What this lesson teaches
I can judge whether part of a passage, such as its ending, does its job, and explain why.
Syllabus 8881, Paper 2 questions: Passage 1. Questions cover literal comprehension, inference, analysis, evaluation and synthesis of ideas based on Passage 1 (9-11 marks).
I can break a passage into its parts and explain how they work together to make the writer's point.
Syllabus 8881, 3.1.1. analyse arguments to understand the parts of the given texts and how the parts relate to one another to convey an overall meaning
Make a guess
A writer claims that corner shops hold neighbourhoods together, and proves it with one story about one shopkeeper. Before you read: how convincing is one story as proof?
- Partly: it shows the claim can be true, not that it usually is
- Fully, because a vivid and detailed story will always persuade its readers
- Not at all, because a single story is only the writer's own opinion
Show the answer
Partly: it shows the claim can be true, not that it usually is
Right. One case shows that something can happen. A general claim needs more cases, or a reason to think this one is typical.
Give a clear judgement, then show how the part does its job, or fails to, with words from the passage.
Evaluation questions ask you to judge part of a passage. They ask 'Is the ending effective?' or 'How convincing is the writer's example?'. They come among the Passage 1 questions.
Every answer needs two parts. First, give a clear judgement: yes, no or partly. Then give a reason that shows how the part works, using words from the passage. A judgement alone proves nothing. A reason with no judgement does not answer the question.
Judge the part against its job. An ending should close the paragraph or passage well. It may return to an earlier idea, sum up the writer's view, or leave the reader with a strong feeling. An opening should draw the reader in and set up what follows.
Sort these
Paragraph 4 ends: 'When the corner shop goes, the neighbourhood goes with it.' Is each reason for calling this ending effective one that can earn credit, or empty praise?
Groups: Can earn credit, Empty praise.
- The writer uses repetition, a literary device, to end the paragraph.
- It widens one shop's story into a warning about every neighbourhood.
- It is a powerful and memorable sentence that grabs attention.
- It is short and simple, so it is easy for the reader to follow.
- Its repeated 'goes' ties the shop's fate to the neighbourhood's, so the warning sticks.
- After two small cases, it states the writer's whole view in one line.
Show the answer
Can earn credit
- It widens one shop's story into a warning about every neighbourhood. It says what the line does for the paragraph and the reader: a single case becomes a general warning.
- Its repeated 'goes' ties the shop's fate to the neighbourhood's, so the warning sticks. It explains how the sentence's shape works: the repeated word links the two losses, which is the writer's point.
- After two small cases, it states the writer's whole view in one line. It names a job the ending does, summing up the writer's view, and shows how: from small cases to one general line.
Empty praise
- The writer uses repetition, a literary device, to end the paragraph. Naming repetition earns nothing alone. Say what repeating 'goes' does: it ties the shop's loss to the neighbourhood's.
- It is a powerful and memorable sentence that grabs attention. This could describe any strong sentence. Explain what this one does for the paragraph and the writer's view.
- It is short and simple, so it is easy for the reader to follow. Being short is not a reason on its own. Say what the short line does: here, it sums up the paragraph.
An example should prove the point it follows. It convinces when it is specific, clearly linked to the claim and typical of what the claim describes. One vivid story can show that something happens. It cannot show that it happens often.
Effective is not the same as convincing. A line can end a paragraph well and still claim more than the paragraph proves. Read which word the question uses, and judge that.
Avoid praise that fits any passage. 'It is effective because it is interesting' or 'because it is short' says nothing. Say what this part does, as the worked example below shows.
- Evaluation answer
- A clear judgement, then a reason drawn from the passage.
- Jobs of an ending
- Return to an earlier idea, sum up the view, or leave a strong feeling.
- A convincing example
- Specific, linked to the claim, and typical, not a rare case.
Practice passage (our own)
Paragraph 3 of a passage on neighbourhood shops
Mr Tan's daughter has offered to put the shop online. He thanks her and changes the subject. Each evening he still wipes the counter, straightens the tins of biscuits and leaves the radio on low, in case someone drops by. Most nights, no one does.
Paragraph 4
Some will call this progress. Groceries now reach the door within the hour, often for less than Mr Tan could charge. But a delivery rider will not notice that Madam Lim on the fourth floor has stopped buying her usual loaf. Nor will a rider see that the boy from the corner unit has not come in since his exams. Mr Tan noticed such things for forty years. When the corner shop goes, the neighbourhood goes with it.
Try it on a new passage: Set 2, crowds and civility (our own)
Passage 1, paragraph 3
The online ticket rush is no better. Thousands refresh a page at the same second, and the losers turn on one another in comment threads, or pay a tout three times the price. At the stadium gate, the usher smiles the tired smile of someone who has said 'please queue' a thousand times.
Your question
Is the last sentence an effective ending to paragraph 3? Give a judgement and one reason drawn from the paragraph.
Check your answer has
A clear judgement, such as yes. A reason that says what the ending does. After the online scramble and the touts, it ends on one tired usher who has asked people to queue again and again. So the reader feels that rude crowds are an everyday problem, not a one-off.
Worked example: Judging an opening
Question: Is the first sentence of paragraph 3 an effective opening? 'Mr Tan's daughter has offered to put the shop online.'
- Name the job: an opening should draw the reader in and set up what follows.
- See what follows: Mr Tan thanks her, changes the subject, and keeps tidying the shop each evening.
- Say what the opening does: it offers him a way out, so everything after it reads as his answer.
- Write it: yes, because it sets up a choice, so his evening routine reads as a quiet refusal.
Watch out for this
If I say an ending is effective because it is short and memorable, I have answered the question.
That praise fits almost any ending. Say what this ending does, such as sum up the writer's view or answer an earlier hope, and quote the words that show it.
Check your understanding
Is 'Most nights, no one does' an effective ending for the paragraph? Which answer is strongest?
- Yes, because it is short, simple and easy to read
- No, because it ends the paragraph without telling us what Mr Tan should do next
- Yes, it answers 'in case someone drops by' with a bleak 'no one does'
Show the answer
Yes, it answers 'in case someone drops by' with a bleak 'no one does'
Right. It gives a judgement and shows how the ending links back to an earlier phrase to leave a strong feeling.
Check your understanding
Set 2, Passage 1, paragraph 3 ends: 'At the stadium gate, the usher smiles the tired smile of someone who has said "please queue" a thousand times.' Is this an effective ending?
- Yes, because the exaggeration 'a thousand times' makes the ending vivid and memorable
- No, because the usher works at a stadium gate and never buys a ticket online
- Yes: after the ticket scramble, one weary usher shows rudeness is routine
Show the answer
Yes: after the ticket scramble, one weary usher shows rudeness is routine
Right. It gives a judgement and says what the ending does: it narrows the scene to one person who meets the same rudeness every day.