Lesson 5 of 13 / Climate change, food and disease vectors
Ocean acidification and the coral skeleton
How does extra carbon dioxide slow the growth of a coral skeleton?
I can explain how dissolved carbon dioxide lowers seawater pH and leaves fewer carbonate ions for calcium carbonate skeletons.
I can explain physical climate effects, fresh-water stress, range shifts, coastal ecosystem stress and thaw feedbacks.Syllabus
Syllabus 8876, Extension A(b). Explain physical climate effects, fresh-water stress, range shifts, coastal ecosystem stress and thaw feedbacks.
About 4 min
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Seawater has a pH of about 8.1. As it absorbs more carbon dioxide, will it become an acid?
Show the answer
No. It stays alkaline, but its pH falls.
Seawater is slightly alkaline. Acidification means the pH is falling towards neutral, not that the sea is an acid.
The key idea
Ocean acidification is the fall in seawater pH as the sea absorbs extra carbon dioxide. The extra hydrogen ions use up carbonate ions, so corals build their calcium carbonate skeletons more slowly, and skeletons can start to dissolve.
Explore the idea
Follow carbon dioxide to the skeleton
The same temperature in every step: acidification works through the water chemistry, not through heat. Seawater stays slightly alkaline while its pH falls.
Explanation
The sea absorbs part of the carbon dioxide that humans release. Carbon dioxide reacts with water to form carbonic acid, a weak acid. Carbonic acid releases hydrogen ions (H+) and hydrogencarbonate ions. More hydrogen ions mean a lower pH.
Ocean acidification is this fall in the pH of seawater. The name does not mean the sea has become an acid. Seawater is slightly alkaline, at about pH 8.1, and it is becoming less alkaline.
Corals build their skeletons by combining calcium ions and carbonate ions from seawater into calcium carbonate. Many of the extra hydrogen ions combine with carbonate ions. So fewer carbonate ions are left for corals to use.
With fewer carbonate ions, skeletons grow more slowly. If the pH falls far enough, existing skeleton can start to dissolve. Oysters and other animals that build calcium carbonate shells face the same problem.
Acidification is caused by the dissolved carbon dioxide itself, not by warmer water. It adds to the stress of bleaching. Once its coral dies, a reef stops growing and is slowly worn away, so the habitat it gave other species disappears.
Step by step
- 1
Start with the gas
Carbon dioxide dissolves and forms carbonic acid.
- 2
Follow the ions
Hydrogen ions rise, the pH falls, and carbonate ions are used up.
- 3
End at the skeleton
Fewer carbonate ions: slower calcium carbonate growth, and dissolving if the pH falls far enough.
Worked example
Two tanks, one temperature
Corals are grown at the same temperature in two tanks. Tank B has more dissolved carbon dioxide than tank A. After six months the corals in B have laid down less skeleton. Explain why.
One way to explain it
In tank B, more carbon dioxide formed carbonic acid, which released hydrogen ions and lowered the pH. The hydrogen ions combined with carbonate ions, so fewer were left. The corals had less carbonate to build calcium carbonate skeleton, so they grew more slowly. The temperature was the same, so heat was not the cause.
Why this answer works
- Name the ion the skeleton needs: carbonate.
- Use the controlled variable: the same temperature rules out bleaching by heat.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Warmer water makes the sea acidic, and that dissolves coral skeletons." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Acidification comes from dissolved carbon dioxide, not from heat; heat causes bleaching, a separate problem. The sea is also not an acid: it is slightly alkaline, and its pH is falling.
In the real world
How far has the pH fallen?
NOAA reports that in the 200-plus years since the industrial revolution began, the pH of surface ocean water has fallen by 0.1 units. The pH scale is logarithmic, so this is about a 30 percent increase in acidity. The ocean absorbs about 30% of the carbon dioxide released into the air.
Source: NOAA, Ocean acidification (education resource collection)
Check your understanding
Why does extra dissolved carbon dioxide slow the growth of a coral skeleton?
Show the answer
Hydrogen ions from carbonic acid combine with carbonate ions, leaving fewer for the skeleton.
The skeleton is calcium carbonate, and acidification uses up the carbonate ions it needs.
Quick recall
How does extra carbon dioxide slow the growth of a coral skeleton?