What this lesson teaches
I can judge which factors shaped the Second and Third Indochina Wars.
Syllabus 8838, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that shaped the development of Cold War conflicts in Southeast Asia
Make a guess
In 1978 Vietnam signed a friendship treaty with the USSR. How do you think China saw this?
- As minor, because it covered trade.
- As Soviet encirclement, with a Soviet ally now on its southern border.
- As good news, since China and the USSR were close allies.
Show the answer
As Soviet encirclement, with a Soviet ally now on its southern border.
China already faced Soviet forces to its north. It answered by backing Democratic Kampuchea and cutting aid to Vietnam.
By 1978 Indochina had split into camps, with the USSR backing Vietnam and China backing Democratic Kampuchea.
After 1975, Vietnam leaned towards the USSR, which could give more aid. In June 1978 Vietnam joined Comecon, the Soviet-led economic bloc. On 3 November 1978, it signed a Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation with the USSR.
China saw this as Soviet encirclement. It already had Soviet forces to its north. Now it had a Soviet ally to its south. China backed Democratic Kampuchea as a buffer and sent it advisers and aid.
Relations between Vietnam and China collapsed in 1978. Vietnam put pressure on its ethnic Chinese. In 1978-79 about 250,000 refugees, most of them ethnic Chinese, fled to China. China cut all aid to Vietnam.
The USA chose China. Talks on normal US-Vietnam ties stalled in 1978, while the USA set up full relations with China on 1 January 1979. A CIA study in November 1978 saw the conflict as rooted in a clash between China and Vietnam. Each wanted to be the leading power in Indochina.
- Comecon
- Vietnam joined in June 1978.
- Soviet-Vietnamese treaty
- 3 November 1978.
- Refugees to China
- About 250,000, mostly ethnic Chinese, in 1978-79.
Real examples to use
China ends aid, July 1978
Beijing stopped all aid to Vietnam as ethnic Chinese fled, a month after Vietnam joined Comecon.
Salvation Front, December 1978
Hanoi set up the Kampuchean United Front for National Salvation, with Heng Samrin, weeks before invading.
Worked example: The Soviet-Vietnamese treaty, 3 November 1978
On 3 November 1978, Vietnam signed a treaty with the USSR. Under Article 6, "in case either party is attacked or threatened with attack", the two would talk at once about how to remove the threat. They would also take steps for their safety. Seven weeks later, Vietnam invaded Cambodia.
- Vietnam: the treaty gave Hanoi a powerful backer before it moved on Cambodia.
- China: Beijing saw Soviet encirclement, and had to judge whether Moscow would fight for Hanoi.
- USA: Washington drew closer to China, with full relations from 1 January 1979.
- Result: a local conflict became part of the Sino-Soviet rivalry.
Watch out for this
The Third Indochina War was simply a proxy war between the superpowers.
Great-power rivalry shaped it, but Vietnam, Democratic Kampuchea and China pursued their own aims. China, not the USA, was Vietnam's main opponent.
Check your understanding
Why did the Soviet-Vietnamese treaty of November 1978 alarm China?
- China saw itself as encircled by the USSR and its ally.
- It gave Vietnam a claim to Taiwan.
- China wanted to join the treaty but was left out.
Show the answer
China saw itself as encircled by the USSR and its ally.
Right. China then backed Democratic Kampuchea more strongly.
Check your understanding
The 1978 treaty said Vietnam and the USSR would consult at once if either was attacked. Why did this matter to China?
- It meant Soviet troops were already based on China's border with Vietnam.
- It made Vietnam a full member of the Warsaw Pact.
- China had to weigh whether the USSR would fight to defend Vietnam.
Show the answer
China had to weigh whether the USSR would fight to defend Vietnam.
Yes. China tested this in February 1979, and the USSR did not fight.