Singapore and the Third Indochina War

H1 History - syllabus 8838, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how Singapore responded to the Cold War in Southeast Asia, and why.

    Syllabus 8838, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate Singapore's responses to the development of the Cold War in Southeast Asia

Make a guess

Vietnam invaded Cambodia in 1978. What do you think Singapore's position was?

  1. It welcomed the end of the Khmer Rouge regime.
  2. It strongly opposed the occupation, defending small states' sovereignty.
  3. It stayed silent to keep good relations with Vietnam.
Show the answer

It strongly opposed the occupation, defending small states' sovereignty.

If a neighbour could overthrow a government by force, a small state like Singapore could be next.

Singapore was one of the strongest opponents of Vietnam's occupation of Cambodia, defending the principle that small states must not be invaded.

Singapore saw Vietnam's invasion of Cambodia in December 1978 as a direct threat to small states. If a stronger neighbour could topple a government by force and get away with it, Singapore could be next.

Singapore took a hard line within ASEAN. It argued against accepting the government that Vietnam had put in place. At the UN, Singapore's diplomats worked hard in ASEAN's yearly call for Vietnam to leave.

On 1 March 1979, Lee Kuan Yew wrote to US President Jimmy Carter. He said that "Vietnam had changed the 'ground rules' of inter-state interference". Until then, communist states had meddled in their neighbours in secret. They armed and hid rebels. Vietnam had now invaded openly. "The danger is most immediate for Thailand," Lee warned.

Singapore then helped unite the Cambodian groups fighting Vietnam. Their coalition included the Khmer Rouge, whose rule had killed huge numbers of Cambodians. The coalition kept Cambodia's UN seat out of the hands of the government Vietnam had installed.

Lee's letter
1 March 1979, to President Carter: Vietnam had changed the "ground rules" by invading openly.
CGDK
1982, with Singapore's support.
Principle
Small states must not be invaded by stronger neighbours.

Worked example: The Singapore Joint Statement, 4 September 1981

Three rival Cambodian leaders met in Singapore: Prince Sihanouk, the non-communist Son Sann and the Khmer Rouge's Khieu Samphan. On 4 September 1981 they issued a joint statement. They said they wished to form a coalition government and set up a committee to work out how. The talks were tense, and the coalition took nine more months. It was formed in Kuala Lumpur on 22 June 1982.

  1. Principle: a united resistance kept the UN seat from the government Vietnam installed.
  2. Interest: denying Vietnam any reward protected small states like Singapore.
  3. Method: diplomacy through ASEAN and the UN, not force.
  4. Cost: Singapore worked with the Khmer Rouge, a communist movement guilty of mass killing.

Watch out for this

Singapore supported the Khmer Rouge because it approved of its policies.

Singapore opposed Vietnam's use of force. It backed a coalition with non-communist groups to deny the occupation any reward, not to praise the Khmer Rouge.

Check your understanding

Why did Singapore see the invasion of Cambodia as a threat to itself?

  1. Vietnam had openly threatened to invade Singapore once Cambodia had fallen.
  2. Cambodia was Singapore's main trading partner.
  3. It undermined the principle that protects small states from stronger neighbours.
Show the answer

It undermined the principle that protects small states from stronger neighbours.

Right. Singapore's survival depended on that principle.

Check your understanding

In 1979 Lee told Carter that Vietnam had changed the "ground rules". What had changed?

  1. Vietnam had joined the Warsaw Pact, the Soviet bloc's military alliance.
  2. China had stopped backing communist rebels in the region.
  3. Vietnam had invaded openly instead of backing rebels secretly.
Show the answer

Vietnam had invaded openly instead of backing rebels secretly.

Yes. Communist states had once interfered in secret. Vietnam had now sent its army across a border.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready