suffer.
Ultranationalist promise
Strong leaders and expansion abroad.

Real examples to use

Rice riots, 1918

Protests over the price of rice began among women in Uozu, a fishing town in Toyama, in July 1918. They spread to nearly 500 places. Troops were sent in, and the cabinet resigned in September.

Bank panic, 1927

Fear that banks would fail made savers rush to take out their money. 37 banks closed, and the big trading firm Suzuki Shoten went under.

Rice prices, 1930

After a big harvest, rice prices fell by more than 40 percent. Farm families lost income on rice as well as silk.

Worked example: A Nagano family's income, 1926 to 1930

The Koike family farmed and also rented land to tenants in a village in Nagano, a silk-raising area. The historian Nishida Yoshiaki studied its income.

  1. From late 1929, silk prices fell as American buyers cut back, so the family's own crop earned less.
  2. Its tenants earned less too, so the family collected less rent.
  3. By 1930, its income was less than half the 1926 level. Across Japan, landowners tried to take back land from tenants who could not pay, and disputes grew.

Watch out for this

Falling prices in the Depression must have helped families after the earlier inflation.

Families who sold silk earned less, while rent and debts stayed high. Lower prices hurt sellers.

Check your understanding

How did the Depression hurt silk-producing families?

  1. Silk prices fell, but rents and debts did not fall as much.
  2. Foreign buyers bought more silk than families could make.
  3. Silk prices rose so fast that foreign buyers stopped placing their orders.
Show the answer

Silk prices fell, but rents and debts did not fall as much.

Yes. Their income dropped while costs stayed high.

Check your understanding

Why did hard times after 1929 make ultranationalist ideas more attractive?

  1. Party leaders seemed unable to help, so calls for strong leadership sounded better.
  2. Hardship left Japan no choice but war, so people backed the army.
  3. Ultranationalists ran the relief schemes, so families were grateful to them.
Show the answer

Party leaders seemed unable to help, so calls for strong leadership sounded better.

Yes. Hardship gave ultranationalists an audience, though it did not make war automatic.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready