What this lesson teaches
I can explain why governments use policy to raise living standards.
Syllabus 9570, 3.2.3(a). Macroeconomic Policies: Macroeconomic policy decisions undertaken by governments to achieve macroeconomic objectives in relation to living standards
Make a guess
Imported energy prices surge, and some low-income households struggle. Which mix suits Singapore best?
- A stronger S$ plus targeted help for low-income households.
- Cut interest rates so households can borrow to pay their bills.
- A broad rise in government spending for everyone.
Show the answer
A stronger S$ plus targeted help for low-income households.
Appreciation cuts the S$ price of imports, easing inflation. Targeted help protects the vulnerable without adding much to overall demand.
Use different tools for different problems: targeted help now, demand support if there is spare capacity, and supply-side policies for the long run.
Most economic problems have more than one cause, so governments often use a mix of policies.
Each tool should have a clear job. Targeted transfers protect households in need. Fiscal and monetary policy steady spending when there is spare capacity. Supply-side policies tackle lasting limits.
More policies are not always better. Tools can pull against each other, for example if a spending boost adds to inflation that monetary policy is trying to cut.
Singapore usually combines three: the exchange rate to keep prices stable, targeted help from the budget, and supply-side policies for the long run.
- Principle
- One tool for each cause.
Worked example: Japan's 'three arrows', 2013
In 2013, Japan launched three 'arrows' against years of weak growth and falling prices (IMF). They were bold monetary easing, a fiscal stimulus and reforms to raise growth.
- Monetary: the Bank of Japan set a 2% inflation target and bought bonds on a huge scale to push down the cost of borrowing.
- Fiscal: a stimulus of about 10 trillion yen raised government spending.
- Supply side: reforms aimed to raise output per worker, for example by bringing more women into work.
- Each arrow had its own job, aimed at a different cause of weak growth.
Watch out for this
I discuss two policies together, since both aim at the same problem.
Treat each policy on its own: how it works, its limits and how well it fits the cause. Then compare them.
Check your understanding
Singapore faces imported inflation, and MAS steepens the S$NEER slope. Why add targeted help for lower-income households rather than cash for everyone?
- Cash for each household would bring inflation down faster, because incomes rise.
- Targeted help lowers import prices directly, in the same way that a stronger S$ does.
- It eases hardship where prices bite hardest, without adding much to demand.
Show the answer
It eases hardship where prices bite hardest, without adding much to demand.
Right. Lower-income households spend more of their income on food and energy. Targeted help protects them while keeping extra spending, and so demand-pull pressure, small.