Decisions with imperfect information

H2 Economics - syllabus 9570, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain profit as total revenue minus total cost and find the profit-maximising output where MR equals MC with MC rising.

    Syllabus 9570, 2.2.1(a). Objectives of Firms: Firms aim to maximise profits; Profit as the difference between total revenue and total cost; Profit-maximising output occurs at the point when marginal revenue (MR) equals marginal cost (MC) and where MC is rising

Make a guess

A firm aims to maximise profit but ends up producing more than the profit-maximising output. What is the most likely reason?

  1. The MR = MC rule does not apply to real firms.
  2. It does not know its exact MR and MC.
  3. It has stopped caring about profit.
Show the answer

It does not know its exact MR and MC.

Demand and costs must be estimated, and rivals react. A firm can aim for MR = MC and still miss it.

Firms rarely know their exact MR and MC, so they use estimates and rules of thumb.

The MR = MC rule assumes a firm knows its demand and costs precisely. In reality, it has to estimate them.

Demand depends on rivals, tastes and the economy, which are hard to predict. Costs can change suddenly, for example when energy prices spike.

So firms often use rules of thumb, such as adding a fixed mark-up to cost, and adjust as they learn.

In an exam, this is a useful evaluation point. A firm may aim to maximise profit but miss the exact output, because its information is incomplete.

Problem
Firms estimate MR and MC.
Response
Rules of thumb, trials and adjustment.

Worked example: Netflix's price rise, 2011

In 2011, Netflix raised the price of its US plan for DVDs and streaming by about 60%, from $9.99 to about $16 a month. It forecast losing about 600,000 US subscribers in the next quarter. It lost about 800,000, falling from 24.6 million to 23.8 million (Associated Press, 24 Oct 2011).

  1. Netflix expected some customers to leave, but more left than it had forecast.
  2. Its share price fell about 35% the next day (CNN Money, 25 Oct 2011).
  3. It had misjudged how customers would react, so its estimate of MR was wrong.
  4. That is why firms often test a price change on a small scale first.

Watch out for this

Firms cannot know their MR and MC, so the MR = MC rule is useless.

It still guides decisions. Firms estimate the extra revenue and extra cost of a change, try it, and adjust as they learn.

Check your understanding

A firm cannot measure its MR and MC, so it prices at average cost plus 20%. What is the main risk of this rule of thumb?

  1. Its output may sit away from MR = MC, so it earns less than it could.
  2. It breaks competition law, because charging a set mark-up counts as collusion.
  3. It must make a loss, because a mark-up on average cost leaves fixed costs unpaid.
Show the answer

Its output may sit away from MR = MC, so it earns less than it could.

Right. A mark-up is a practical guess. It can leave the firm short of, or beyond, the output that maximises profit.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready