Lesson 9 of 9
Closed force triangles
I can use zero resultant force and zero resultant torque as the conditions for equilibrium.Syllabus
Syllabus 9478, 2(h). Use zero resultant force and zero resultant torque as the conditions for equilibrium.
I can use free-body diagrams and vector triangles for translational and rotational equilibrium.Syllabus
Syllabus 9478, 2(i). Use free-body diagrams and vector triangles for translational and rotational equilibrium.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A load hangs from a light knot held by two strings, one on each side. The strings are moved so that they are closer to horizontal. What happens to the tensions?
Show the answer
They rise, to keep enough upward pull for the load
Only the upward parts of the tensions hold the load up. A flatter string has a smaller upward part, so its tension must be larger.
When three forces keep a point in equilibrium, they form a closed triangle when drawn head to tail.
A real example. Simon Stevin's book on statics, De Beghinselen der Weeghconst, was published in 1586. It is famous for the theorem of the triangle of forces.
A knot held by two strings
A light knot holds up a 50 N load through a third string. The third string pulls the knot down with 50 N. Do not also add the load's weight to the knot.
The left string goes 4 across for every 3 up. The right string goes 3 across for every 4 up. Each is a 3-4-5 triangle, so each component is a simple fraction of the tension.
The spatial arrangement and the force triangle answer different questions
1. The strings set the force directions
2. Place the force arrows head to tail
The three vectors are (-24, +18) N, (+24, +32) N and (0, -50) N. Closing the triangle establishes force balance. For an extended body, also check the moments and lines of action.
Worked tensions
Balance the components
Take right and up as positive.
Across: 0.8Tleft = 0.6Tright.
Up: 0.6Tleft + 0.8Tright = 50.
The first gives Tleft = 0.75Tright. Put that into the second: 1.25Tright = 50. So Tright = 40 N and Tleft = 30 N.
The components are (-24, +18) N and (+24, +32) N. Across: -24 + 24 = 0. Up: 18 + 32 - 50 = 0.
Drawn head to tail, the three forces make a closed triangle: the last arrow ends where the first began. The tensions are different, but their sideways parts are equal and opposite.
All three forces act at one point here, so they cannot form a couple. For a body with size, a closed triangle shows zero resultant force but not zero moment. Check the moments as well.
Check your understanding
At a light stationary knot, the left tension has components (-24, +18) N and the right tension (+24, +32) N. A third string pulls down with 50 N. What do these values show?
Show the answer
The tensions are 30 N and 40 N, and all three force vectors close head to tail.
Horizontal components cancel and vertical components sum to 18 + 32 - 50 = 0. The forces are concurrent in the light-knot model, so there is also no remaining couple.
Sine and cosine rules for any triangle
A force triangle need not have a right angle. For a triangle with sides a, b and c opposite angles α, β and γ:
a/sin α = b/sin β = c/sin γ
c2 = a2 + b2 - 2ab cos γ
Pair each side with the angle opposite it. In the cosine rule, γ is the angle inside the triangle between sides a and b. The side lengths stand for force sizes, not string lengths.
Worked triangle without a right angle
Two 20 N tensions hold a load
Another light knot hangs from two strings, each pulling with 20 N at 60° above the horizontal, one left and one right. A third string pulls down with the load W.
Drawn from the same point, the two tensions are 60° apart. Drawn head to tail, the triangle has a 120° angle between the two 20 N sides, and 30° at each other corner.
W2 = 202 + 202 - 2(20)(20) cos 120° = 1200 N2.
So W = 20√3 N ≈ 34.6 N.
The sine rule agrees: W = 20 sin 120° / sin 30° ≈ 34.6 N.
Use the interior angles of the closed force triangle
The downward side is W = 20√3 N, about 34.6 N. It is opposite the 120° angle, and each 20 N side is opposite a 30° angle. Do not put the 60° angle into the cosine rule.
Use the angle inside the triangle in the cosine rule. Putting in the 60° between the strings gives the wrong load.