K323 / 2027
Thermal processes overview

Lesson 5 of 6

Investigating surfaces and radiation

  • I can explain transfer without a material medium and how surface colour and texture, temperature and area affect radiative energy transfer to or from a body.Syllabus

    Syllabus K323, 8(d). Explain transfer without a material medium and how surface colour and texture, temperature and area affect radiative energy transfer to or from a body.

  • I can apply conduction, convection and radiation to everyday situations and designs.Syllabus

    Syllabus K323, 8(e). Apply conduction, convection and radiation to everyday situations and designs.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

Two identical cans hold the same mass of cold water. One can is dull black and the other is shiny. Both stand the same distance from a lamp for 6 minutes. Which water ends up warmer?

  1. The water in the dull black can.
  2. The water in the shiny can.
  3. Neither. They warm equally, because the lamp and the distance are the same.
Show the answer

The water in the dull black can.

A dull black surface absorbs more of the radiation that reaches it. A shiny surface reflects most of it. So the black can gains energy faster and its water warms more.

To compare how two surfaces absorb radiation, change only the surface and keep everything else the same.

A dull black surface is a better absorber and emitter of thermal radiation than a shiny one. An experiment has to show this with no other difference between the two samples.

Investigate absorption with a fair comparison

Use two metal cans that are the same in every other way, each holding the same mass of water. Give one a dull black outer finish and leave the other shiny. Assume the thin finish changes only the radiation. Its effect on the total mass and on the rest of the thermal response is small enough to ignore.

  1. Keep the samples the same: use the same can material, mass and shape, the same water mass, and the same starting temperature.
  2. Keep the source the same: expose both to the same lamp at equal distances, facing the same way, for the same length of time. Keep the surroundings and air movement the same.
  3. Measure in the same way: place matching thermometers at the same depth in the water, clear of the can walls and base. Use the same lids and the same stirring, if any.
  4. Record the change: read the temperature at the same times, allowing for the response of the sensors. Repeat the comparison from matched starting conditions.
Supplied model readings for the controlled lamp comparison
Time / minDull black can / °CShiny can / °C
02020
22422
42824
63125

Interpret the readings

Compare temperature rises over the same interval

After 6 min, the water in the dull black can has risen by 31 - 20 = 11°C. The water in the shiny can has risen by 25 - 20 = 5°C.

With the matched samples, the greater rise is evidence of greater net energy gain under these conditions. It fits the idea that the dull black surface absorbs radiation better.

The readings do not show that every joule received was kept. Both cans also transfer energy to their surroundings, and conduction carries energy from each warmed can into its water. So the ratio of the temperature rises need not be the ratio of radiation absorbed from the lamp.

A can closer to the lamp may receive more radiation for that reason alone. A thermometer touching the lit metal may read a hotter spot there, not the water. Repeating readings does not fix unequal distances or badly placed sensors.

A cooling comparison needs the same care. Match the material, mass, shape, starting temperature, sensor placement and surroundings. Dull and shiny surfaces differ in how well they emit radiation. But a simple cooling experiment in air also includes conduction and convection. Do not claim those routes have vanished.

One changed condition, one conclusion. If the cans also differ in distance from the lamp, water mass or starting temperature, a larger rise cannot be blamed on the surface. Repeating an unfair test gives the same unfair result.

Check your understanding

A student shines a lamp on a shiny can and a dull black can of water. The shiny can stands 10 cm from the lamp and the black can 20 cm from it. The water in the shiny can warms more. Which of these is the best conclusion?

  1. No conclusion about the surfaces, because the distance changed as well.
  2. Shiny surfaces absorb radiation better than dull black surfaces.
  3. The result can be trusted if she repeats it with the cans in the same places.
Show the answer

No conclusion about the surfaces, because the distance changed as well.

Two things differ: the surface and the distance from the lamp. The nearer can receives more radiation, so the result cannot be put down to its surface. Repeat with both cans at the same distance.