Budget balance and fiscal sustainability

H1 Economics - syllabus 8843, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain fiscal, monetary and supply-side policy and judge how well each works.

    Syllabus 8843, 3.2.3(b). Macroeconomic Policies: Policy measures and their effectiveness in achieving macroeconomic objectives:; Fiscal policy - How discretionary fiscal policy can influence the level of economic activities and living standards through government spending and taxation; Supply-side policies - How supply-side policies can improve quantity, quality and mobility of factors of production to increase the productive capacity of an economy and hence affect living standards; Monetary policy - How monetary policy can influence the level of economic activities and living standards through the management of exchange rates (case of Singapore) and interest rates

Make a guess

The budget surplus shrinks from 10 to 2 because spending rose. Has fiscal policy become more contractionary?

  1. Yes. Any surplus means contractionary policy.
  2. No change, because the budget is still in surplus.
  3. No. It became more expansionary than the year before.
Show the answer

No. It became more expansionary than the year before.

A surplus still takes more out than it puts in, but a smaller surplus means more spending than before, which adds to AD.

A deficit this year is not the whole story; what matters is whether the government can keep meeting its commitments.

A budget deficit means government spending is greater than revenue this year. A surplus means revenue is greater. To read the stance, compare with last year. A smaller surplus or a bigger deficit means policy has become more expansionary.

A deficit adds to government debt, which must be repaid, with interest, in future.

Fiscal sustainability means the government can keep meeting its commitments without debt rising out of control. It depends on future tax revenue, spending needs such as care for an ageing population, and interest costs.

Singapore aims to balance its budget over each term of government. It can also spend part of the returns on its reserves, known as the Net Investment Returns Contribution. This gives it room to act in a crisis.

Deficit
Spending > revenue this year.
Sustainable
Commitments can be met without runaway debt.

Worked example: The UK's mini-budget, 2022

On 23 September 2022, the UK announced about 45 billion pounds of tax cuts with no plan to pay for them. Three days later, the pound fell to a record low of about US$1.03.

  1. Lenders feared UK debt would grow out of control, so they asked for higher interest on government bonds.
  2. On 28 September, the Bank of England stepped in to buy bonds and calm the market.
  3. Most of the tax cuts were reversed on 17 October, and the Prime Minister resigned days later.
  4. Lenders judge sustainability too: a plan they doubt can raise borrowing costs at once.

Watch out for this

Fiscal sustainability means growth that does not harm the environment.

That is sustainable growth. Fiscal sustainability is about public finances: whether the government can meet its spending and debt costs over the long term.

Check your understanding

Which government's finances look least sustainable?

  1. One that runs a deficit for a year to fight a recession, then returns to balance.
  2. One whose surplus has shrunk because it spent more on hospitals this year.
  3. One whose debt keeps growing faster than the economy, with interest taking a rising share of revenue.
Show the answer

One whose debt keeps growing faster than the economy, with interest taking a rising share of revenue.

Right. Debt growing faster than income, with ever larger interest bills, cannot go on for ever.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready