What this lesson teaches
I can describe the political problems new governments faced in Europe and Asia after World War I.
Syllabus K336, Rise of Authoritarian Regimes, Learning Outcomes. Demonstrate awareness of political developments after World War I.
I can explain how authoritarian regimes rose in Germany and Japan, and judge how they changed politics, society and the economy.
Syllabus K336, Rise of Authoritarian Regimes, Learning Outcomes. Examine the rise of authoritarian regimes and evaluate their impact on the political, economic and social context of countries.
Make a guess
In 1925 all Japanese men aged 25 and over got the vote. Do you think that meant elected politicians controlled the army?
- No, because the emperor commanded the army personally in battle.
- Yes, the elected cabinet could order the army as it chose.
- No, military leaders claimed the right to command in the emperor's name.
Show the answer
No, military leaders claimed the right to command in the emperor's name.
Elections did not give the cabinet firm control of the army and navy. Military leaders acted outside civilian orders.
Japan had elections, but elected politicians had no firm control over the army and navy.
A civilian leader is a leader who is not in the armed forces. In Japan, party politicians could lead the cabinet. This is the prime minister's team of senior ministers. The elected lower house of parliament debated laws and spending. Party government grew stronger in the Taisho period, from 1912 to 1926. In 1925, all men aged 25 and over got the vote. The rule that voters must pay a set amount of tax was dropped. Women still could not vote.
But winning votes did not give the cabinet firm control of the army and navy. The emperor was at the centre of the political system. Army and navy chiefs claimed the right to command the forces in his name. They said this right lay outside the cabinet's control. Senior advisers and officials also had a say. So a cabinet could want restraint abroad but struggle to make officers obey.
Many people also lost trust in politicians. Parties quarrelled and faced claims of corruption. They were also close to big business groups called zaibatsu. Ultranationalism is an extreme nationalism. It puts the nation above individuals and can justify ruling other peoples. Ultranationalists attacked deals with other powers, such as treaties that limited the size of navies. They said politicians were making Japan weak. These attacks made restraint harder to defend. But they did not prove that such deals put Japan in danger.
- 1925
- All men aged 25 and over gain the vote; women do not.
- Military claim
- Commanded the forces in the emperor's name, not the cabinet's.
- Zaibatsu
- Large business groups linked to party politicians.
Real examples to use
Party cabinets, 1924 to 1932
In these years, every cabinet was led by the head of a political party. It looked as if elected parties now ran Japan.
London Naval Treaty, 1930
Prime Minister Hamaguchi Osachi's cabinet accepted limits on Japan's warships. Navy chiefs who opposed this, and the rival Seiyukai party, said the cabinet had taken a decision that belonged to the military.
Worked example: The killing of Zhang Zuolin, 1928
In June 1928, Japanese army officers in Manchuria blew up the train of Zhang Zuolin. He was the warlord who ruled this region of north-east China. Tokyo had not ordered the attack.
- Prime Minister Tanaka Giichi, himself a retired general, told the emperor he would punish those responsible.
- Army leaders and his own ministers opposed a public trial, so the killing was covered up.
- The emperor scolded Tanaka, and his cabinet resigned in July 1929. Even a prime minister could not punish army officers.
Watch out for this
Because Japan held elections, the cabinet could command the armed forces.
Military leaders claimed to answer to the emperor, so the cabinet could not reliably control them.
Check your understanding
Why could Japan's cabinet struggle to control the military?
- Japan held no general elections in the 1920s, so the cabinet lacked support.
- Military leaders claimed to command in the emperor's name, not under the cabinet.
- The cabinet was made up mostly of serving army officers chosen by the emperor.
Show the answer
Military leaders claimed to command in the emperor's name, not under the cabinet.
Yes. Elections did not give politicians firm control of the forces.
Check your understanding
Why did many Japanese lose trust in party politicians in the 1920s?
- Parties had taken the vote away from poorer men in 1925.
- Parties quarrelled, faced corruption claims and seemed close to big business.
- The parties refused to sign any treaties that limited Japan's navy.
Show the answer
Parties quarrelled, faced corruption claims and seemed close to big business.
Yes. This made parties look selfish, and ultranationalists used it to attack them.