The outbreak: Kim, Stalin, Mao and Truman

H1 History - syllabus 8838, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how the Cold War played out in Korea and Cuba, as the superpowers competed and looked for allies.

    Syllabus 8838, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the manifestation of the Cold War conflict across different contexts over time

Make a guess

Kim Il-sung asked Stalin to back an invasion of the south. Stalin refused in 1949. Why do you think he agreed in early 1950?

  1. He wanted to provoke a direct war with the USA in Asia.
  2. The UN had asked him to reunite Korea.
  3. China's revolution, the Soviet bomb and US signals made the risk look lower.
Show the answer

China's revolution, the Soviet bomb and US signals made the risk look lower.

Acheson's speech seemed to leave Korea outside the US defence line. Stalin still made Kim get Mao's consent.

Kim Il-sung started the war with Stalin's approval and Mao's consent; the USA responded through the UN.

Kim Il-sung asked Stalin many times to approve an invasion of the south. Stalin refused in 1949, fearing an American response. In early 1950 he agreed. The communist victory in China, the Soviet atomic test and Acheson's speech had made the risk seem lower. He insisted that Kim also win Mao's agreement, which Kim did in May 1950.

On 25 June 1950, North Korean forces invaded the south and quickly captured Seoul. Soviet archives, opened in the 1990s, show the attack was planned with Soviet approval and advisers.

Truman decided the attack must be resisted. The Soviet delegate was boycotting the UN Security Council over China's seat. So the Council could condemn the invasion and call on members to help South Korea. US forces fought under a UN command led by General Douglas MacArthur.

On 27 June, Truman also sent the US Seventh Fleet into the Taiwan Strait. He increased aid to the Philippines and to the French in Indochina. The response was regional containment in Asia, not only the defence of Korea.

Invasion
25 June 1950.
Soviet boycott
Allowed UN Security Council resolutions to pass.
Seventh Fleet
Sent to the Taiwan Strait, 27 June 1950.

Real examples to use

UN Resolutions 82-84, June-July 1950

The Council demanded withdrawal (25 June), urged members to help the South (27 June) and set up a US-led unified command (7 July).

Seoul falls, 28 June 1950

North Korean forces took the southern capital within three days, which shows how unprepared the South was.

Worked example: Stalin says yes, with care, 1950

On 30 January 1950, Stalin told his ambassador in Pyongyang that so large a matter needed careful preparation. It had to be organised so that there would not be too great a risk. Kim then spent almost a month in the USSR, from 30 March to 25 April. Stalin approved the attack on condition that Mao would send help if needed. Kim met Mao in May.

  1. Change: Stalin moved from refusal in 1949 to cautious approval in 1950.
  2. Why: China's revolution, the Soviet bomb and US signals made the risk look lower.
  3. Risk-sharing: Mao's consent meant China, not the USSR, would carry the burden if the war went badly.
  4. Judgement: Kim drove the war; Stalin enabled it while limiting Soviet risk.

Watch out for this

The Soviet Union planned the Korean War and forced Kim to invade.

Kim initiated and pushed for the war. Stalin approved and supported it, and Mao consented, but the drive came from Kim's aim to reunify Korea.

Check your understanding

Why could the UN Security Council act quickly against North Korea in June 1950?

  1. China used its veto to support action.
  2. The Soviet delegate was boycotting the Council and could not veto.
  3. The USSR voted in favour to avoid a wider war in Asia.
Show the answer

The Soviet delegate was boycotting the Council and could not veto.

Right. The USSR was protesting China's seat being held by Taiwan.

Check your understanding

Stalin told Kim to organise the attack so there was not too great a risk, and made him win Mao's consent. What does this show about Stalin's role?

  1. He opposed any war in Korea until the USA had left the whole region.
  2. He backed the war but tried to limit the risk to the USSR.
  3. He planned the whole war himself and then forced Kim to invade the south.
Show the answer

He backed the war but tried to limit the risk to the USSR.

Yes. He approved it, but kept Soviet forces out of open combat and passed the burden to China.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • Truman explains American action

    Paraphrase of President Truman's statement on the situation in Korea, 27 June 1950.

  • A secret plan for national security

    Paraphrase of NSC-68, a top secret report to the US National Security Council, 14 April 1950.

  • China's foreign minister responds to a ceasefire proposal

    Paraphrase of a statement by Chinese Foreign Minister Zhou Enlai, 22 December 1950, as cabled to the UN General Assembly President and reported by the US representative at the UN.

  • The Korean Armistice Agreement

    Paraphrase of the Korean Armistice Agreement, signed at Panmunjom, 27 July 1953.

  • Stalin replies to Kim Il-sung, January 1950

    Paraphrase of a telegram from Joseph Stalin to Terenti Shtykov, the Soviet ambassador in Pyongyang, 30 January 1950, from the Russian Presidential Archive, in the English translation published by the National Security Archive and the Cold War International History Project. Paraphrased because the translation's licence is unclear.

  • the UN Security Council acts, 27 June 1950

    Extract from United Nations Security Council Resolution 83 (1950), adopted at the Council's 474th meeting on 27 June 1950 by 7 votes to 1 (Yugoslavia). The Soviet representative was boycotting the Council. A UN record.

  • Truman's advisers meet at Blair House, 25 June 1950

    Extract from a memorandum of conversation by Ambassador at Large Philip Jessup, recording the dinner meeting of President Truman and his senior advisers at Blair House, Washington, on the evening of 25 June 1950. Top Secret. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1950, volume VII, document 86. A US government document in the public domain.

  • China's warning, October 1950

    Extract from a circular telegram from Acting Secretary of State James Webb to certain US diplomatic and consular posts, Washington, 5 October 1950, two days before the first American patrols crossed the 38th parallel. Secret. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1950, volume VII, document 614. A US government document in the public domain. (Abbreviations as in the original telegram.)

  • MacArthur meets Truman on Wake Island, 15 October 1950

    Extract from "Substance of Statements Made at Wake Island Conference on 15 October 1950", compiled by General Omar Bradley, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, from notes kept by the officials who came from Washington. Top Secret. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1950, volume VII, document 680. A US government document in the public domain.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready