What this lesson teaches
I can judge which factors, at home and abroad, did most to shape economic change in Southeast Asia.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors shaping economic change in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Domestic conditions, government decisions and outside conditions all shaped Southeast Asian growth. Thailand and the Philippines were similar in size, mainly rural and traded in the same world economy, yet Thailand grew much faster. Which do you think mattered most?
- Outside conditions, because they decided which countries could grow.
- Natural resources, because they fixed each country's path.
- Government decisions, because they decided how countries used the rest.
Show the answer
Government decisions, because they decided how countries used the rest.
Both countries faced the same world economy, so outside conditions explain little of the gap. Thailand's stable, business-friendly policies brought fast growth, while the Philippines under Marcos wasted its borrowing on cronies.
Government decisions mattered most, because they decided how countries used their conditions and their outside opportunities.
Conditions at home set the chances and limits, such as oil wealth or the lack of a home market.
Outside conditions brought chances and shocks. Examples are Cold War aid, the oil boom, Japanese investment and the 1997 crisis.
Government choices decided how countries responded. Singapore and Malaysia used foreign money to build industry. Burma shut itself off.
Private firms turned policy into goods and jobs, but they worked within the rules that governments made.
A strong essay shows how these factors worked together. It compares at least three countries. It shows why similar starting points led to different results.
- Conditions
- Set opportunities and limits.
- External
- Chances and shocks.
- Government
- Decided responses; mattered most.
Real examples to use
Same crisis, different responses, 1997 to 1999
Indonesia agreed its first IMF programme on 31 October 1997. Malaysia refused IMF loans and imposed capital controls on 1 September 1998. World Bank data show Malaysia growing about 6 per cent in 1999, and Indonesia less than 1 per cent.
Worked example: Thailand and the Philippines, 1960 to 1995
In 1960 Thailand and the Philippines each had 27 to 28 million people, and both were mainly rural. World Bank data put income per person at about 100 dollars in Thailand and about 270 dollars in the Philippines.
- Growth: from 1961 to 1996 Thailand's economy grew by about 7.7 per cent a year on average. The Philippines grew by about 4 per cent.
- Outcome: by 1995 income per person was about 2,900 dollars in Thailand and about 1,200 dollars in the Philippines.
- Explanation: both sold into the same world market. Thailand kept steady, business-friendly policies. The Philippines suffered crony rule under Marcos and unrest.
- Judgement: government choices explain why the poorer country overtook the richer one. Both faced the same outside world.
Watch out for this
External conditions decided everything.
All countries faced the same world economy, but their results differed widely. Government choices explain much of that difference.
Check your understanding
Why compare Thailand with the Philippines in an essay on factors?
- Neither economy grew in the period.
- They had identical colonial histories, rulers and systems, so their economies were the one difference.
- Both were similar in size and mainly rural, but their policies and results differed.
Show the answer
Both were similar in size and mainly rural, but their policies and results differed.
Right. It isolates the role of government.
Check your understanding
Singapore and Burma faced the same world economy but ended very differently. Which factor does this comparison point to?
- Government choices, since outside conditions were broadly the same.
- Private business, since Burma had banned all trade with the world.
- External conditions, since the world economy treated them differently.
Show the answer
Government choices, since outside conditions were broadly the same.
Right. A shared world economy cannot explain different results, but different strategies can.