Why the Weimar Republic struggled

G3 Full History - syllabus K330, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can describe the political problems new governments faced in Europe and Asia after World War I.

    Syllabus K330, Rise of Authoritarian Regimes, Learning Outcomes. Demonstrate awareness of political developments after World War I.

  • I can explain how authoritarian regimes rose in Germany and Japan, and judge how they changed politics, society and the economy.

    Syllabus K330, Rise of Authoritarian Regimes, Learning Outcomes. Examine the rise of authoritarian regimes and evaluate their impact on the political, social and economic context of countries.

Make a guess

Germany's 1919 constitution gave men and women the vote and a fair share of seats to every party. What do you think made this democracy hard to run?

  1. The Kaiser still controlled the government quietly from behind the scenes.
  2. Women voting for the first time split the country into angry camps.
  3. Many parties won seats, so governments needed shaky coalitions to act.
Show the answer

Many parties won seats, so governments needed shaky coalitions to act.

Proportional representation gave seats to many parties. Coalitions broke up when partners fell out, and from 1930 governments ruled by emergency decree instead.

Unstable coalitions pushed governments to rule by emergency decree from 1930, moving power to the president, while many Germans rejected the republic.

The Weimar Republic was Germany's democracy after the First World War. The emperor, Kaiser Wilhelm II, lost power in 1918. The 1919 constitution set the rules for how Germany was governed. Men and women voted for the Reichstag, Germany's parliament.

Seats were shared by proportional representation: a party's share of seats roughly matched its share of votes. So many parties won seats, and no party ever won a majority on its own. Governments were coalitions, groups of parties agreeing to govern together. If the partners fell out, the government fell. Sharing power was not a failure in itself. The problem grew when parties refused to work together or wanted to end democracy.

Article 48 let the president rule by emergency decree in a crisis. A decree was an order that became law without a vote in parliament. In March 1930, the last coalition with a majority broke up. From then on, chancellors ruled through the president's decrees, not parliament's votes.

This moved real power from parliament to President Hindenburg and his advisers. A chancellor now needed the president's trust more than a Reichstag majority. This later let Hitler become chancellor without a majority.

The republic was unpopular with many Germans from the start. Its leaders had agreed to end the war in November 1918 and signed the Treaty of Versailles in 1919. Nationalists called them the November criminals. They spread the stab-in-the-back myth, the false claim that traitors at home, not defeat in battle, had lost the war. Armed groups on the left and the right tried to overthrow it by force.

In a democracy, parties compete, and elected members can limit the government. Authoritarian rule puts power in a few hands and bans opposition. The constitution's weaknesses did not make Hitler's rise certain, but made it much easier.

March 1930
Last coalition with a majority falls; rule by decree begins.
Proportional representation
Seats match vote share, so coalitions are common.
Article 48
Let the president rule by emergency decree.

Real examples to use

Rule by decree, 1930 to 1932

When the Reichstag rejected Chancellor Bruening's budget in 1930, Hindenburg passed it by decree. In 1932 he issued 66 decrees, while the Reichstag passed only 5 laws.

Kapp Putsch, March 1920

Nationalist troops seized Berlin and the government fled. The army would not fire on them, but a general strike by workers ended the coup within days.

Votes against the republic, July 1932

The Nazis and the Communists, both enemies of the republic, together won more than half the seats. No government could win a majority without one of them.

Worked example: Same rules, different results

Germany used proportional representation in both the good years of the mid-1920s and the crisis after 1929.

  1. In the good years, parties could still agree and form governments.
  2. After 1929, the crisis made agreement much harder, so governments relied on the president.
  3. So the crisis and political choices, not the voting rules alone, broke the system.

Watch out for this

Article 48 elected Hitler and made him dictator at once.

Article 48 was an emergency power. Hitler was appointed chancellor in 1933 and built his dictatorship in stages.

Check your understanding

Why did Weimar governments rely on Article 48 after 1930?

  1. The constitution had suspended elections during the economic crisis.
  2. Hitler had already become chancellor and demanded emergency powers.
  3. No party or coalition held a stable Reichstag majority.
Show the answer

No party or coalition held a stable Reichstag majority.

Yes. Emergency decrees let them act without parliament's approval.

Check your understanding

Why did rule by decree after 1930 make it possible for Hitler to become chancellor without a majority?

  1. It let the Reichstag elect Hitler as chancellor by a simple vote of its members.
  2. It moved power to Hindenburg and his advisers, so the president's choice decided who became chancellor.
  3. It made Hitler president, so he could appoint himself as chancellor.
Show the answer

It moved power to Hindenburg and his advisers, so the president's choice decided who became chancellor.

Yes. The president's trust, not a Reichstag majority, became the route to office. Papen used that route for Hitler in January 1933.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • Hitler asks for trust

    Paraphrase of Hitler's radio appeal on behalf of the new Reich government, 1 February 1933, reproduced by GHDI.

  • USHMM, Enabling Act; law translated from Reichsgesetzblatt I, 1933, p141

    Paraphrase of Articles 1-3 of the Enabling Act, promulgated 24 March 1933; text translated from the official law gazette by USHMM.

  • Wels opposes the Act

    Paraphrase of SPD leader Otto Wels' Reichstag speech, 23 March 1933, as reproduced in the German Bundestag historical exhibition, p2.

  • workers' mixed responses

    Paraphrase of a Central Germany report commissioned by the exiled Social Democratic leadership (Sopade), September 1938; published in GHDI.

  • Hitler's confidential memorandum on autarky, August 1936, GHDI

    Paraphrase of the concluding instructions in Hitler's confidential memorandum on autarky, August 1936, published in GHDI.

  • a Nazi election poster, July 1932

    An original poster drawn for these notes in the style of Nazi Party posters for the Reichstag election of 31 July 1932. It is not a copy of a real poster, but its promises match what Nazi posters of that campaign offered unemployed voters.

  • the Enabling Act, March 1933

    Extract from the "Law to remove the distress of people and State" (the Enabling Act), 24 March 1933, signed by President Hindenburg and Chancellor Hitler. English translation of document 2001-PS from Nazi Conspiracy and Aggression, volume IV, published by the US Office of Chief Counsel for Prosecution of Axis Criminality (1946); text from the Avalon Project.

  • the American ambassador reports, 30 June 1934

    Extract from a telegram from William Dodd, US Ambassador in Germany, to the Secretary of State, Berlin, 30 June 1934, 5 p.m., sent on the day the purge began. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1934, volume II, document 194. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the ambassador looks again, 2 July 1934

    Extract from a telegram from Ambassador Dodd to the Secretary of State, Berlin, 2 July 1934, two days later. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1934, volume II, document 197. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the German Foreign Minister explains, July 1934

    Extract from a telegram from Ambassador Dodd to the Secretary of State, Berlin, 6 July 1934, reporting what the German Foreign Minister, Konstantin von Neurath, told him. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1934, volume II, document 199. A US government document in the public domain.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready