What this lesson teaches
I can explain how citizens can shape decisions on public matters, for example through feedback and dialogue.
Syllabus K230, Issue 1, Guiding Question 4. Influencing decision-making in public affairs
Make a guess
A town council invites everyone to an online poll about a new park. Thousands reply. Do you think everyone's views were heard?
- Yes, because thousands of replies is a large and useful number.
- Yes, because each resident was invited to reply.
- Not necessarily, since some cannot use online polls.
Show the answer
Not necessarily, since some cannot use online polls.
Work, language, disability and internet access affect who takes part. Numbers alone do not show every group was heard.
Inviting everyone is not enough. Different times, formats and ways to give views help more people take part.
Work, caring duties, language, disability, internet access and confidence all affect whether people can take part. Missing a meeting does not show that someone is not interested. A popular online poll may still miss people who cannot use it or do not know about it.
Government and community organisers can offer different routes. These include evening sessions, phone or paper feedback, venues that are easy to reach, and clear explanations in different languages. Individuals can share their own experience and help others find a way to take part. But they should not claim to speak for others without asking them.
More responses are useful, but numbers alone do not show that every affected group was heard. Check whose views are included, and reach out to people who may be missing. Weigh each view on what it shows, not on how many people hold it. Listening to different needs leads to better decisions, even when views clash.
- Barriers
- Work, caring duties, language, disability, internet access, confidence.
- Remedies
- Different times, formats, languages and accessible venues.
- Check
- Whose views are missing?
Real examples to use
Seniors Go Digital, 2020
A programme launched in 2020 to help older residents learn to use smartphones and digital services, with help at community centres and service booths. Use it for removing a barrier so more people can take part.
Worked example: Our Singapore Conversation, 2012 to 2013
Our Singapore Conversation was a national dialogue on Singapore's future. About 47,000 people took part in some 660 dialogue sessions. Community groups and government agencies ran many of them. About 4,000 people came through sessions run by community and welfare groups. Most talks were held in small groups, not large town halls, so people felt freer to speak.
- Different routes: sessions run by community and welfare groups reached people who might not come to a government event.
- Format: small groups helped people who are less confident to speak up.
- Limit: 47,000 is a large number, but it does not show that every group was heard. Check who took part and whose views were missing.
Watch out for this
Everyone was invited, so the views collected represent everyone.
An invitation does not remove barriers. The views collected are still useful, but check who could actually take part and whose experiences are missing.
Check your understanding
A consultation is held online only. Who is most likely to be left out?
- Students who use their phones daily for school.
- Office workers who use computers at work.
- Older residents without internet access.
Show the answer
Older residents without internet access.
Yes. An online-only format creates a barrier for them.
Check your understanding
At a consultation, 300 residents back Plan A. Twenty wheelchair users say Plan A blocks their only step-free route. How should the organisers treat the twenty views?
- Weigh them on their merits, since they raise a serious problem others missed.
- Set them aside, because most of the people who spoke prefer Plan A.
- Adopt their view in full, because the smaller group's view should win.
Show the answer
Weigh them on their merits, since they raise a serious problem others missed.
Right. Views are weighed by what they show, not by how many people hold them.