Old fears: Vietnam, Cambodia and China

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge why tensions arose between Southeast Asian states and how they affected the region.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes and consequences of inter-state tensions on inter-state relations and the region

Make a guess

By 1976 Vietnam, Cambodia and China all had communist governments. What do you think their relations were like?

  1. Friendly, because they had just won a common war against the USA.
  2. Close, because communist states backed each other.
  3. Tense, because old fears of domination outlasted their shared ideology.
Show the answer

Tense, because old fears of domination outlasted their shared ideology.

Cambodians feared Vietnamese expansion, and Vietnamese resented Chinese pressure. Shared communism did not remove centuries of mistrust.

Centuries of rivalry made Cambodians fear Vietnamese domination and Vietnamese resent Chinese pressure.

Vietnam and Cambodia had a long, unequal history. From the 1600s, Vietnamese settlers and armies moved south into the Mekong Delta, once Khmer land. Many Cambodians feared that Vietnam wanted to swallow their country.

Vietnam and China also had a history of conflict. China ruled Vietnam for about a thousand years, until 939, and invaded several times after that. Vietnamese nationalism was built partly on resisting China.

Communist links did not remove these fears. In 1930 Ho Chi Minh founded the party that, later that year, became the Indochinese Communist Party. It was meant to cover Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia. Khmer communists, including Pol Pot, came to see this as a sign that Hanoi wanted to rule them.

These old fears did not cause the war on their own. But after 1975 they shaped how each side read the others' actions, and they turned disputes into deep mistrust.

Chinese rule of Vietnam
About a thousand years, ending in 939.
Indochinese Communist Party
1930: one party meant for all three countries.
Mekong Delta
Once Khmer land, settled by Vietnamese from the 1600s.

Real examples to use

Ming occupation, 1407-1427

China ruled Vietnam again until Le Loi drove the Ming out. Vietnamese memory of resisting China ran deep.

Ethnic Vietnamese expelled, 1975

The Khmer Rouge drove most ethnic Vietnamese out of Cambodia soon after taking power, an early sign of its hostility to Vietnam.

Worked example: The Khmer Rouge Black Book, September 1978

In September 1978, Pol Pot's government published a Black Book against Vietnam. It said that Vietnam "has always had the aim of annexing and swallowing Kampuchea". It traced this through centuries of Vietnamese expansion into land once ruled from the Cambodian court. It also blamed Ho Chi Minh's Indochinese Communist Party of 1930. Three months later, Vietnam invaded.

  1. Background: Khmer fear of Vietnamese expansion went back centuries.
  2. Use: the regime turned that history into proof that Vietnam meant to destroy Cambodia.
  3. Limit: the same history had not caused war before; it mattered because leaders used it in 1977-78.
  4. Judgement: old fears made compromise hard, but choices made after 1975 turned them into war.

Watch out for this

Communist states could not fight each other because they shared an ideology.

The Third Indochina War was fought between communist states. National interests and historical fears outweighed shared ideology.

Check your understanding

Why did many Khmer communists distrust Hanoi?

  1. Vietnam was allied with the USA.
  2. Vietnam had refused to support communist parties in Cambodia before the 1975 victory.
  3. They feared Vietnam wanted to dominate Cambodia, as the old Indochinese party suggested.
Show the answer

They feared Vietnam wanted to dominate Cambodia, as the old Indochinese party suggested.

Right. History made them suspicious of Vietnamese aims.

Check your understanding

The 1978 Black Book said Vietnam had "always" aimed to swallow Kampuchea. How should a historian use it?

  1. As a neutral record, because it was published by a government.
  2. As proof that Vietnam had planned to invade Cambodia since the 1600s.
  3. As evidence of Khmer Rouge fears and propaganda, not proof of Vietnam's aims.
Show the answer

As evidence of Khmer Rouge fears and propaganda, not proof of Vietnam's aims.

Yes. It shows how the regime used history to justify its hostility.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • A CIA assessment of the conflict

    Paraphrase of the key judgments of an Interagency Intelligence Memorandum, "Sino-Soviet Competition in Indochina", prepared in the CIA, 14 November 1978.

  • A State Department analysis of Vietnam's motives

    Paraphrase of a briefing memorandum from the Acting Director of the Bureau of Intelligence and Research to Secretary of State Vance, 8 January 1979, the day after Phnom Penh fell.

  • Thailand watches the Vietnamese advance

    Paraphrase of a telegram from the US embassy in Bangkok to the State Department, 4 January 1979.

  • China prepares to attack

    Paraphrase of the minutes of a US National Security Council meeting on the Sino-Vietnamese conflict, 16 February 1979.

  • Lee Kuan Yew writes to Carter

    Paraphrase of a letter from Singapore's Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew to President Carter, 1 March 1979.

  • a Vietnamese diplomat explains the Soviet treaty, November 1978

    Extract from the US record of a meeting in New York, 30 November 1978, between US official Robert Oakley and the Vietnamese representative (named "Co" in the record) in talks on normalising US-Vietnamese relations, four weeks after Vietnam signed its treaty with the USSR. Secret. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977-1980, volume XXII, document 33. A US government document in the public domain.

  • Deng Xiaoping briefs President Carter, 29 January 1979

    Extract from the US memorandum of conversation of a meeting between President Carter, Vice Premier Deng Xiaoping and their senior advisers, Washington, 29 January 1979, a month after Vietnam invaded Cambodia. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977-1980, volume XIII, document 205. A US government document in the public domain.

  • Carter reports Deng's private message, 30 January 1979

    Extract from a US memorandum of conversation, Washington, 30 January 1979, in which President Carter reported to his advisers on his private talk with Deng Xiaoping. China attacked Vietnam on 17 February 1979. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977-1980, volume XIII, document 207. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the UN General Assembly on Kampuchea, November 1979

    Extract from United Nations General Assembly Resolution 34/22, "The situation in Kampuchea", adopted at the 67th plenary meeting, 14 November 1979, on a draft sponsored by the ASEAN states. A UN record.

  • a cartoon about the conflict, 1979

    An original cartoon drawn for these notes in the style of a Southeast Asian newspaper cartoon of 1979, after the Vietnamese invasion of Cambodia and the Chinese attack on Vietnam. It is not a copy of a real cartoon.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready