Lesson 3 of 10
Temporary and permanent magnets
I can distinguish temporary and permanent magnets by their properties and uses.Syllabus
Syllabus K326 / K327, 15(c). Distinguish temporary and permanent magnets by their properties and uses.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A soft-iron rod and a steel rod of the same size are put in the same coil with the same current. Both are then taken out of the coil. Which one still picks up paper clips?
Show the answer
The steel rod, because steel keeps its magnetism.
Steel is harder to magnetise but keeps its magnetism once magnetised. Soft iron loses most of its magnetism as soon as it leaves the coil's field.
Soft iron is easy to magnetise but loses its magnetism easily, so it makes temporary magnets. Steel is harder to magnetise but keeps its magnetism, so it makes permanent magnets.
A magnetic material can be magnetised near a strong magnet or inside a coil carrying a current.
- Soft iron: a temporary magnet
- It is magnetised easily, and it loses most of its magnetism as soon as the magnetising field is removed. It is used for the cores of electromagnets, which must stop attracting when the current is switched off.
- Steel: a permanent magnet
- It is harder to magnetise, but it keeps its magnetism afterwards. It is used for compass needles and bar magnets, which must stay magnetised.
Match the material to the job
A crane magnet for scrap iron
Lifting magnets pick up and move scrap iron and steel. The core must become a strong magnet when the current is on, and stop being one when it is off. Soft iron does both, so the crane can drop its load.
A steel core would stay magnetised, so the scrap would stay stuck to it.
Comparing two materials fairly
- Take a soft-iron rod and a steel rod of the same size.
- Magnetise both in the same way: the same coil, the same current and the same time.
- Check how many paper clips each rod can pick up while it is in the coil.
- Take each rod out of the coil and count the paper clips it can still hold.
- Repeat each test and compare the averages.
In the coil, the soft iron usually picks up more clips. Out of the coil, the steel holds more, because it keeps its magnetism.
Permanent does not mean forever. Heating a magnet, or hammering or dropping it, can weaken it.
Today the strongest permanent magnets are neodymium magnets. General Motors and Sumitomo Special Metals developed them separately in 1984. They are used in the motors of cordless tools and in hard disk drives.
"Soft" is about magnetism, not hardness. Soft iron is easy to magnetise and easy to demagnetise. Say what each material does with its magnetism, and why the job needs that.
Check your understanding
A switched device must pick up small iron pieces when current flows and release them after the current is switched off. Which material choice and reason best fit its core?
Show the answer
Soft iron, because it magnetises easily and loses most magnetism when the current stops.
The coil magnetises the soft-iron core while current flows. Low retention lets its magnetic effect largely disappear afterwards, helping the device release its load.