Source D, a ministry statement promoting a new law, says complaints halved, so "the problem is solved". Source E, an independent association, found residents still waiting for repayment. Pick a move and see which level it reaches.
Provenance only
- Level reached: Level 1 or 2. Provenance alone does not test what D claims.
- Next step: Look at whether D's evidence supports its claim.
Who made a source is a reason to check it, not proof that it is wrong.
Cross-reference E
- Level reached: Level 3 or 4. E shows residents still waiting, which contradicts "solved".
- Next step: Explain why the ministry might overstate its success.
Cross-reference is the move most mark schemes reward.
Add purpose (CAP)
- Level reached: Top level. The claim is tested and the reason for overstating it is explained.
- Watch for: Keep the purpose tied to the words in D, not to a general claim about governments.
CAP turns a tested claim into an explained judgement.