Lesson 6 of 7
Perfectly elastic collisions
I can apply momentum conservation to inelastic and perfectly elastic interactions between two bodies in one dimension.Syllabus
Syllabus 8867, 6(c). Apply momentum conservation to inelastic and perfectly elastic interactions between two bodies in one dimension.
I can use equality of relative approach and separation speeds for a perfectly elastic two-body collision.Syllabus
Syllabus 8867, 6(d). Use equality of relative approach and separation speeds for a perfectly elastic two-body collision.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A ball hits an identical ball at rest, head on, in a perfectly elastic collision. What happens?
Show the answer
The first ball stops, and the second moves off at the first ball's speed.
This keeps both the momentum and the kinetic energy the same. The speed of separation then equals the speed of approach.
In a perfectly elastic collision, total kinetic energy is conserved as well as momentum. Then the relative speed of approach equals the relative speed of separation.
Take the same two carts again: A, 0.60 kg at +3.0 m/s, and B, 0.40 kg at -2.0 m/s, with A on the left. The total momentum is +1.0 kg m/s and the total kinetic energy is 3.5 J.
Momentum gives 0.60vA + 0.40vB = 1.0. That one equation has two unknowns. You need one more fact about the collision.
Three possible outcomes from the same initial account
Before: A, 0.60 kg at +3.0 m/s; B, 0.40 kg at -2.0 m/s. Momentum +1.00 kg m/s, kinetic energy 3.50 J, approach speed 5.0 m/s.
Every outcome keeps +1.00 kg m/s of momentum. Their kinetic energies differ.
1. Perfectly elastic
Total kinetic energy: 3.50 J. Kinetic energy is kept. Separation speed 4.0 - (-1.0) = 5.0 m/s, equal to the approach speed.
2. Inelastic, with the carts separating
Total kinetic energy: 1.25 J. 2.25 J of kinetic energy is lost, although the carts separate.
3. Sticking together
Total kinetic energy: 0.50 J. 3.0 J of kinetic energy is lost. The carts do not separate.
All velocity arrows use one scale. A cart at rest has no arrow.
Inelastic does not always mean sticking. Only the perfectly elastic outcome keeps the kinetic energy.
Use the relative speeds
Relative speed is how fast the gap between the bodies closes or opens. Before the collision, the gap closes at:
For a perfectly elastic collision, with B still on the right afterwards, the speed of separation vB - vA is also 5.0 m/s. Put vB = vA + 5.0 into the momentum equation:
vA = -1.0 m/s, vB = +4.0 m/s
Both carts turn round. Check: momentum = 0.60(-1.0) + 0.40(4.0) = +1.0 kg m/s, and kinetic energy = 0.30 + 3.20 = 3.50 J. Both are unchanged.
A real example. In 1932, James Chadwick studied the radiation given off when alpha particles hit beryllium. He let it strike paraffin wax, which is rich in hydrogen, and nitrogen gas. He measured how fast the hydrogen and nitrogen nuclei were knocked on. Comparing the two kinds of collision, he found the radiation was neutral particles with about the mass of a proton. He had found the neutron.
Approach and separation speeds are equal only in a perfectly elastic collision. If the speeds differ, kinetic energy was not conserved, so the collision was not elastic.
Check your understanding
Before contact, A is to the left of B with u_A = +3.0 m/s and u_B = -2.0 m/s. Which relative-speed statement is valid for the perfectly elastic separating outcome?
Show the answer
v_B - v_A = 5.0 m/s here, because this particular outcome is perfectly elastic.
The initial approach speed is 3 - (-2) = 5.0 m/s. For a perfectly elastic collision it equals the final separation speed. Momentum conservation then supplies the other equation needed to find both final velocities.