When both curves shift

H1 Economics - syllabus 8843, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can work out how shifts in demand or supply change price, quantity, consumer spending and producer revenue.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.1.2(f). Demand and Supply Analysis and its Applications: Changes in demand and supply can affect equilibrium price and quantity, consumer expenditure and producer revenue

Make a guess

Demand for durians rises at the same time as a poor harvest cuts supply. What can you say for certain?

  1. Price and quantity both rise, as more people chase the fruit.
  2. The price rises; the change in quantity is uncertain.
  3. Quantity falls; the change in price is uncertain.
Show the answer

The price rises; the change in quantity is uncertain.

Both shifts push the price up. Demand rising pushes quantity up and supply falling pushes it down, so quantity depends on which shift is bigger.

When both curves shift, one outcome is certain and the other depends on which shift is bigger.

Analyse each shift on its own first, then combine them.

If demand rises and supply falls, both push the price up. The price definitely rises. But demand rising pushes quantity up while supply falling pushes it down, so the change in quantity depends on which shift is larger.

Every pair of shifts works the same way: one outcome is certain and the other is uncertain. The table below lists all four cases.

In an exam answer, this uncertainty is useful evaluation. State which outcome is certain, then explain what the other depends on.

Same direction for an outcome
That outcome is certain.
Opposite directions
That outcome depends on the relative sizes of the shifts.
Both curves shift: one outcome is certain, the other depends on which shift is bigger.
DemandSupplyPriceQuantity
RisesRisesDepends on the sizesRises
FallsFallsDepends on the sizesFalls
RisesFallsRisesDepends on the sizes
FallsRisesFallsDepends on the sizes

Worked example: Air travel through Changi, 2020

In 2020, COVID-19 closed borders around the world. Changi Airport handled 11.8 million passengers, down from 68.3 million in 2019.

  1. Demand fell: travellers cancelled trips, and many could not enter other countries. Demand for flights shifted left.
  2. Supply fell: airlines grounded planes and cut flights. Supply shifted left too.
  3. Both shifts cut the number of trips, so the fall in quantity was certain.
  4. The fare could rise or fall: less demand pushes it down, fewer flights push it up. It depends on which shift was bigger.

Watch out for this

Both curves shifted, so the change in quantity is uncertain. That is my conclusion.

Uncertain is where the analysis starts. Use the data to judge which shift was bigger: if the price rose and quantity fell, the fall in supply was larger. Examiners expect a clear judgement.

Check your understanding

In December, more shoppers want air tickets to Bangkok, and airlines add extra flights. What can you say about tickets sold and their price?

  1. Both the price and the number of tickets sold rise.
  2. The price rises; the number sold may rise or fall.
  3. More tickets are sold; the price may rise or fall.
Show the answer

More tickets are sold; the price may rise or fall.

Right. Both shifts raise the number sold, but more demand pushes price up while more supply pushes it down.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready