What this lesson teaches
I can judge how the Cold War played out in Korea and Cuba, as the superpowers competed and looked for allies.
Syllabus 8838, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the manifestation of the Cold War conflict across different contexts over time
Make a guess
On 27 October 1962 a US spy plane was shot down over Cuba, at the height of the crisis. What do you think Kennedy did next?
- Held back and offered a deal, with a secret promise on Turkey.
- Ordered air strikes on the missile sites in Cuba that same night.
- Invaded Cuba with US ground forces.
Show the answer
Held back and offered a deal, with a secret promise on Turkey.
Kennedy accepted a no-invasion pledge publicly and agreed privately to remove US missiles from Turkey. Khrushchev agreed on 28 October.
Kennedy chose a naval quarantine over an air strike, and a public no-invasion pledge plus a secret deal on Turkey ended the crisis.
On 14 October 1962, a U-2 spy plane photographed missile sites in Cuba. From 16 October, Kennedy talked through his options with a small group of advisers, later called ExComm. Military leaders wanted air strikes and an invasion. Kennedy chose a naval quarantine, a blockade to stop more weapons reaching Cuba.
On 22 October, Kennedy spoke on television. He announced the quarantine and demanded that the missiles be removed. On 24 October, Soviet ships nearing the quarantine line stopped or turned back.
On 26 October, Khrushchev sent a letter. It suggested the missiles could go if the USA promised not to invade Cuba. On 27 October, a second letter also demanded the removal of US missiles from Turkey. The same day, a U-2 was shot down over Cuba and its pilot was killed. This was the most dangerous day.
In public, Kennedy answered the first letter. He promised not to invade Cuba if the missiles went. In private, Robert Kennedy told the Soviet ambassador, Anatoly Dobrynin, that the Jupiters in Turkey would go later. A public swap would have looked like selling out a NATO ally under threat, so the promise had to stay secret. On 28 October, Khrushchev said the missiles would be taken out.
- Quarantine announced
- 22 October 1962.
- Black Saturday
- 27 October: U-2 shot down; Turkey demand.
- Withdrawal announced
- 28 October 1962.
Real examples to use
Kennedy's warning, 4 September 1962
Kennedy warned the USSR in public not to put weapons for attack in Cuba. The October photographs turned that warning into a test of his word.
The UN Security Council, 25 October 1962
The US ambassador, Adlai Stevenson, showed photos of the missile sites. The Soviet ambassador, Valerian Zorin, called them forged. The proof was now public.
Major Rudolf Anderson, 27 October 1962
His U-2 was hit by Soviet missiles fired on the orders of two Soviet generals in Cuba, without Khrushchev's approval. It showed the crisis could slip out of the leaders' control.
Worked example: The air strike briefing, 21 October 1962
On 21 October, Kennedy met General Walter Sweeney of Tactical Air Command. Sweeney was sure a strike would be "successful". But the meeting notes add that "it was not likely that all of the known missiles would be destroyed." General Maxwell Taylor told Kennedy: "The best we can offer you is to destroy 90% of the known missiles." The next evening, Kennedy announced the quarantine instead.
- Risk: any missile left after a strike could be fired at an American city.
- Choice: a quarantine stopped new weapons and gave Khrushchev time to back down.
- Limit: it did not remove the missiles already in Cuba, so the strike plan stayed ready.
- Use: this evidence helps you judge how far caution, not only firmness, ended the crisis.
Watch out for this
Khrushchev simply backed down and got nothing in return.
He got a public US pledge not to invade Cuba and a secret promise to remove the Jupiter missiles from Turkey.
Check your understanding
What did the USA secretly promise to end the crisis?
- To end the trade embargo on Cuba
- To withdraw its troops from West Berlin within a year
- To remove its Jupiter missiles from Turkey later
Show the answer
To remove its Jupiter missiles from Turkey later
Right. This was kept secret at Kennedy's insistence.
Check your understanding
Khrushchev's second letter, on 27 October, added a demand about Turkey. Why did Kennedy answer the first letter in public instead?
- The second letter had come from Castro in Havana, not from Khrushchev in Moscow.
- A public deal on Turkey would look like betraying a NATO ally under threat.
- The USA had already removed its Jupiter missiles from Turkey earlier that year.
Show the answer
A public deal on Turkey would look like betraying a NATO ally under threat.
Yes. So the promise on the Jupiters was made in secret, and the public deal was the no-invasion pledge.