8867 / 2027
Forces and Moments overview

Lesson 4 of 8

Spring experiments and best-fit lines

  • I can recall and apply Hooke's law, F = kx, to problems and unfamiliar situations.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8867, 2(c). Recall and apply Hooke's law, F = kx, to problems and unfamiliar situations.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

A student plots extension (up the side, in m) against force (along the bottom, in N) for a spring. The gradient is 0.020 m/N. What is the force constant k?

  1. 0.020 N/m, because the gradient of the graph is k
  2. 0.020 m/N, which is already k in other units
  3. 50 N/m, because k is 1 divided by the gradient
Show the answer

50 N/m, because k is 1 divided by the gradient

With extension on the vertical axis, the gradient is x/F = 1/k. So k = 1/0.020 = 50 N/m.

Measure extension from a truly unloaded spring, plot force against extension, and draw one straight line that follows all the points.

A real example. SEAB's H1 and H2 syllabuses list these graph skills. You must choose, by inspection, the best straight line through a set of points. You must also find a line's slope and intercept, and where two lines cross.

Plan the experiment

  1. Hang the spring beside a fixed ruler. Attach a light pointer and record the unloaded length.
  2. Add loads in steps. Include the hanger in the total mass m, and work out the force as W = mg.
  3. Let the spring stop bouncing. Read the pointer with your eye level with it, at right angles to the scale.
  4. Plot force up the side against extension along the bottom, with units on both axes.
  5. Take the loads off in steps and check that the spring goes back to its original length.

Before you start, estimate the force. A 0.3 kg load gives about 0.3 × 10 = 3 N. If that stretches the spring about 4 cm, k is about 3 / 0.04 = 75 N/m. A 0 to 1 N scale would be too small; a 0 to 5 N scale would cover it.

The hanger already stretches the spring. Measure the unloaded length with no hanger, and count the hanger in every force. Otherwise the line will not pass through the origin.

Pointer read from an angle
This parallax error changes the reading. Put your eye level with the pointer.
Pointer still moving
Wait until it stops before you read it.
Ruler has moved
Fix the ruler and measure the unloaded length again. Repeating a reading from a moved ruler does not help.

Choose a line by eye

The crosses below are made-up points for a separate spring. They show some scatter and a small offset. Which line describes the whole pattern better?

Two straight lines drawn through force-extension pointsFive points, from 0.20 N at zero extension to 3.18 N at 0.040 m. Solid line A follows all the points, with some on each side. Dashed line B is too flat. The lines cross at 0.030 m and 2.40 N.Force F / N00.511.522.533.500.010.020.030.04Extension x / m
Crosses: made-up points. Line A is solid; line B is dashed.
  1. Lay a ruler along the trend of all the points. Move it until the points above and below are balanced along the whole line. Do not force it through the first and last points.
  2. Line A fits. Line B is too flat: the low points sit below it and the last point sits above it.
  3. For the gradient, pick two points far apart on your line, not data points. For A, (0, 0.15 N) and (0.040 m, 3.15 N) give (3.15 - 0.15) / 0.040 = 75 N/m.

A straight line is y = mx + c, where m is the gradient and c the intercept. Here y is F and x is the extension, so line A is:

F = (75 N/m)x + 0.15 N

The 0.15 N intercept is what the line predicts at zero extension. Check the force zero and the unloaded length before you explain it. Keep every point unless you wrote down a reason to drop one.

Find where two lines cross

Line B is F = (50 N/m)x + 0.90 N. Where the lines cross, both give the same force at the same extension:

(75 N/m)x + 0.15 N = (50 N/m)x + 0.90 N
(25 N/m)x = 0.75 N
x = 0.030 m; F = 2.40 N

Crossing line A at one point does not make B a good fit. The crossing is not a measured reading either.

In an exam, a straight line through the origin shows that force is proportional to extension, which is Hooke's law. If your straight line misses the origin, check the unloaded length and the force zero before you decide.

Check your understanding

A best-fit line on a force-extension graph passes through (0, 0.15 N) and (0.040 m, 3.15 N). The plotted points at the two ends are (0, 0.20 N) and (0.040 m, 3.18 N). Which of these is the force constant?

  1. 75 N/m, from the two points on the line
  2. 79 N/m, from 3.15 N divided by 0.040 m
  3. 74.5 N/m, from the two plotted end points
Show the answer

75 N/m, from the two points on the line

The gradient of the best-fit line is (3.15 - 0.15) / 0.040 = 75 N/m. Take both points from the line, not from the data.