Efficiency: productive, allocative and dynamic

H2 Economics - syllabus 9570, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how a firm's strategy affects efficiency, consumer welfare and other firms.

    Syllabus 9570, 2.2.3(c). Firms' Decisions and Strategies: Impact of firms' decisions and strategies on:; efficiency (allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency); consumer welfare (consumer choice, product quality and consumer surplus); other firms (cost, revenue and profit)

Make a guess

A monopolist keeps its price well above marginal cost but spends its profits on research into better products. Is it efficient?

  1. Yes, because spending profit on research makes up for the high price.
  2. No, because a price above marginal cost means resources are wasted.
  3. In one way but not another: dynamically, not allocatively.
Show the answer

In one way but not another: dynamically, not allocatively.

Price above MC means society would value more output than is made, which is allocative inefficiency. Research can still improve products over time.

Productive efficiency is producing at the lowest cost, allocative is producing what society values most, and dynamic is improving over time.

Productive efficiency means making goods at the lowest possible average cost, with no waste. A firm with few rivals may let waste build up. This is called X-inefficiency.

Allocative efficiency means producing the mix of goods that society values most. In one market, this is where price equals marginal cost (P = MC), if there are no externalities. Then the value of the last unit to buyers equals its cost.

Dynamic efficiency means finding better products and better ways to make them, over time. It comes from research and investment.

Market power can pull these apart. A firm with market power may make less and charge more than MC. That is allocatively inefficient. Yet it may use its profit to pay for research, which can be dynamically efficient. Competition tends to push firms to cut costs and to price closer to MC.

Productive
Lowest average cost.
Allocative
P = MC: producing what society values most.
Dynamic
Improvement over time.

Worked example: A large supplier's choices

Suppose a large supplier adopts a process that uses fewer inputs per unit, but restricts sales to keep its price high. It spends some of its profits on research.

  1. Fewer inputs per unit: a gain in productive efficiency.
  2. Price kept above MC by selling less: a loss of allocative efficiency.
  3. Research: a possible gain in dynamic efficiency, if it works.
  4. Judge each type on its own, then weigh them up.

Watch out for this

A monopoly is bad for society because its demand is inelastic, so it can charge high prices.

High prices alone move gains from buyers to the firm. The loss to society is that the firm makes too little: it stops short of P = MC. Units that buyers value above their cost are never made. That is allocative inefficiency.

Check your understanding

A firm with no rivals lets waste build up, so its costs are higher than they need to be at its output. Which efficiency is lost?

  1. Productive efficiency: it is not producing at the lowest possible cost.
  2. Dynamic efficiency, because it is not yet at the lowest point of its long-run AC.
  3. Allocative efficiency, because its costs are higher than they need to be.
Show the answer

Productive efficiency: it is not producing at the lowest possible cost.

Right. With no competition, there is little pressure to cut waste, so its costs sit above the lowest possible. This is X-inefficiency.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready