What this lesson teaches
I can explain internal and external economies and diseconomies of scale and link them to long-run average cost.
Syllabus 9570, 2.2.2(b). Cost and Revenue: Internal and external economies and diseconomies of scale and their link to the long run average cost of production
Make a guess
So many firms crowd into one estate that roads jam and skilled workers become scarce. What happens to each firm's LRAC curve?
- It shifts up: an external diseconomy of scale.
- Nothing, because each firm's own size has not changed.
- It shifts down, because the industry has grown.
Show the answer
It shifts up: an external diseconomy of scale.
Congestion and dearer skilled labour raise costs at every size, so the whole LRAC curve shifts up.
External economies come from the growth of the whole industry, and shift every firm's LRAC down.
External economies of scale are cost savings a firm gets because its whole industry has grown, not because the firm itself has grown.
When an industry gathers in one area, specialist suppliers, trained workers and shared facilities appear. Every firm's costs fall, so each firm's LRAC curve shifts down.
Singapore has built such clusters on purpose. On Jurong Island, chemical firms share pipelines, storage and power.
External diseconomies of scale raise every firm's costs when the industry grows too big. Roads get jammed, and firms compete for scarce skilled workers, which pushes up wages.
- External economies
- Industry growth shifts every firm's LRAC down.
- External diseconomies
- Industry growth raises costs, e.g. congestion.
Worked example: Shared cold rooms at JTC Food Hub, 2018
In 2018, JTC said firms at its Food Hub at Senoko could pay to use shared cold rooms, stores and a shared delivery service. They no longer had to run their own (JTC).
- A small food firm that has not grown still cuts its storage and delivery costs.
- The saving comes from the cluster's growth: an external economy of scale.
- So its whole LRAC curve shifts down.
Watch out for this
An external economy of scale moves the firm down its LRAC curve.
Moving along LRAC comes from the firm's own growth: internal economies. An external economy shifts the whole LRAC curve down, at every size.
Check your understanding
Many semiconductor firms set up in one industrial park, and a specialist training institute opens nearby. What is this for each firm?
- An external diseconomy of scale.
- An external economy of scale.
- An internal economy of scale.
Show the answer
An external economy of scale.
Right. The training benefit comes from the industry's growth, not from each firm's own size.