Problems of the Maoist economy

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge which factors did most to transform the economies of Japan and China over time.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that contributed to the economic transformation of Japan and China over time

Make a guess

Commune farmers under Mao were paid in work points however much they produced. What do you think this did to farm output?

  1. It stayed low, because extra effort brought no extra reward.
  2. It made China the world's largest food exporter.
  3. It soared, because farmers worked for the common good.
Show the answer

It stayed low, because extra effort brought no extra reward.

Weak incentives, political campaigns and isolation left China poor by 1978, which is why reform and fast catch-up were possible.

Weak incentives, political campaigns and isolation left China poor by 1978. These problems explain why reform began and why catch-up growth was possible.

From the 1950s China followed a Soviet-style planned economy. The state set prices and output targets and put heavy industry first.

Mao's campaigns did great damage. The Great Leap Forward (1958-1962) caused a famine in which tens of millions died. The Cultural Revolution (1966-1976) disrupted education, management and production.

Incentives were weak. Farmers in communes were paid in "work points" however much they produced, so extra effort did not pay. Factory workers had jobs for life, the "iron rice bowl", however well they worked.

By 1978 most Chinese were poor, and about four in five lived in the countryside. Consumer goods were scarce. China was largely cut off from world trade and technology.

Leaders could see the gap. Deng Xiaoping visited Japan and Singapore in late 1978 and was struck by their prosperity. The Third Plenum of December 1978 shifted the Party's focus to economic modernisation.

Great Leap Forward
1958-1962: famine; tens of millions died.
Iron rice bowl
Jobs for life whatever the performance.
Third Plenum
December 1978: focus shifts to modernisation.

Real examples to use

Cultural Revolution, 1966-1976

University entrance exams stopped from 1966 until 1977 and experts were attacked, which left China short of skilled workers when reform began.

Deng's 'cat', 1962

Deng said it did not matter whether a cat was black or white if it caught mice. The remark cost him in the Cultural Revolution but summed up his later approach.

Worked example: The Third Plenum, December 1978

From 18 to 22 December 1978 the Party's Central Committee met in Beijing. Its communique said "the stress of the Party's work should shift to socialist modernization as of 1979".

  1. Why now: Mao had died in 1976, and Deng Xiaoping had become the leading figure. After the Cultural Revolution the Party needed results.
  2. Problem: about four in five Chinese lived in the countryside, and most were poor. The Party was told to push farming forward "as fast as possible".
  3. Opportunity: from such a low start, simply rewarding effort could raise output fast.
  4. Judgement: Mao's failures made reform urgent and fast catch-up possible. They explain why reform began, not why it worked.

Watch out for this

China's economy grew fast because Mao had built a strong base.

Mao left some heavy industry and a literate, healthy workforce, but the planned economy wasted resources. Much of the growth after 1978 came from removing its weaknesses.

Check your understanding

Why did farmers in the communes have little reason to work harder?

  1. They owned their land and kept the profits for their families.
  2. They were paid by foreign companies at fixed rates.
  3. They were paid in work points however much the commune produced.
Show the answer

They were paid in work points however much the commune produced.

Right. Extra effort did not raise their pay.

Check your understanding

Why did the weaknesses of Mao's economy make fast growth possible after 1978?

  1. Foreign aid had already rebuilt the whole economy by 1978.
  2. Simply rewarding effort could raise output quickly from a low base.
  3. Mao's factories were already world leaders, waiting to export.
Show the answer

Simply rewarding effort could raise output quickly from a low base.

Right. Removing waste gave quick gains.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready